The origin of most Palestinians is Jewish?

Tell me PALESTINIANS?

  • It has been about 60 years of Zionist occupation and none of your attempt against them has been successful in either them back to their former place of origin or to make them pack up and leave your country. Have you Palestinians ever given a thought, why is it all so? For past so many months, since I have joined Yahoo! Answers, observing dialogues between the Palestinian Muslims & the Jewish Israelites. It has been my observation that you Palestinians are banking more on the others to help you out instead of fighting a war by yourselves, which was waged on you. Nonetheless, you are asking for help from human beings… what is with you that you do not seek help of God All-mighty? In fact, it would be eyebrow-raising statement in my fellow Muslim world but I care for being honest instead. For those refuting my controversial statement must know that you Palestinians were even betrayed by their beloved leader who accepted the official presence of the...

  • Answer:

    Dear Habib thank you for a great question. If you study our past or contemporary history you will find that we have achieved more than you ever think. Look Habib many nations had lost their nationality in the world: In Europe, Africa, Asia and even the new world. The Palestinian people were subjects to uprooting in the early history of man kind but no nation on this plant of our was able to uproot the people of Palestine. The last attempt to uproot the great people of Palestine was the European colonial system which uprooted many nations all over the world. Here we all have to stand up and salute the people of Palestine for their smart stand against colonialism they stood against the odd when most of the world cave in and yet the Palestinians were fighting colonialism every where in Africa , Asia and South America those nations who are now the best supporters of the Palestine case. Israel and the West kept saying for more than 45 years there is no Palestine and there is no Palestinian people. But they found the Palestinian people every where telling the world we must go home to Palestine by all means and the world must understand there is no world with out viable Palestine. Dear Habib. today thank God most nations including 70% of the Israelis say yes to the people of Palestine and yes to a Palestinian state. But brother Habib we do not want any kind of state we call for a viable Palestinian state even if takes another 100 years we know it is coming. Wouldn't you say we have come a long way and keep in mind we are fighting for peace for Jews, Christians and Muslims. This is the Palestinian massage to all we are blessed by God to fight for peace for all God people in his holy land thank God for that we are going to have peace at last.

Habib at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Beucase the Jewish state was armed from the funds of the richest and most powerful nation in the world and who also gave it nuclear weapons. I will use your logic against you and ask why Isreal, with all the money and weapons it has got from the USA cannot win against a group of people who have nothing and are focred to live in virtual prison camps? EDIT You are free to say whatever you choose. Please do not assume to know where I live.

Marky

How dare you be so bigoted. Palestine has existed for thousands of years, whereas your lot stole land to create Israel, nothing but common thieves. The Palestinians don't have an army or anything in comparison to Israel purely because USA gave Israel all thei hand me downs to create an ally in the middle east. Sit back & realise you are being used for America's gain & as soon as America have had their way with you they will bomb you as well.

Shauna

I am not Palestinian but I can guess some of the answers. I think Palestinians fought with a lot of courage in many occassions, especially in the first and second Intifada. Yes, the opponent is Israel, but in reality it is Israel and US. US is fighting a lot because of the Jewish lobby in the US. So, in reality, it has many relegious - political infleunce in the background. And I would say, we Muslims have a lot to be blamed for letting the Palestinians fight alone. Our attachement to Palestine and Palestinians are not any less than Jews to Israel. Well, it is complex. Arabs really fought back but it was very painful. And decided (silently) since 1973 not to engage in any real war again. I blame many Palestinians for the corruption, internal conflicts on facing the struggle. However, I am sure that it is a matter of time only before they regain unity again. ============= Mr. X: If Israel is looking to live for peace, then why it does not have fixed borders since 1967 at least? Why continue building the settlements? What about the water? It is an old successful strategy. Israel provokes the Palestinian hoping they reply with some deadly way. Then, blame them for violence and practice self-defence by committing massacres. What happened in 2000 was the clear example. Early 2000 was the most peaceful time since 1948. In Sep, 28 Sharon visited the Aqsa mosque with 1500 soldiers in a provoking way. When Palestinians protested the answer was guns. More protests happened and more guns happened. Then, it was even more, there were snipers hunting for Palestinian kids. The whole attitude was a 'provocative' way, till the Intifada became very strong. 2 months later, 2 suicide bombs (the first ones I think in 2 or 3 years). In 2001, 8 suicide bombs, I think more than all suicde bombs in the history. Feb,6 Sharon was elected as a President. Israelis wanted more aggressive leader. Oppps, Sharon is a war criminal. Israel itself dismissed him as a minister of defence because of his deadly massacres in 1982 in Lebanon. There was an international charge against him that never reached court (because of political pressure) So, a war criminal, was okay to take a leading position in the government, and to be the head of the country again????? It is like Iraqis electing Al Zarqawi as president of Iraq.

