Fantasy Football Keeper Question? Help Decide?

I would pick Peterson and Manning. Not really that hard of a choice actually. . .

Adrian Peterson is the obvious choice here for your first keeper he's arguably if not arguably the best fantasy player in the league. As for your 2nd pick it would have to be between Calvin Johnson and Peyton Manning, It depends on your draft next year will it be tougher to get a great WR or a great QB. I would think QB because WR is a deep position plus you don't know who is going to throw to Johnson next year it may be Cullpepper again and that might not be a good thing. So to be smart I'd choose the best RB in the game and either the best or 2nd best QB in the league as your keepers AP and Manning.

AP is the no brainer but I think the next 2 to decide would be either Peyton or Calvin. Depending on how your league scores either way won't be a wrong decision. Take Manning to play it safe but take johnson if you would like to gamble.

Peterson, without a doubt. Despite the fact that I'm one of Calvin Johnson's biggest fans since his days at Sandy Creek HS and Georgia Tech, I'd probably keep Manning over CJ. The question I'd ask if I were in your position is: how far has Joseph Addai's stock fallen? If you think he just had a bad season in 2008, Manning becomes slightly more risky; if you think Addai is on the backslide, Manning should be a little more valuable as the Colts would likely be forced to throw more in the red zone. Hope any part of that helps.

AP and TO