Is it possible to have a chemical change without a physical change?

TRUE OR FALSE? is it a physical or chemical change?

  • CHEMICAL CHANGE CAN'T BE OBSERVED WITHOUT CHANGING THE MATERIAL ITSELF... I ANSWERED FALSE. THE "CHEMICAL" WAS UNDERLINED. AND I PUT PHYSICAL CHANGE. BUT RIGHT NOW I THINK I GOT IT WRONG AND I'M THINKING ITS A CHEMICAL CHANGE. WHICH ONE IS RIGHT? IS IT CHEMICAL OR A PHYSICAL CHANGE?

  • Answer:

    with a physical change the material stays the same, just the shape or phase changes but with a chemical change a new substance is formed I think the statement is true.....

lavie at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Yes, a chemical change cannot be observed without changing the material. Such as turning apples to oranges vs cutting apples. Obviously if the apples turn to oranges, they aren't apples anymore. But if you just simply cut it, that's still an apple.

Jessica

Chemical

Miley N

It's a chemical change. Think about it, when you bake a cake it's a chemical change b/c when you take it out of the oven you cannot get it back to it's original state therefore it has changed the material itself.

amanda

it is true... think about it this way: a physical change would be like the color, which is observed. A chemical change would be like the mineral composition...

Jack D

i dont really get what u mean......but i think physical change is like water-steam-water-ice and chemical was somethin like iron-copper (or something) i cant come up with a good one for that but chemical change changes the whole thing, not just appearance but chemical makeup too

Allen

It's true...a chemical change creates a new substance which is observable.

Norrie

Chemical Change Can't be observed Without changing the material I'm struggling to make sense of this. False: it can be observed without changing the material. Iron (grey metal) changes to iron oxide (red, non metal). Can we observe the change? Yes, easily. Did the act of observing change the material (rust)? No, obviously not. Unless this is a translation of a foreign language whomever wrote this needs some serious English lessons. Chemical change is about material change, but so is a physical change. A material is composed of one or more chemicals. Melting ice is a physical change that changes the material (from solid to liquid) but is not considered a chemical change. If you analyze the question posed there is no mention of "Physical Change", so I do not understand why you write about it, especially if it is a true or false question. A "tautology" is some statements which have to be true. Breaking down the question .."change can't be observed without change" - the answer seems pretty obvious doesn't it? But if the question is: Can a chemical change occur WITHOUT visibly changing the material, the answer is yes. I can make a chemical change without observable change. For instance I can bombard a polymer with radiation and break the polymer chains. This happens in airplanes and makes the plastic composites weaker, and it is very hard to find, hard to observe.

odimwitdwon

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.