When did Brazil get independence?

Should Taiwan try to get independence?

  • I'm doing a research paper on the whether Taiwan should or should not try to get independence. Please provide some pros and cons and possible problems that might occur if Taiwan tries to get independence. Let's try to stray away from "China's never going to allow it" and the internal politics of Taiwan and focus on the goods and bads of independence/non-independence.

  • Answer:

    I'm afraid that you will only get people's political opinions in this forum, as opposed to the hard cold provable facts your teacher is likely looking for.

Pagan Dan at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

It was my understanding that Taiwan is independent. That's what makes China so P.O.d

GUNNY

Yes. The people of Taiwan should seek to be accepted BACK into the UN. There are a few avenues available for this, but the present KMT government in Taiwan is strongly against anything that should lead to independence or in any way suggest that the Taiwanese are not an ethnic group belonging to Mainland China. All reports that I have here suggest that the politicos are severing ties with the USA, and lining their pockets with RMB. It's the sad truth. Congratulations to the CCP; they will at last succeed in defeating their democratic nemesis by paying off Taiwan's leadership, who are willing to sell the Taiwanese back into slavery. This is gross negligence by elected officials, and an example of their self-centered short-sighted personal selfishness. It's truly heartbreaking to see democracy fail in such a miserable way due to a widespread betrayal. To: Li Teng-hui... (The greatest Taiwanese statesmen in the post-WW2 era)... Where are you when we need you?

FED UP TO HERE WITH MAINLANDERS!

Hell yeah. It already has independence; it needs to get recognition from the U.N. to get the official stamp of nation-ness from a table of old men who always defer to whoever has some cash at hand to pay them what to think. Unfortunately, China has had better luck than usual the last few decades of playing the game, and has more cash at hand to compel others to do what it wants. If it doesn't get independance we can look forward to more people getting dragged out of bed in the middle of the night, and getting shot for saying their political opinions. It basically will drag Taiwan's development backwards 60 years to when the KMT army first got exiled and cause instability and destruction across the island. If Taiwan is not allowed to be independent a civil war could quite likely break out across the island and damage all those precious jewels of multinational companies infrastructure. Despite all the rhetoric from China, it is a paper tiger. It has lots of theoretical cash at hand; I predict this advantage will disappear as the recession tides recede and all those who are swimming nude in the water get exposed as the lying liars that they are. The food supply is getting tighter and tighter; China has enough money for the short term; but its own considerable contributions to global warming mean that it should pay the consequences of its actions on its own. Taiwan doesn't need to be dragged down with China into the death spiral that is consuming the middle eastern stability as we type this. Right now, Taiwan IS independant and we can say what ever we wish and travel/trade and have our own foreign policy/police/and agricultural self-sufficiency. China joining Taiwan would rob Taiwan of its food security; Taiwanese would starve instead of Chinese. If Taiwanese want to survive and maintain their own self-stability, food security and voice in the world, they cannot let China bully or buy out their leadership. The troubling trend in Taiwan is that the current party in power, the KMT, is taking money from China to shut up and to try and squash dissent inside the nation of Taiwan. It spends all of its money on trying to build the fiction that Taiwanese culture is Chinese. The truth is that Taiwanese have to make their own, separate distinct cultural identity. Chinese tradition has a part to play in this; but it shouldn't be overstated and made the ONLY culture that is allowed to identify Taiwan. Taiwan needs to create it's own image of a distinct Asian cultural identity that is different than Japan, Korea or China. Just as those all have been shaped by the historical influence of China, so will Taiwan. But that is only a historical influence. China can burn on its own. Taiwan will assist the people of China and help get more survivors; but it won't hand itself over to be used and abused. Edit: Just did some research on Taiwan's food security. It is a bit scary, actually. But Taiwan cannot afford to lose its own voice internationally; handing it over to China will only increase the insecurity.

matt_of_asia

The only reason that they shouldn't is that they would be signing their own death warrant at the hands of the Chinese, and quite possibly it would lead to a bigger conflict drawing in the US (potential world war 3).

Rodney

If Taiwan is not afraid of China bombing her, then Taiwan can go ahead with independence.

Pretty

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.