Do You Know When The First Open-Heart Surgery Was?

How did my 4 year old healthy English Bulldog die after a having a Reproductive Vaginal Hyperplasia Surgery?

  • First of all I want to say that I am devastated by the death of my dog. She was the sweetest and loving dog anyone could ever ask for. I can't believe that she died over something that we choose to have done. This is a common problem english bulldogs have and we managed to hold off for 4 years without having the surgery. All along we have been told this was a very routine surgery where they cut the extra skin around her vagina and sort of tighten it up a bit. She was starting to get a UTI and the vet said if we did not get the surgery it would just keep coming back and could then become a real health concern for our dog Bree. My boyfriend went on the consultation and the vet NEVER said one thing about the dangers of this surgery. I know it sounds odd but he really didn't. He told my boyfriend that it was a very simple surgery and we had nothing to worry about. The consulation was VERY short, so short my boyfriend almost left without paying. He thought it was added in the cost of the surgery and the visit was so short he didn't think he would be getting charge. They charged us $120 for that consulation and NEVER even took the time to explain the dangers especially with having this done on a bulldog. We got the call at around 4pm she was in recovery that the surgery was fine, all went well, she is awake and they have an ice pack on the area. I am still at work at this point. My boyfriend calls me back at 7:45pm to tell me to GET HOME right away,but doesn't say why just something has happened. I speed home to find out that the vet on duty called him to say she went into cardiac arrest can they do whatever is necessary. He said YES please! The same vet calls back 6 mintues later to say she died. I AM BLOWN AWAY! How did this happen? We went there and the vet on staff who was the one to call that said she died, started off by saying how bulldogs have restricted air waves and when you put them under it slows down the breathing and the heart rate. With this, I asked her why did they not monitor her better, why was Bree not on a machine that would have warned them she was dying, why was she just treated like any other breed of dog when they knew the risks. The vet without coming right out and saying YES we screwed up, just agreed with me and kept saying she was so sorry that she doesn't know how this happened. I told her they killed my dog, she never gave me any explanation or try to talk her way out of it and say...well no, we did this,this,this. She agreed with me and I knew that my thoughts were correct. I asked for a copy of my records, a detail description of what took place during and after the surgery, who was working on staff, how many beds are back in recovery room for the staff to look after all at once,etc. She said "okay". She then came back to say she couldn't that she called the vet that performed the surgery and he told her not to do anything that they would prepare something for us tomorrow. I then replied, so that you guys can cover your tracks? She didn't answer me. How likely is it that I am going to get a REAL account of the details surrounding the death of my dog? I'm probably not. I am so discussed, so heart broken, so empty inside, I can't believe this happened to my dog. I know there are risks with any surgery but WHY didn't they come out and say "you have a bulldog here are some the of the problems that may arise from this surgery, this is what we are going to do to make sure that nothing happens to her, but we have to warn you" had they said THAT or anything remotely close to that, we would have thought twice about it and did our own research, picked a vet that specialized in bulldogs or waited like we had done for this long and seen if she got another UTI. I really feel, it was not anything they did during surgery (or atleast I hope not) but the after care is where they dropped the ball and which ultimately killed my best friend. Who knows how long Bree was back there suffering or even just dead. Who knows! I wonder if she wasn't really already dead when they called. The vet said she was not breathing when they found her and that her heart had already stopped. Our lives will never be the same! This dog brought so much joy in our lives I can not believe it. How could one little animal bring me so much joy! I will truely miss her and just want nothing more than her to be right next to me. I have to go today and have her remains taken care of. I will never forget what this dog has done for me! I will miss her!

