Where is Waldorf schools in Croatia?

Why aren't public schools simply modeled off of Waldorf schools?

  • Since Waldorf schools inspire growth and children learn and retain more both hands on and intellectually why don't public schools just at least attempt to duplicate the waldorf experience? Is it because of money? Extreme behavior problems or ruined minds of the deprived extreme disaadvantaged? Why?

  • Answer:

    Because Waldorf, although it presents itself as a hands on, arts based academic program, is really a religious evangelistic movement. Everything in Waldorf is designed to lead the child through the different stages of it's founder's Rudolf Steiner's visions of reincarnation. This in no way belongs in a public school, especially when they mislead parents as to what they really are and believe. Additionally Waldorf is so much out of sync with "real world" and state expectations that children who go through their programs are woefully behind academically, as well as out of touch with a good deal of reality and rational educated thought. For example many Waldorf teachers believe that an ancient Babylonian devil called Ahriman is especially present in electronic media such as computers and the Internet. Therefore, all forms of electronic media are banned from Waldorf schools.http://www.openwaldorf.com/anthroposophy.html Since an important component of public education today is technology education, children in Waldorf settings are completely at a loss in this area. Sadly though, technology education is not the only place they are at a loss. They are also behind in reading, writing and math. As far as science and history go, well, although Waldorf educators talk a good talk about integrating the arts into these areas, what they don't tell you is that the actual concepts that the children are being taught.are out of date at best, occultic nonsense at their worse. For example the children are taught that Lemurians, Atlanteans, and Aryans are root-races of humanity. (Lemuria and its existence was a big theory in science 100 years ago, but has since been proven wrong by modern scientific methods. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemuria_%28continent%29#In_popular_culture. Yet since Waldorf teachers believe that Rudorf Steiner had clairvoyant visions about it, it is still taught to children in Waldorf schools today as a complete and irrefutable fact. --------------------------------------… I completely agree with imparting a love of learning, but it doesn't have to be done at the expense of knowledge. (see here for multi-modality, integrated education that doesn't dumb down their curriculum www.montessorianswers.com) Additionally, I have a problem with teaching religion, as well as outdated and inaccurate information in general, but specifically in the public schools. More so, I have a great problem with people lying to parents about their doing so. And just because SOME children catch up at age 11, doesn't mean that most do, especially when they are low income and don't have access to the resources to help them "catch up". All the recent research shows that low income children are behind by age 3 because of their lack of exposure to academic subjects and thinking, (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/education/6740139.stm) keeping them behind, by continuing to not expose them to the things their peers are exposed to, and then expecting them to magically "catch up" at 11 is not only ludicrous, but harmful, both to the child and society in general

Mayah Jenay at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

I had my first child in a Waldorf school. Oh, it was beautiful alright, but he wasn't learning anything academic. Instead he was talking about gnomes living in the woods and black being a "dead color". He was even told that brown was evil! When I went for a parent teacher conference, I was told that his soul wasn't incarnating correctly! The teachers were sure this was my fault. Was I secretly reading to him? Had he seen a TV show? Was I letting him play with plastic toys? Things really hit home when we went to a family reunion and all of his younger cousins could read and write while he couldn't even recognize his name! He could dance in the corner with silk scarves though.Yet when I spoke to his teachers about this, none seemed upset.They told me that childhood was a time of innocence and there was plenty of time for academics when he got older. There wasn't just one thing that was the breaking point, although, everything I mentioned was upsetting, but there was more included, things like having the children pray each morning and afternoon but calling it a "verse" a "verse" that included thanking God and Jesus), asking the gnomes for permission to enter their world, and the fairies to help them sing. Look, you want to believe in gnomes and fairies, that's your business, but don't teach my kid that they really exist and lie to me by calling it "non-sectarian". When we took our child out of Waldorf, it took years for him to catch up to his peers, and that was with a lot of hard work by his teachers, family, and tutors. Don't tell me about some child that "caught up" I know mine wouldn't have without help, and that most people can't afford all the help he needed. Oh, and by the way, all of his peers in Waldorf are either still woefully behind, or needed help to catch up also.

montessoriparent

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.