Differences in and in i adj. and na adji., and te + iru and aru and base conj.?
-
Okay, so this would be my third or fourth japanese grammar question asked. I'm really puzzled on two things. 1. Why do people say the base te of a verb + iru and aru. For example, saying I have eaten - tabete-aru. and to say I am eating eating- tabete-iru. Isn't that equivualent to I eat- taberu (taberimasu) or I ate- tabeta (tabemashita) Why would I say one and not the other? Is the difference what I just explained? ( I eat-taberu vs. I am eating- tabete iru/ I ate- tabeta vs. I have eaten- tabeta aru) 2. Useing a i adjective and adding -kute is equivalent to useing and, except you don't use kute on the last I adjective. samukute (samui) atsui. cold and hot. What do I use for the na adjective? I have the i adjective down already. Any help and awnsers are highly apprecitated. Thank you for your consideration when awnsering if you choose to awnser. If you give setences please translate it too, because I am just a beginner. Thank you!
-
Answer:
I thought you people were native Japanese...C'mon, now you should know this. There is a time where you can use -te aru. It's used with verbs to suggest that a state has been completed. Mado ga shimatte imasu. The window is closed.= Is how we usually say that, Mado ga akete arimasu. The window is opened (implying somebody did it for some reason) Other examples: 1. Asa ni naru to panyasan ha pan wo mise ni narabemasu. Kyou mo oishii pan ga mise ni narande arimasu. Every morning, the baker lines up bread in the bakery window. Today too, lots of good bread is on display at the shop. 2. [pasupooto ha dou shita?] [Kaban no naka ni irete arimasu. Nakusanai you ni, sakki iretan desu.] Where's your passport? It's in my bag (lit. It has been put in my bag) I put it in here a minute ago so I wouldn't lose it. So this is a special usage to given a reason that something is in the state it is. (narande aru, shimete aru.) Note that it is only used with transitive verbs (verbs that can take a direct object.) tabete aru normally wouldn't be said but I bet it can be used, but....it's best just to remember to use te iru. You will rarely if never use the grammar point I was talking about. Wow, you need to slow down and stop asking so many questions. In English, we say "I eat" vs. "I am eating" vs. "I have eaten" vs. "I ate" all of these have different meanings which I hope you understand. Tabete aru is not something you will ever see, and it's not equivalent to the English you think it is. taberu I eat (like a schedule or routine "I eat ice cream every day.") tabeta I ate Mou tabeta ("I've already eaten.") tabete iru I am eating. (like right now) JUST LIKE ENGLISH reg. form present tense--- something that you eat. Making a general statement. Oh? Celery? Yeah, I eat that. When I'm in Japan, I eat lots of sushi. present. continuous: NOW right now I am eating cookies. There are cookie crumbs on my finger as I type because I am doing it NOW. Natto Tabeta koto ga aru? Have you ever eaten- natto-? This is like the past tense, but instead of asking a specific time in the past, it is asking from birth until right now, have you done something. Have you had this experience? Have you seen the new Twilight movie? (Point in time is not important---whether or not you HAVE seen it is important.) When did you see the Twilight movie. (HAVE has disappeared because we are asking about a specific point in time.)
Samantha at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
As Mr. Noh Yoy pointed out, taberimasu doesn't sound right. However, I vaguely remember saying it once or twice in my entire life. Kind of a slip of the tongue. "verb-ta koto aru/arimasuka?" is an equivalent of "Have you ever...?" "tabete aru" is not correct. You always need to add "koto" in between.
1. No such thing as tabete aru. I have eaten = Tabeta koto aru, or just tabeta (I ate). Tabete iru means eating. I eat = taberu (not the same) No such thing as taberimasu. Do you mean tabemasu? tabete imasu? Yes, there's a difference between taberu and tabete iru. One is "I eat", the other is "I am eating." The first usually means the future tense, "I'm going to eat", but can also just mean "I eat". The second means "I am eating" (as in NOW - a process of doing something). For example, Ringo taberu. I'll have an apple. Ringo tabete iru (or abbreviated to tabeteru). I'm eating an apple (now). 2. For na-adjectives, use "de". Kirei de atama ii hito. A beautiful and smart person. Shizuka de benri na heya. A quiet and convenient room.
Eda
Related Q & A:
- How do I remove the base from my LCD TV?Best solution by ehow.com
- What is Te Puke (in New Zealand) like?Best solution by nz.answers.yahoo.com
- Where can I find home-base jobs?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I develop a customer base for selling cars?Best solution by briantracy.com
- HOW DO I TRANSFER NA EMAIL TO MY NOTEPAD?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.