Can I get your opinion of this? Israeli soldiers admit war crimes?
-
Ok, so a few days ago I read this article, and it made my view of Israel worse. So was everything I saw on the news real? Well, what do you think of these witnesses? Here are a few passages from the article: Israeli soldiers admit war crimes "JERUSALEM — Israeli combat soldiers have acknowledged that they forced Palestinian civilians to serve as human shields, needlessly killed unarmed Gazans and improperly used white phosphorus shells to burn down buildings as part of Israel's three-week military offensive in the Gaza Strip last winter. In filmed testimony and written statements released Wednesday, more than two dozen soldiers told an Israeli army veterans' group that military commanders led the fighters into what one described as a "moral Twilight Zone" where almost every Palestinian was seen as a threat. Soldiers described incidents in which Israeli forces killed an unarmed Palestinian carrying a white cloth, an elderly woman carrying a sack, a Gazan riding a motorcycle, and an elderly man with a flashlight, said Breaking the Silence, a group formed by army reservists in 2004. "In urban warfare, everyone is your enemy," said one soldier. "No innocents." "Two soldiers from the Givati brigade who served in Zeitoun told the story of shooting an unarmed civilian without warning him. The elderly man was walking with a flashlight toward a building where Israeli forces were taking cover. The Israeli officer in the house repeatedly ignored requests from other soldiers to fire warning shots as the man approached, the soldiers said. Instead, when he got within 20 yards of the soldiers, the commander ordered snipers to kill the man. The soldiers later confirmed that the man was unarmed." "Breaking the Silence identified other specific instances in which Israeli forces carried out highly questionable practices. According to the soldiers, the Israeli military fired white phosphorus mortars and artillery shells to set suspicious buildings ablaze and destroyed scores of Palestinian homes for questionable reasons. The white phosphorus supplied by the U.S. is supposed to be used to illuminate targets or provide smoke cover for advancing troops. "Phosphorus was used as an igniter, simply making it all go up in flames," one soldier said." "A second soldier-....told Breaking the Silence that at least one officer fired unauthorized white phosphorus mortars because it was "cool."" ""In practical terms, this meant taking a house that is not implicated in any way, that its single sin is the fact that it is situated on top of a hill in the Gaza Strip ," said one soldier." "In the Ezbt Abd Rabbo neighborhood, Israeli combatants said they forced Palestinians to search homes for militants and enter buildings ahead of soldiers in direct violation of an Israeli Supreme Court ruling that bars fighters from using civilians as human shields." "One Palestinian, Castro Abed Rabbo, said Israeli soldiers ordered him to enter buildings to search for militants and booby traps before they sent in a specially trained dog with high-tech detection gear. Two other Palestinian men told McClatchy that Israeli soldiers used them as human shields by forcing them to kneel in a field during a firefight as they exchanged fire with Gaza fighters. "I was down on my knees and they fanned out in a 'V' behind me," Sami Rashid Mohammed, a Fatah-leaning former Palestinian Authority police officer, said in an unpublished interview in February. "It wasn't more than 10 or 15 minutes of shooting, but it was so scary." One of the Israeli soldiers interviewed described the offensive was necessary. "We did what we had to do," he said. "The actual doing was a bit thoughtless. We were allowed to do anything we wanted. Who's to tell us not to?"" ""He said something along the line of 'Don't let morality become an issue; that will come later,'" the soldier said. "He had this strange language: 'Leave the nightmares and horrors that will come up for later — now just shoot.'" "You felt like a child playing around with a magnifying glass, burning up ants," another Israeli soldier said. "A 20-year-old kid should not be doing such things to people. . . . the guys were running a 'Wild West' scene: draw, cock, kill."" This is the article: http://www.arabamericannews.com/news/index.php?mod=article&cat=Palestine&article=2354 Here, I copied and pasted parts of the whole article, please read it and tell me what you think? If this is how the IDF soldiers act, then by all means, the Palestinians have the right to resist this oppression. Or if you'd like a more reliable source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7952603.stm
-
Answer:
My opinion is this is a senseless rant from someone that knows nothing of soldiers or war. Watching on tv doesn't count.
Dead Silent at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
your whole question is just surmising with no factual evidence,its a "he said she said"situation
roostermanforever
I think its a great function of a democracy where newspapers can publish things like when the country erred. The IDF committed injustices in Gaza, and Israeli society won't ignore it. If you posted it in the Israel section to hear a response from "Israel", here is a government link: http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2009/Reaction_to_Breaking_Silence_report_15_Jul_2009.htm I do, however disagree with your conclusion on the basis that resisting oppression far often means resorting to terrorism, which is not justified.
Jon
I'll tell you what,... "israel" is doomed. There will be a reckoning for this world, a great awakening. Unfortunately, the west won't be able to do anything when this is all over except weep in uncontrollable sorrow for their ignorance to what has happened. The Arab and Muslim world will weep, but we will also rejoice, for it will be us who rise up, unite, and end this massacre, this injustice, this genocide against the Arab race.
I don't think we should be a model family living in a model home. - Moshe Dayan. Were fighting people who strap bombs to their children and send them into shopping centers. Trust me, any other country would of done much worse. Israel showed much restraint. I even heard some people say that Israel would of been justified to carpet bomb the whole of Gaza ( not that i agree with that ).
Jim E
''my view of Israel worse'' I don't think think that is possible. Your source ''The Arab American News agency'' is known worldwide as a ''pro'' Israel news agency, any soldier that thinks minor crimes were committed knows were he should go, none have !!!!!!
Shay p
What can anyone say?
Arieh
Since my first visit here at Yahoo, in the Israel Travel section, I have never had the pleasure of reading any answer of any of our Jewish friends, feeling the slightest remorse about all of these war crimes that have been happening in Palestine since 1948. Some of these people say that the jews may have different opinions on that but I am afraid all I have seen here the purest kind of hatred of this race against some unfortunate people that have been living in the Middle East for more than 5000 years (according to Herodotus). I may have my doubts about this sudden "change of heart" of these jewish soldiers. I think that this is a mere trick and nothing more. I also believe that we must not trust any of these people. They are simply using "reverse psychology" to water down down our Gentile feelings against their horrible actions since the first day of their arrival in Palestine. We must never let our guard down towards them my dear friend since they never use the truth even about simple or trivial matters of everyday life. It's actually permissible to do this according to their holiest books, The Talmud and the Protocols of their Elder Rabbis. Greetings
John E
I'm only wondering when someone is going to "break the silence" on "Breaking the Silence". What do I mean? This organization, while touting the fact that it is "breaking the silence" is somewhat silent itself on some other details. Like the identity of the soldiers. And the names of their units. And most details on when and where the incidents occurred. In other words, if these incidents really occurred, let the public have full disclosure. If these incidents did not occur, then the public should also know so they can be "fact checked" and found to be false. Now, some may argue that revealing the names of the soldiers may result in them being harassed. That may be a valid point. But the other details should be released. And their names should be released to the IDF so they can conduct an investigation.
BMCR
that is noting new, Israeli soldiers have been doing these crimes for a very long time that is why you have A LOT OF PEOPLE that don't like Israel
Related Q & A:
- How can I get rid of the "Get IE7 now!" button on the Yahoo Toolbar?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I get an audio alert when I get a new e-mail?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I get Bahrain police clearance and were can I apply for it in Australia?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I get a text alert when I get an email?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- If I get my GED and a degree can I get a good job?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.