What fish are poisonous?

Help what killed my gold fish?

  • Okay sorry this is sorta long. I really need some help figuring this out. Please only serious answers and please don't be rude. I have had fish tanks before. The last one I had before this one was a 55 gallon fish tank but we were moving to South America so I sold it. Wish I hadn't but then we didn't end up going, only moved somewhere else in the USA. So when a few days over two weeks ago someone gave me 13 goldfish I was delighted to have fish again. They gave them to me in two fish bowls so, the next day my son and I went to Walmart and since I was not cash rich I bought a five gallon tank. I know too small for 13 fish. But my mom wanted some so I was going to take her all but 4 of the fish when I went to pick up my daughter who was visiting her in about three weeks, I figured for short term the fish would be okay in the smaller tank. Better at least then the fish bowl they were given to me in. I set up the fish tank, treated the water and turned everything on to let it run for a day or so before putting the fish in. By the next day there were two fish dead in the fish bowl. Got rid of them and decided that 36 hours would have to be enough for the fish tank to run, I had to get the fish out of the small fish bowls. I put the fish in the tank. With in a day, two more died. I attributed it to the trauma of moving them. But they kept dying, some times a day or so would go by and then another one would die. Until there were only two left. The two biggest ones. The largest of the two died on Thursday, this morning I found the last one dead. He seemed fine this weekend, fine last night.Dead this morning. What happened to all the fish? Why did they die? I used some rocks that are large that I had found but cleaned first before they were put in the tank. No soap was used. I have used those sort of rocks before with no problems. In fact at least one of the rocks was the same one I had used before in our other fish tank. Could the filter have been to strong for them and wore them out? It was the filter that came with the tank. Could it be something I haven't even thought of which is why I am asking on here. Please if you have any ideas I would be very happy to hear them. I want to get some more fish but not until I have figured out what killed these so it won't happen again. Thank you for anything you can offer in helping me figure out this mystery.

  • Answer:

    I would have to point to the ammonia and lack of o2 in the tank added on my the stress of transit that more then likely did them in. For that many goldfish in such a small area the damage may have already been done previously by the person that gave them to you.

Ddvanywa... at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Sorry to hear about your fish, it could have possibly been that you overloaded the filter. When introducing fish to a new tank you have to do it gradually for the filter to cope properly with the amount of fish waste especially for goldfish as they generally are dirty fish. For every new fish you add you have to allow the tank and filter to cycle therefore getting the filter used to the amount of fish waste, I normally wait about 28 days to a month before adding the next fish. Adding too many fish too soon (all at once) will create high ammonia levels from the waste which will poison the fish. Hope this helped. Good luck next time. :)

gina-g

Your fish more then likely died from a mixture of the stress and filth of living in such small spaces. Goldfish are highly dirty fish, and when kept in small bowls/tanks the dirt tends to accumulate, and it will eventually cause all of your fish to become diseased. Do you know what type they were? Because if they were a type, such as comet goldfish, that are often used as feeder fish, they may have been kept in a small and dirty tank from the get-go. Very sorry about your fish. ;(

TaylorBreezy

like all fish, goldfish get stressed when they are cramped in too-small spaces with too many others... that might have killed them. another cause could be that since goldfish usually carry diseases, and since they were so close too each other all the time, one diseased fish could have contaminated all of the goldies... besides that, i can't think of anything sry for your fish

Drowning_Fish

Hmmmm............... really strange............. really mysterious................ Did you ask your son? Sorry couldn't really think of any other cause.

Hi. I'm sorry to hear of your loss-I understand how upsetting this is for you. My first guess is the new fish were carrying a disease , if your Goldfish were in an already weakened by poor water conditions this could have triggered their demise.Best to do a Google search. then research it & also join a forum dealing with that type of fish. Another point to be aware of is tank lighting, this should never be allowed to stay on for more than 8 or 9 hours per day & even that is excessive unless you have real plants growing in your tank. Fish don't need artificial lighting if they have ambient light coming into their tanks from a window so a couple of hours a day for viewing purposes is adequate, a light on constantly deprives the fish of valuable sleep making them listless & lethargic.. There are several other possibilities for your fish dying, I'm going to assume you only have a small tank Do you do regular maintenance like partial water changes & gravel vacuuming, also do you have a filter? If not then poor water conditions may have been the cause, you will need to invest in a test kit for your water parameters to keep an eye on this. Goldfish produce an immense amount of waste compared to many other types of fish so they need large, filtered tanks to keep their living environment clean-otherwise they are simply swimming in their own waste & will suffocate. I would strongly advise you to refer to the attached link regarding Goldfish care if you plan on getting any more [you'll need a separate tank!]-despite what many people believe they are not a particularly easy fish to keep & like any pets for young children we should be prepared to put the hard work in ourselves!! Although some Goldfish are only pennies to buy it's the equipment needed for their care that cost the money, a couple of Goldfish need at least a 20 gallon filtered tank with a fitted lid. Properly care for Fancy Goldfish can live well into their teens, Comet or Common Goldfish can easily live 20+ years & grow over a foot & half long.

Kamila Sz.

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.