Why did evolution "choose" for plants to be green?
-
I asked my teacher in Biology and she said I should find out. I know why plants are green (chloroplasts in the cells contain chlorophyll a, b and several other pigments that absorb mostly red and purple light, while reflecting green. Hence leaves appear green). I also know not all plants are green, some contain other pigments and are red etc... but MOST plants are green. So why green? It's in the middle of the light spectrum, it's not even the lowest energy colour. Plants have so many adaptions for photosynthesis, so surely reflecting a colour costs the plant valuable light? What evolutionary value is it to the plant to reflect green light? In fact, why reflect any light at all? Why not just absorb all light?
-
Answer:
Because evolution is based on *inheritance*, sometimes the answer is just an arbitrary "choice" in a very early organism, that is widely inherited simply because it works "well enough" to be useful to a wide variety of organisms. That is enough of a reason to be widespread. The thing that gives chlorophyll its green color, is the magnesium ion at the center of its nitrogen ring. It is a kind of organic molecule called a chelate, which consists of a metal ion in a ring of nitrogen, carbon, and oxygen atoms, and bound to a larger organic molecule. (Another example of a chelate is heme, which has an iron ion at its core, instead of magnesium, and when bound to a protein molecule produces hemoglobin ... and the iron ion gives hemoglobin its distinctive red color, instead of green.) [1] There are a number of variations of chlorophyll, but plants contain almost entirely two types, chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b. They vary slightly in their absorption spectrum, but they all have the same basic shape ... they absorb light in the long-wavelength end of the spectrum (the reds), and the short-wavelength end of the spectrum (the violets), but reflect light in the center of the spectrum (the greens). [1] [2] So the question you are asking is ... why plants are not black (absorbing all wavelengths of light, instead of just the long- and short-wavelength light)? There are some advantages to reflecting light at the the short-wavelength (violet) end of the spectrum. Short-wavelength photons have a higher energy level, and are generally harmful to living things. These high-energy photons have just the right wavelength to break chemical bonds in organic molecules ... like RNA and DNA ... which is why unchecked ultraviolet light causes harmful mutations (like cancers). Our atmosphere shields a lot of the most harmful UV light, but pigments that naturally reflect purple, would also act as a natural shield from the more harmful parts of the remaining spectrum. In fact, there is some evidence that the early earth may have been *purple*, rather than green, as micro-organisms would have used retinal, rather than chlorophyll as the basis for converting light energy. [3] Retinal is a form of Vitamin A that forms the basis for the photopigments in the retinas of our eyes. It is a simpler molecule than chlorophyll, but reflects light only at the violet (purple) end of the spectrum. [4] So the chlorophyll-based photosynthesizers may have been latecomers relative to the retinal-based microorganisms ... but survived because they used wavelengths not used by retinal. But because chlorophyll is a more efficient energy converter, the green photosynthesizers just out-competed their purple rivals, and ended up becoming the dominant form of light-converting life. So there may no further advantage than that. Evolution is often about some arbitrary "choice" that spreads simply because it works. The variations, like chlorophyll a and b, can arise by a mutation in the genes that code for chlorophyll, and can both be co-existing without either becoming dominant. But unless there is some significant newcomer with a distinct advantage, life just may never have discovered anything better (even though we can engineer them in the lab). Life does not "engineer" things ('design' them with a particular goal in mind) ... it "discovers" them, and if they work, a LOT of organisms will inherit it. [5] I highly recommend source [3]. The idea of a retinal-based biome is really interesting. ----
Anne9600 at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
Purple bacteria achieved photosynthesis before chlorophyll existed; they do not produce oxygen as a by-product and in fact oxygen is harmful to them. When green plants appeared on earth the oxygen they produced was lethal to most other organisms so giving green plants a huge advantage. Non-green photosynthetic organisms still exist but only occupying odd ecological niches such as brine lakes which, in Africa, are often stained a bright purple..
spiderman
Because... "As the Lord said, Amaranth shall it not be....neither shall be Bisque. Ecru shall it not be, nor shall it be Phlox. Fuchsia is right out!!!" (Chapter 520, Verse 570, The Book of Green)
L_Dopa
green is the most visible color for human eye,followed by red... that`s why the railway and traffic lights are of those colors... probably for animals as well,the most visible color is green... or is it to encourage humans to graze grass? or is the final situation for human species,to graze? ask your teacher...
Nico Nicolai
red denotes hot blue cold green is in the middle, temperate just as earth is in the perfect orbit to sustain life in my opinion colors could've been different, but i think everything would go on the same no matter what color nature chose it's a big picture kind of thing...probly something you find out for yourself
A Town
One day waaaaay back about 12 Billion years ago, there was a fish who was hungry,l and fee up or all the brown algae he was eating, he wanted something more colourful and exotic, but it was late at night, so he thought the feeling might go away in the morning, and he went to bed. The next morning, his hunger for something new had not disappeared and so he decided a venture to the surface world,might bring him what his cravings longed fir him to have. He hopped out or the ocean and found a desolate wasteland, devoid of colour and life. Saddened by this, he walked around for a while, and just when he had given up hope, he noticed a little seed lying in the ground. The fish knew about seeds. He knew if you put them in the ground, they would grow into something beautiful, so he began scooping dirt with his fin until there was a deep enough hole. He dropped the seed in the hole and went back to the sea, vowing to come back the next morning to view its progress. The next morning he came back to the spot, but nothing had grown. He was upset, but decided nit to give up hope, and instead he decided to return everyday until something grew. For days, nothing grew, and just and just as he was about to give up hope, he saw a small stalk protruding from the ground. Elated by this, he began to nurture and tend to this plant until it grew into a beautiful flower. For weeks he came back everyday, watering it, pruning the stray leaves until it grew into the most beautiful flower in all of the land. It had petals of every colour, and the mist perfect leaves ever seen. One day when tending to his flower, he noticed it had some seeds about to disperse. Each seed was in one if the different coloured petals, the seeds the same colour as,their respective petal. He plucked them out and began digging holes to plant them in. He suddenly realised it was getting late, and he quickly tossed the seeds into the hole, forgetting to cover them up. The next morning, he returned and was horrified to see how mistake. All if the holes remained uncovered, but worst of all, only one still had a seed in it. Distressed by his error, he planted the one green seed properly and went away in tears. After only a few days, the stalk had begun ti sprout and his happiness,returned, and he tended to this flower. He tended to it so much, however, that his first flower began to wither from neglect. It was too late before he noticed this, and the flower eventually died. Disgusted by his neglect, he vowed ti never let this happen again, and so he tended to the green flower and all its consequent seeds. Fir the rest of his life he never figured out what happened to those other seeds, but he was happy with the array of green plants that came,from his one seed, he just wished that his garden had more colour, a regret he would have for the rest of his life. And that my friend is why most plants are green, other colours,just developed by natural,selection! (sorry for any spelling errors)
Mike_G
Related Q & A:
- Why is the sky green during a tornado?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why should I choose to have a career in the medical field?Best solution by Server Fault
- Why must we wait 4 hours before we can choose BEST ANSWER?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why did YOU choose to go into the medical field?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why Can't I Choose 'Best Answer' Anymore?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.