Where can I rent a breast pump?

Does a breast pump get the same amount of milk as breastfeeding?

  • I am a working mom who pumps breast milk during the day for my baby. I've seen a lot of information indicating that using a breast pump is not as efficient as nursing and that many women have to pump multiple times to get enough for one feeding. I pump at least twice as much milk each time as my son eats during each bottle feeding; so I don't think I have a problem with efficiency. When he nurses he usually does a cluster feed (eats for about 10 minutes on one breast and then eats again an hour later on the other breast). I use a Medela pump in style, which is considered a high quality pump. I'm just wondering if I get the same amount of milk in 10-minutes of pumping as my son gets in 10-minutes of breast feeding.

  • Answer:

    It's impossible to say, as you can't measure what your baby is able to get out since you can't see it. I had assumed that what my baby was eating in 15 minutes was the same thing I could pump in that amount of time. I was told that isn't true though. Your baby is a more efficient sucker than even the best pump. Also, your body reacts & releases more milk when a baby is attached than when a machine is. Pretty cool actually. I'm nursing my 4 month old, and I am assuming at this point that my baby is able to get much more out than I pump. I only am able to pump usually 4 oz's at a time at the most, and that's every 3-5 hours. I rarely pump - I used to do it daily the first two months. Now it's only once a week, if that. I am a stay at home mom, so pumping is only done if my baby is sleeping & I feel engorged or need extra milk for some reason. Anyways, my baby is thriving. She is in the 50% for weight and 60% for height. I have to assume she gets more than 4 ozs or less every 3-5 hours or she wouldn't be in that percentile. She also seems satisfied after feedings. At 4 months, she would be eating more than that. So my assumption is that she pulls out more milk than I pump. This was also what I was told from a friend of mine who has nursed both her daughters. For a more professional opinion though, you could contact your local Le Leche League, or local hospital lactation center. I've called mine with a few questions, and they've been really nice!

allinerd... at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

yes, it does, a baby's suction isn't as strong as a pump, your baby just doesn't stop eating, but that's normal

happy camper

The only way to answer that question is to use a scale accurate to about 1 gram and weight the baby before and after feeding. And honestly, I don't suggest you do that. Remember, too, that the amount of milk varies with the time of day, and what and when you last ate and drank. Are you pumping at approximately the same times that the baby would nurse, or are you scheduling according to your work day, because that may make a difference, too. Be grateful that pumping sufficient milk is easy for you. That is not the case for many women, with or without a "high quality" pump.

Ellen

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.