Does the whizzinator work well?

Why cant Direct Democracy work for the US, its work very well in Switzerland, maybe a Hybrid of the 2 types??

  • People say Direct Democracy does not work because. 1. Direct democracy tends to impose the tyranny of mob rule. Well, so can the present form of Democracy. 2.The problem is the millions of people who do not vote Well, maybe there tired of picking the best devil. So maybe voting should be made compulsory even if the Person voted for "None of the Above". 3.Unfair population advantage to certain areas of the country. Well, this looks like a Math problem to me. All you do is have a Ratio Factor for different regions based on the population region. 4.People cannot vote via Internet because the software is too easy to fraud. I don’t think so, the Internet can be very secure that why people Bank Online, its a good excuse. Well maybe a Hybrid of Both of types. http://www.swissworld.org/dvd_rom/eng/direct_democracy_2004/content/impact/impact.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy#Direct_democracy_in_the_United_States Thx

  • Answer:

    Why doesn't Switzerland adopt Representative Democracy? It works very well in the USA.

_Red_ at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

The Internet to vote? People complain now about the ATM-type voting machines.... I could not even imagine what could of fraud could happen with voting online.

Dina W

If you mean the popular vote, it's not feasible for the U.S. because the bigger states with bigger populations would crush the smaller states; in other words they'd be drowned out through mob rule! I feel the better solution for replacement of the Electoral College would be Proportional Representation, in other words you take however many delegates you get per state win or lose; no winner takes all, it would make presidential candidates work harder to earn your vote and not become too confortable be it Democrat or Republican; which would be a welcome change, if the Voting Rights Act can adhered to and safeguards against fraud can be put in place, this would greatly work; once the GOP at he height of their majority rule blocked a Colorado resolution to institute Proportional Representation, nothing against the Republicans, I'm just against any group of politicians getting too comfortable even the Democrats where my interests lie.

Jorge D

while there is no such thing as a system that can't be abused, our current system would make it impossible for a majority to force Jews into Concentration Camps, as an example, a direct democracy means majority rules, and what if the majority has fallen under the spell of Bill Clinton? a demagogue loves democracy

kapute2

Ozzy said it best... Close the city and tell the people that something's coming to call Death and darkness are rushing forward to take a bite from the wall, oh You've nothing to say They're breaking away If you listen to fools... The mob rules The mob rules

Natesmom

Democrscy doesn't work, full stop. The preasent US Govenrment is a Federal Republic, not a Democracy. All system of Govenment are prone tp tyranny but Democracy assures it. Democracy casts peoples minds on their personal desires and interests, and eventulaly see's the rise of spcial interest groups, and fragmentaiton in society as rival parties band togather to vie for power. The More Democratic the United States becomes, the less free. Even you want to abolish freedom by makign voting compulsory. Freedom is not assured by Democracy, but rather you create a Tyrnany of the masses. Freedom is only secured by just laws and an equitable Govenrment.EVen an absolute monarchy where one man is the law can be free if said man was just, and alloed freedom. The trouble with this is, however, that a single man can eaisly be a tyrant. We need, rather, an external law code, and a mean of keeping any leadership in line. We also need limited Govenment. Not Democracy, as thats all-pervasive Govenrment. We need a Govenrment that merley acts to settle disputes between individuals and that regulates trade and secured the boarders, defendign the people from all threats, both forign and domestic. Then, allow peopel the freedom of choice on how they live their own lives, getting invovled only in matters of public concern and welfare. Democracy is 51% of the populace removing the rights of The other 49%. Democrayc is not viable. Sory this is poorly written, wa sin a hurry and am Dyslxic.

ZAROVE E

The democracy works in U.S. , because from there begun and spread into the world. The democracy that we see in other countries be-sight U.S.are just put their oun democracy to work. There are not two democracy-es the same , even if they have the same ruth, because the states and people are different . Thanks

horia_coman2002

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.