How do I tell my very strict violin teacher and my strict Asian parents I want to stop violin?
-
My Violin Teacher is a very strict Asian, is a Julliard Graduate, all my lessons end up with him screaming at me. I'm pretty sure he hates me, from his language and attitude towards me. He has made me stay over the summer to practice for this audition, requiring me to stay for 2 hours a day.He makes me stay after class and he humiliates me all the time. My parents keep pushing me to keep practicing. The only reason pushing them is for me to develop discipline. They have paid so much, got so little out of me because i procrastinate and don't do all the work that meets my teachers high standards. (His standards are very high, but I still work at it, but my parents don't seem to notice anything but the failures, which is practically every week. I still get a lot done but not enough to meet him and they don't take it my hard work into consideration.) How would I tell my violin teacher, who hates me, but has done so much for me, and how do I tell my parents that I want to stop.
-
Answer:
By beating them to death with your violin
Miguel at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
I'd start first with your Asian Juilliard Graduate teacher and ask him if he likes music at all, or if he too was a victim of this cultural dynamic, if he is happy with teaching kids instead of playing in a string quartet, orchestra, or as a soloist. Ask him too, if any of those performance goals were ever part of the reason he studied violin, or if he is there because he followed duty rather than any personal interest of his own. Ask him if he went through all that just to please his parents. Ask yourself if you are interested in music or playing music at all, because if it is a matter of discipline, there are dozens of other disciplines you can learn which will be more practical... maths, science, etc. Ask yourself if you are interested in music and perhaps would like to play another instrument instead, including a non-western instrument and non-western music: an interest in wanting to learn how to play the Shakuhachi and traditional classical Japanese music might startle both you and your parents. The orchestras of the western world are rather chock-a-block filled with the accurate, dull and dutiful Asian female violin player, as witnessed in many a western symphony string section. Behind closed doors, they are no glory for the pride of the Japanese or their culture, they are thought of as accurate and dull players who are partially responsible for the current lackluster sound and energy of formerly more dynamic western orchestras. [There, that dirty little politically incorrect yet truthful statement is out.] There are great and passionate Asian players of western classical music, BTW, but almost none of them are those dutiful daughters now sitting in the string sections of many of the west's major orchestras. Dutiful playing is the death of vitality of any kind of music, east or west. You will have to figure out some presentation where you make it clear you understand the value of discipline - there, your parents, Asian or other, are correct - there is much of any part of life, including work we may love to do, which is just grunt-work, unpleasant, not fun. Everyone needs discipline or there would be no continuing with one pursuit, or much success at anything. Best regards.
petr b
If you don't like your teacher so much why don't you just find a new one?
Kalen
ur asian. u will have do learn to like it
That's a shame. As the problems seems to be the teacher not the instrument, why don't you consider switching violin teachers? Or talk personally to your violin teacher and just tell him how you feel (politely!) and say that you enjoy violin and appreciate him, but that lately all the pressure, has made you want to quit. Or you could be a good kid, and just practice more and procrastinate less :) Your choice.
Me
It seems like your problem may be the teacher rather than the violin. I would start by asking your parents if you could take lessons from a different teacher. Explain to them the problem with the teacher and tell them you would like to switch to a different teacher. You can tell them that this treatment is making you want to quit, so you want to try switching teachers in hopes of that desire going away, and tell your parents that a nurturing teacher will get you further on the violin than a Julliard graduate who yells and screams at you. No teacher should treat students that way. You might find that if you get a nicer teacher you no longer want to quit taking lessons. But if your parents won't let you get a new teacher you may want to work a little harder and see if that makes your teacher kinder to you.
Teresa
Related Q & A:
- How should I tell my boyfriend I love him?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I tell how long I've been a member of Yahoo?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
- How do i delete my old profile, but not my account or ID. I just want to make a new profile?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- If I have a subscription to Seventeen and I'm moving out, how do I tell them my address has changed?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I find out the names of my great great grandfather's parents?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.