Why can't jews have their OWN land?

Why do the muslims want palestine havent they got enough land in the middle east already?

• i mean the jews were in that area of land thousands of years before the muslims got their they just came over to that area of land and took it from the jews i mean the jews should have the say of who it belongs to not the muslims seeing how the jews where in that area of land first i mean dont the muslims have enough land in the middle east alreadu cant they just allow the jews to have that small area of land to themselves i mean if the muslims did allow the jews to have that area of land the world would be a lot more easier and safer place to live in so i think the palestinian muslims in that land should go and live in saudi arabia,iran,jordan,or iraq and let the jews have that small small area of land because their just being greedy also im not israeli im irish and im not anti muslim i just think that the land their should belong to the jews not the muslims seeing how the jews were in that area of land thousands of years before muslims got there

• Answer:

  Wow, you really don't have a clue. If you are Irish, as you claim then you will have a better understanding of your own History of independence. Just in case you didn't know Israel does exist on the basis that God promised them Arab Land (!) so arguing it's right to exist is kinda pointless. American and European Jews have flooded into this Arab Land calling it Israel and Palestinians got screwed in the deal. That's a matter of fact, so let's not play the feel sorry for me card. Justice demands they be compensated in some manner. Having their own state, without Israeli interference, blockades to food and medicine, able to repair their own buildings (blown by Israeli's) permitted to or build infrastructure. This would be a big step without making it the biggest open prison in the world - as Mandela said. In terms of greediness, you will find Palestinian homes are being demolished daily by new American/European settlers who openly steal their land to make their own homes- why? because God promised them. Will you be so accommodating if they were to come to Ireland tomorrow, bulldozed your home because God promised them your postcode?? Palestinians are poor and becoming poorer because they can’t get jobs. They can’t get access to adequate health care, to education or to employment because of the internal controls imposed by Israel. They need permits from the Israeli authorities to gain access to land and crops, to medical facilities, to schools and universities, and even to visit family and friends. Right now the Israelis are acting very similar to their European persecutors. (if ya know who I mean and I think ya do...)