What is the best San Diego auto accident attorney?

When does an accident that kills your child become criminal?

  • Last Sunday, here in San Diego, a man was riding his 4 y/o daughter around on the back of his bicycle. At a trolley crossing, (auto arms down, red lights flashing, bells ringing) he wove his way between the arms and was struck by the trolley. He had a broken hip, his daughter died. His wife and a few other family members were there too. Simple accident or criminal negligence? Will he suffer enough or should he be brought up on charges? He still isn't taking full responsibility because he claims the trolley driver didn't honk. There is a debate going on here. There is forum open on Yelp and many people say let him be. http://www.yelp.com/topic/chula-vista-4-yr-old-girl-killed-by-trolley-and-daddy-should-hang

  • Answer:

    If you cross rails when you are obviously not supposed ("auto arms down, red lights flashing, bells ringing") to by foot or otherwise and get hit you are considered a trespasser and liable for all that happens to you, which is what this person did. Obviously he broke the law by crossing at the wrong time, it doesn't matter if the trolley didn't ring or not - he wasn't supposed to be there, it's pretty obvious why this is criminal and not accidental - he violated some pretty basic laws here.

gripper2 at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Sounds like wreckless endangerment to me. The child should have been wearing at least a helmet,and he should not have weaved through there seeing the lights flash,common sense. He took a risk,and it ended in tragedy. Perhaps an example should be made of him.

Timid Women Rarely Make History

That is extremely Negligent. It just depends if the DA feels it is right to file charges or not.

TobiasFunke2

He should be held responsible. The high school student that was charged for killing another student while playing football was held accountable and that was an accident. This jackass deliberately put his child in danger...people should need to take a test be four being allowed to have kids.

Barb

THIS BUM NEEDS TO GO TO JAIL FOR CHILD ENDANGERMENT

Stay BEHIND the yellow line. How many times I gots to tell you.

Hay111

That guy is a dumb***!!! The trolley driver shouldn't have to honk to assert his presence because that's what the flashing lights, ringing bells and auto arms are for! I say it's criminal negligence or at least endangerment of a child. If he's trying to blame it on the trolley driver, I say throw the book at him. However, if he admits that it was a VERY stupid mistake, I think they should let him be.

huntsmaj22

Yes it's criminal negligence...The Auto arms were down, red lights flashing and bells ringing. Those three things tells a person "hey moron, a trolley car is coming." If he wanted to play russian roulette with his own life - that's one thing. He played with the life of a child. Stupid people should not breed.

asking a question

How anyone could be so stupid is beyond me! Criminal Negligence Plain and Simple...How Dare He Take Such a Gamble With His Childs Life!

♥HEARTS 808's KIDDO♥

Criminal neglect and child endangerment. Add Manslaughter to that. Im sure he is suffering, but that doesnt let him off the hook for his actions. In St. Louis last fall there was a story about a baby who suffocated in the back of a car. Mom put the baby in Dads car expecting him to take baby to daycare. There was no communication and Dad didnt look in the backseat to make sure. Dead baby. They were both health care professionals, Dad a surgeon. No charges pressed which I found outrageous. I'll bet if they were poor or middle class they would have been prosecuted and persecuted. I recently read another story about parents leaving their baby in a cab van. Fortunately the cab driver returned the baby to the parents. The Cab driver was facing charges but not the parents. That infuriated me.

TOM CAT

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.