ameen

Tell me PALESTINIANS? It has been about 60 years of Zionist occupation and none of your attempt against them has been successful in either them back to their former place of origin or to make them pack up and leave your country. Have you Palestinians ever given a thought, why is it all so? Hi Habib: I am trying to understand where you are coming from but I want and need to write you this note, your question is very very much in general. On this website there are many Palestinian supporters, (thanks to God), I have seen maybe 2 Palestinians here. Why? Because 5,000,000 Palestinians live in poverty and cannot have access to the internet. I find that your first statement was very general. And from what I understand you are trying to say that through prayer . Allah will be the answer. All I mean to tell you is that I worked in Nahr El Bared for 3 years and I saw how those Palestinians live. (not only in one camp but throughout) They don't and can't have a voice everyday to discuss their situation. I have seen the MOST religious and peaceful families, that at the end of the day when they can put together 3$ to feed 11 people, and eat adis(lentils) or Mulehaha(mind the spelling), I have seen children cry to their mothers that they are still hungry. Why? because Palestinians are lazy? No , because they are not allowed to work, confined to the camps, but at the end of a meal that really I understand because it left me hungry also. To see them say elhamdollah and then do evening prayer, and thank God for all that he gave that day. And to have tears in my eyes and know that at the very least or most, they have God. and will one day go to Paradise for all of their suffering. So plz do not speak in general and also I thank God that there are so many Good people that feel for the Palestinians who can have a voice and put out the word and let the world hear and understand what's going on is not right. Any human who can stand for another human, when they can't stand for themselves. Bless these humans. I hope you have understood me. Salam. Mimi, Habibti: he said "This is why you say "YOU ARE NOT ANY LESS THAN MUSLIM FANATICS". " to Mr. X and Lando, not to Muslims dear. But I certainly understand ALL of your anger. I'm with you always. It's Fate. Peace.

HopelessZ00

I need an Aspirin!

Stainless Steel

you have it backwards. as long as the palestinians refuse to accept israel, they will suffer. it's a simple as that.

Mr. X

Peace and blessings be upon you. i'm not palestinian ,but it is supposed that we all sisters and brothers. i liked your honesty in offering your point of veiw about this case. But actually ,most of people who belongs to Islam became a west followers now. We left our case and moved behind the west doing as them and left our ethics and our values. We trust that Allah will support the right ,but we need to return to our religion which asked us to unite and help each other.

rona

So you're saying, that Palestinians are not praying enough? Religious Muslims pray 5 times a day, Religious Jews pray 3 times a day. Yet, if Hamas & other "Jihad fighters" wer being diligent at praying... there would be less time to smuggle weapons, and build bombs. So Yes, that would result in a better peace deal for Palestinians. Edit: Habib, these posts are showing how close minded people can get when people give them advice.

