What are the simple differences between engines?

What are the differences between a radial and rotary engine (excluding Wankel engines)?

  • I know that in rotatory engines the cylinders spin round and in radial they do not. I was wondering what other differences exist and what advantages and problems this creates.

  • Answer:

    Radial were used in aircraft because they were easier to air cool, as each cylinder was exposed directly to incoming airflow, at least until the mutli-row engines of the 50's. Rotaries took that a step further by spinning the entire engine, so the individual cylinders were exposed to more air as the cylinder spun around the crankshaft. The rotary arrangement created much better cooling, particularly at lower speeds. Having a consistent amount of cooling allowed the engines to be built to tighter tolerances because there was less thermal expansion. Given the metallurgy of the time, consistent cooling also made the engines more reliable. Spinning the entire engine created a number of problems: The spinning mass of the engine acted as a huge gyroscope that had tremendous impact on the plane's ability to maneuver. Any plane using a rotary had a limited ability to turn in one direction, depending on the rotation of the engine. Most of these planes could not make abrupt left turns. Carburetion and lubrication were challenges on an engine that was spinning. Because of this, these engines did not have a throttle - they ran full throttle or not at all. Rather than a throttle the pilot had an button that interrupted the ignition. To reduce power for landing, the engine would be constantly "blipped" - turned on and off. To lubricate these engines, a constant supply of oil was delivered to the cylinders, which slung it into the air in a fine mist. The plane was constantly enveloped in a mist of this oil. To make matters worse, the lubricate used was Castor oil, a natural laxative. Flying behind a rotary had predictable results on the pilots digestive tract.

andrewk at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

radial engines are where the cylinders are placed in a radial like fashion.. Rotary engines are completely different, the pistons are triangular in shape and spin around that way.. one of the big advantages of a rotary engine is the reduction of vibration.

ht Freerider

The rotary engine had the advantage of creating its own cooling, by spinning the cylinder heads around. The admission, ignition and exhaust were all occurring at a specific location in the circle, meaning that the exhaust gases did not need to be collected by piping to be vented away from the top of the cockpit (and thus towards the pilot). The downside were many however: spinning a complete engine block around meant that the heads were subjected to enormous centrifugal action and leaked oil (hence the long scarves the pilots had to clean the goggle), the gyroscopic moment made the aircraft very nimble in one direction but much less when turning in the other, and created strong coupling along different axis due to gyroscopic precession.

Vincent G

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hWZ40120BQ Shows you how a radial works with a stationary engine turning a shaft. A rotary engine of the WWI period, the shaft is stationary and the engine turns around it (the prop is attached to the shaft).

Warbird Pilot

a radial engine was of the type used on early aircraft I.e. the cylinders arranged in a circle around the propeller shaft usually air cooled find pics. of old aircraft to see them

carver

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.