God is all-powerful, or as theologians put it, “omnipotent”; there is nothing that he cannot do.?
-
This is part of the definition of “God”. Can God create a stone that is so heavy that he cannot lift it? Either he can or he can’t. If God can’t, then he isn’t all-powerful. If God can’t create a stone that he can’t lift, then there is something that he can’t do: create the stone. If God can create a stone that is so heavy that he can’t lift it, though, then he also isn’t all-powerful. If God can create a stone that is so heavy that he can’t lift it, then there’s something that he can’t do: lift that stone. There is, therefore, no way of answering the question above that preserves God’s omnipotence. If there is an omnipotent God, then he neither can nor can’t create a stone so heavy that he cannot lift it. This, though, is absurd; he must be either able or unable to perform this feat. This is the paradox of omnipotence. Many critics of theism have used it to argue that the concept of omnipotence is self-contradictory, that there can be no omnipotent being, and so that God cannot exist
-
Answer:
Do you think this proves anything? Just because you can't conceive of an answer to it hardly makes it a problem from God's point of view. Man is by nature...pretty dumb. We do some dumb things. That's why we are considered the "children" in this relationship and He the Father. Because He has grown out of doing dumb things. Here is a question for you, see if you can answer it. Imagine I am from a world like yours except we have no salt or salty substances. You are stuck in my world forever and your trying to explain to me what it tastes like. Tell me, what does salt taste like using terms I can understand? (Remember you can't refer me to any substance like blood or food since nothing here has salt.) While your trying to answer that question (good luck by the way) you will realize that just because you don't have an answer for something doesn't mean it doesn't exist. That is... unless you stop believing in salt just because you can't answer the question? God Bless.
boring g at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
Some philosophers maintain that the paradox can be resolved if the definition of omnipotence includes Descartes' view that an omnipotent being can do the logically impossible: An omnipotent being can do the logically impossible. The omnipotent being creates a stone which it cannot lift. The omnipotent being then lifts the stone. Presumably, such a being could also make the sum 2 + 2 = 5 become mathematically possible, or could create a square circle. In this case the being's omnipotence is defined by its power to overcome the inherent contradiction of such statements. In the words of Harry Frankfurt, "If an omnipotent being can do what is logically impossible, then he can not only create situations which he cannot handle but also, since he is not bound by the limits of consistency, he can handle situations which he cannot handle."
Dave
The problem here is more with the STONE (at least as you've DEFINED it), than with GOD! Your question SOUNDS like it makes sense because of how it works when I apply it to ME (or any other mere creature). In other words, the statement "I can make an object that is too heavy for ME to lift" makes sense (and of course happens to be true). So it appears like you're doing the same thing if you ask about the statement "God can make an object [instead of 'rock' to make it match the first case] that is too heavy for God to lift." If we say "No, he cannot do that" it creates quite a conundrum -- God cannot do something that *I* can do! But is that really true? Not necessarily. You see, you've been comparing apples and oranges. To say *I* can do something that God cannot do, I would have to say "I can make an object too heavy for GOD to lift." And that is NOT self-evidently true. ----------------- To see that's going on try breaking it down into two statements. The first statement is that of God's omnipotence. In this case it is expressed "If God is all powerful, he can lift any object, no matter how heavy." We'll assume that this is a proper deduction, so that the statement "God can lift any object, no matter how heavy." is true. The second statement is "There is [or 'can be'] an object too heavy for God too lift". Hmmm. Do you see the problem here? It is NOT, as you have assumed, with the idea of God being omnipotent (at least we cannot assume that it is, since we have not yet proved there is a problem with that idea). Rather it is that you have accepted, if only for the sake of argument, the proposition "God IS omnipotent". And from that you get the statement "God can lift anything." In other words, the DEFINITION of God you are using includes "One-who-can-lift-anything....... So if that's your definition of God we should be able to plug it back into your second statement above: "There can be an object to heavy for 'the-One-who-can-lift-anything (no matter how heavy)' to lift." But that, of course, is nonsense. By the definition we've been using we have already SAID that such an object CANNOT exist-- "by definition!" ----------------- If that isn't clear, try this. The statement you started with "God [as omnipotent] can lift any object, no matter how heavy" leads, by simple deduction to another statement. => "there CANNOT be an object too heavy for God to lift" Once you've said that, you cannot, at the SAME time, say "There CAN be an object too heavy for God to lift". You are, quite simply, contradicting yourself." So, however it may appear to you at first (when you haven't spelled out the definitions you are, in fact, using) your statement has no meaning. Going back the original point -- it is hardly a limitation to God's power to say he is "unable" to do something that is a self-contradiction (and therefore meaningless). And nowhere does the Bible make such a sillly claim. ----------------- Note then that the argument for the concept of omnipotence being self-contradictory is NOT supported by the scenario you've been using. Yes, there is a contradiction, but it stems from EQUIVOCATION by those posing the question -- that is, definitions are switched in the middle of the argument (and those definitions contradict each other). The problem, in other words, is with the framing of the QUESTION, not with the concept of omnipotence. There are certainly legitimate grounds for criticizing theism, but to simply "define God away" by such confused used of language is not one of them!
bruhaha
fairy tales
can he burp the alphabet?
cock balls
Ah the paradox of the stone. I love to use this one against door to door Bible humpers.
Death
Apparently he can do everything you can think of and more. He can also resolve paradoxes.
Mephistopheles
He is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent. He is the creator of everything so no there is nothing he cant do. The Bible speaks of it. Ezekial 38:19-21 for example.
A*
God, cannot put the caramel in the caramilk bar. Only Cadbury can do that.
Beeg Juan
Of course I exist ...for not beileving in me you shall be smited !!!! Are you smited yet?? hehe.. well everything with me takes millions of years ..but you'll get whats coming too ya.. hehe
The Almighty Kevin
Related Q & A:
- How To Read Their Eyes Were Watching God Online For Free?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
- When You Say Nothing At All?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why is Javascript called Javascript, if it has nothing to do with Java?Best solution by Stack Overflow
- How come only your fingers and toes get wrinkly in the shower and nothing else does?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Is God Omnipotent? If so?Best solution by Christianity
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.