Gator

I think I haven't released all my anger yet. Here is another round: Those Arabs who claim that they love us should understand that they are not better than what they call their ‘enemies’ Israelis. Their stupid leaders convinced the Palestinians to leave the land, they attacked the Jews in 1948 and 1967 and they are responsible for the Jews occupying the lands in 1967. They claim they love us and they treat us like animals in their damn countries. They keep the Palestinians in camps, where they are not allowed to build their houses or renovate them. I know most of Palestinians live in houses that have ceiling made of zinc and in winter all the water drift on their heads and fills their rooms and the Arabs don't allow them to fix their houses. They don't provide the Palestinian camps with enough garbage containers so people have to throw the garbage of the ground and keep it accumulated for weeks, which causes many diseases. In Lebanon, there are about 80 jobs that the Palestinians can't have. In Emirates they kick the Palestinian male out of the country once he becomes 18 even if his family lives there. In Iraq, they enter the Palestinian houses, assault women and kidnap men and do all kinds of torturing to them and then kill them for no reason. Just because the Palestinians are Muslim Sunnis, they call us wahhabi. In Syria, they (the previous Syrian president, Hafiz Al Asad) used to kidnap the Palestinians and destroy their houses with tanks. In Jordan, that is full of Palestinians, the previous Jordanian king used to drive on Palestinians with tanks and smash them and destroy their houses. The Egyptians and Jordanians occupied parts of the Palestinian territories. What do you want me to say more than that? I can keep going but I am really tired now. The Palestinians can't live with monsters, they need an independent state. The Palestinians had to leave their homes a long time ago and they left them and because they belong to the Arabic identity, the Arabs have to at least help them find a shelter in their countries. Remember, no work (and here if you want to argue that the lebanese people themselves don't have work, then why do they allow other nationalities to work, do you remember how many Iraqis went to work in lebanon, syrians?, they should allow work and it is all about luck and intelligence at finding job) no ownership, Sewage water !, narrow paths (zawarib), zinc roofs that drift water in winter? How can they fix all these if the lebanese government doesn't allow them to take building matterials to the camp? I think the made some changes to this rule but I am not sure how it is like now. In Emarites, they kick the palestinian when he becomes 18 years old, what do they los if they keep him? They have a lot of money, don't tell me they can't feed them.. And yes western countries DO give citizenships to refugees, when they have them. The problem is not with the citizenship, the problem is with the humilation like not allowing them to work or renovate their homes to prevent rain water from falling on their heads in winter. The problem is with a government like Iraq (and I mean the old government too. During the old governments time (Saddam's time), the palestinians had all their rights just like Iraqis but they didn't have any documents or citizenships. When the old Iraqi government fell, the Palestinians got stuck there and couldn't leave because they didn't have any documents to show on the borders and many of them had to make fake passports to be able to leave and get rid of the new government's evil. Do you know they are killing the Palestinians whereever they find them with no exception? For no reason and they are doing horrible things to them that even animals can't do? These are the Arabs I still haven't finished yet but the problem my exams start tomorrow and I really have to go. I wish you could leave this question open until April 28. I will write two or three pages everyday and then when I finish my exams, I will be really ready to answer. Maybe I will write hundred more pages. This means my answer to your question would be about 200 pages book. Read it in your leisure time or better after you read the quran everyday ok? ((((((Clarification: * I am not from Middle East, am a practicing Muslim, * I do not live in the wrold of make-believe, * I am trying to help you, so don't please take me wrong.))))) Yes sure, it is obvious that you are not from the middle east especially that your name "habib is Arabic" Yes sure you are muslim, I can see that from the level of your errogance Yes you seem to be trying you help. This is why you say "YOU ARE NOT ANY LESS THAN MUSLIM FANATICS". You helped a lot thanks Thanks hopelessZ00 for the clarification. I was actually angry at something else (computer programming) and when I saw this question, I found a way to release my anger. Habib is generalizing too much and being errogant as well. He pretends that all of th palestinians are bad and are not following Islam correctly and have low faith. Yes you may say everything you want about me. I have a very sharp toungue and I can be very rude but for a reason. I pray four times not five but at least I pray. I don't wear Hijab but I never wear revealing clothes. I talk with a lot of boys and have many boy friends but never have any serious relation or had sex with any of them. I am not a "perfect" muslim (there is no perfect muslim) but I am a muslim. I care more about being a good human being than being a good muslim. Peace to only those who want it

Mimi (u can't suspend me)

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.