With Tom Brady out for the season whos the best QB in fantasy right now?

I have Jay Cutler, he gave me 31 points last week. I also like Romo for his consistency week in and week out. Manning the Elder is also a good one to have, if you have him, albeit his numbers are subpar, but should get better as the season rolls along. I'd avoid Roethlisberger not because he's bad, but because that Pitt offense runs the ball too much, same for Eli Manning and the G-Men.

Sure I love Cutler. He was one of my sleeper picks this year, but I still decided not to grab him. I also think he'll be the best quarterback in the AFC. He blew away the Raiders secondary without Brandon Marshall. And when Baby T.O. came back, he absolutely tore up the Chargers. With that said, I don't think he can produce such great numbers forever. He will be one of the best, top 5 without doubt. I like Tony Romo to be the best producing quarterback however. Tony goes out and throws as many as he wants to throw. He had an early lead against Cleveland, and didn't throw as much because he was on cruise control. Against Philly, he went nuts because it was necessary for him to do so. I'd be surprised to see Romo get less than 3 games with 4+ td's, so long as Witten, TO, Crayton stay healthy. :)

Cutler, who I drafted in the 8th round, and everyone mocked me for drafting... My brother, who drafted Palmer in the 4th ripped me for 2 weeks...

Sadly anybody besides Kyle Orton!

Cutler! He'll be putting on a clinic all season.

Jay Cutler has emerged thus far as a top QB. Of course, you could say that about Eli Manning and Phillip Rivers..THUS FAR. Only a few Qbs have the rare talent to consitency put up huge numbers. Brady, Manning, Romo were the 3 coming in. I think Romo runs such a smooth offense that he will break past manning, and of course Brady is out of the picture. I obvioulsy can't see the rest of your roster, but the QB set you have there is very good (I don't know if you start 1 or 2 QB)...With those QB's, you must have picked a solid group of RB/WR early in the draft. So with only seeing 2 players, my logic is that you have a pretty good team.

I agree and disagree with you....as of now the only person I see is McNabb but in the next couple of weeks I can see Trent Edwards being in that same group. Maybe its the Bills year to win a Superbowl, but they are going to have to win it over the Bucs.

I would say Drew Brees, McNabb, Romo, and Peyton Manning, also I would include Eli Manning.

I would have to go with either Peyton Manning,Donovan Mcnabb,Jay Cutler,Tony Romo, and Drew Brees