"Can Allah create an rock that He can't lift?

Let’s learn "Can Allah create an rock that He can't lift. The most accurate or helpful solution is served by Islam.

There are ten answers to this question.

Best solution

Can Allah create a rock that He can't lift?

If Allah has all the power and can do anything can he create something (e.g. a rock) that he himself can't lift? If the answer was no, it doesn't mean that he is not able to do something which contradicts the view of Islam that Allah can do anything?

Answer:

This is a popular question put forth by Atheists who want to challenge believers. But before trying...

user4456 at Islam Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Other solutions

Can God create a rock so heavy he would be unable to lift it?

I'm just trying to point out a potential problem: -If he can create a rock he can't lift, there is something he is unable to do, which means he is not omnipotent. -If he cannot create that rock, then there is something he is unable to do, which means...

Answer:

What you are asking for is a more a paradoxial type of question. As illogical as trying to answer as...

stuinblu... at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Is this a good answer to the "Could God create a rock that he could not lift" question?

"Yes, but he could also lift it." The thinking behind this is that if god is all powerful, there is nothing he can't do, and this involves operating outside of logic.

Answer:

If God can literally do anything, then he can defy and redefine the rules of logic.

Captain-Michael Kelly at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Could God create a rock so big that He, himself, could not lift it?

Assume he is omnicious and omnipotent. Typical Christian scholar answer: "No, God cannot create something that defies his perfect logic."

Answer:

You are assuming the presence of gravity. Is there gravity where the big guy upstairs lives?

neksute at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

E@(yen)Y$(pounds)Is it possible for God to create a rock too heavy for Him to lift? Because if he is all powerful, then shouldnt he be able to lift all rocks? Or create o?

Answer:

The rock wouldn't exist. Saying that omnipotence requires the ability to do logically impossible things...

Brock J. at ChaCha Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Is the following lost in translation or why is "Could an omnipotent being create a stone so heavy that even he could not lift it?" considered a paradox?

It is argued as follows: â€œIf he could lift the rock, then it seems that the being would not have been omnipotent to begin with in that he would have been incapable of creating a heavy enough stone; if he could not lift the stone, then it...

Answer:

The word "paradox" is used a variety of ways in English. The strong form means something is...

Joshua Engel at Quora Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Possible solution to the "Rock God cannot lift" paradox?

This is just an idea. God can create the rock he cannot lift, but God not being physical creates something that can lift it through his will, but it is not God himself? Just wondering if this makes sense to anyone else, because i find this paradox just...

Answer:

I can answer it myself. God cannot perform logically impossible acts regardless of his status as omnipotent...

Ross at Yahoo! Answers Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

If God is so powerful that he can create heaven and earth how can he also create a rock that he himself cannot lift?

Answer:

I feel stuck in a loop. Maybe he glued the rock to his back?

Vincent C. at ChaCha Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

if god can create anything n do ne thing can he create a rock that even he cant lift

Answer:

I would assume that god could do that if he or she really wanted to.

Anonymous at ChaCha Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

If God can create anything,can he create a rock so big he cant even lift it?

Answer:

Either way God will fail. Either He can make the rock and can't lift it or He can't make a rock that...

ChaCha Mark as irrelevant Marked as irrelevant Undo

Related Q & A:

Why can't I create a screen name?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
How Can I Create an XML to Create a Menu?Best solution by Drupal Answers
Why can't my computer can't detect my external hard drive?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Where can I find chalk rock and boulder clay?Best solution by geosuffolk.co.uk
Why can't I create a myyearbook account?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers

Just Added Q & A:

How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

Got an issue and looking for advice?
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.