  • Answer:

    Sue their asses for malpractice

pennie at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Right. First of all l have to say you have all my sympathies in your very sad loss. And for sure there seems to have been a distinct lack of communication between your vet and you as to the possible risks involved in this surgery. However, every single time a dog goes under a general anaesthetic, even given that anaesthesia today has far less risks than ever before, there is still a risk. And a Bulldog is, I'd think, a high risk breed. At the least, this vet should have done every check before putting her under to establish whether or not she was a good candidate for surgery. It's still a sad fact that sometimes the unexpected happens. This is by no means letting these vets off the hook here. This is ghastly. Was she lost while on the table, or afterwards, while in recovery? I can't quite figure this out from your description and it is significant I'd think. What you need to do, after you have sat back and allowed the dust to settle - you are naturally shocked, devastated etc.etc. right now, is find out what channels are open to you in terms of reporting what's happened to the governing body for Vets in your country. You are talking dollars, so I guess you are in the States? Write down everything that has happened, from your side of the story (as you have here). Speak with the relevant people (governing body for vets) and see what they say. You might get 'closed ranks'. Get yourself a good lawyer, one who knows about dogs if possible and can look on this as a malpractice situation. I would caution you that you may have an uphill battle ahead, and you will have, once you have got over the shock, have to decide whether you want to take this further, or not. Whatever you do won't bring your lovely ****** back at the end of the day. I would expect the vet practice NOT to bill you (we sued in the UK over a delayed C.Section (long sad story) that resulted in the loss of over half the litter, and the inability to take another litter from my Champion ****** and the Practice didn't submit a bill for the Section that was eventually performed). You may be able to claim damages ........ whatever you decide to do, I wish you luck, and again, my sympathies.

Lindsay B grow the heck up! as for the main, i am sorry for the loss of your beloved Bree i know you can sue for what they have done. some people are just ignorant. remember for future reference. 1. the longer you leave the need for surgery the more complications. 2. don't agree with a vet if they refuse to tell you the possible complications. it is very common for some dogs to just not wake up not just bulldogs they should have taken better care because it was that breed and they do have very bad breathing problems. renowned for them really i would probably sue for the surgery and the basically from what you said fake consultation. 3. go online and look for possible complications with your breed so this will never happen to you they should have monitored this dog during recovery that means monitoring the breathing because as i said it is fairly common for a dog to go under and not come up more people do need to be aware of this and the older the dog the more risks of this..

I am so sorry for your loss. I would ask your vet what type of anesthesia they used. A bulldog should be put under using ISO, NOT NOT NOT ACE. I cannot stress that enough. Many many bulldogs have died from vets using the wrong anesthesia. Our vet even has a tech sit with the bulldogs until they are fully recovered from the anesthesia and are up, alert and walking around. Also, do you see a bulldog vet? There are numerous vets out there that specialize in bulldogs, you can find a list of them on the Bulldog Club of America website. I would only take ours to a vet on that list. Also, if I were you, I would have a necropsy done so you can know exactly how she died. Again, I am so sorry for your loss.

I truly feel your pain in the loss, I had one of those losses in my best dog I had when I grew up had a surgery to get her fixed. My parents felt that was needed to avoid male dogs marking our yard, her getting pregnant and the male dogs always "visiting"then. I now disagree with that as SOME breeds like her being a black lab and prone to hip displasia made her die at 6 years old then. She had complications from the surgery they said, it worsened as she aged some , ended up anemic and then died. I felt it was tragic to watch her live her days that way, frail and unable to walk out the door to go the bathroom. She had a seizure later on and died the vet claimed when my parents took her there. I feel that this is the worst way for an animal to have lived. The vet SHOULD have told you the risks. If you both didn't hear him say of any then and you are CERTAIN he didn't , I'd file a lawsuit. It won't bring back your dog but can get you some reimbursement for this now. I feel that you should not have been charged such for a consultation. In hopes that you find some comfort in this now, google Rainbow Bridge, read it and find that you are not alone in your grieving. If you want and need to talk further of this I can be reached by email also.

First of all, I am so very sorry for your loss. Truly, I am. It is heartbreaking and I hope, in time, you can be comforted by the memories you have. Unfortunately, bulldogs are exceptionally prone to a myriad of health problems. While most of the time they handle anesthesia and surgery well, it's been my experience that they do have a tougher time than a lot of other breeds making recoveries from it. Anesthesia and surgery presents inherent risks in even the healthiest of dogs. Most certainly you signed some sort of release stating you agreed to the procedure (???). My vet makes me do that every time I go in for even bloodwork to be drawn. The sad truth of the matter is, sometimes dogs die while under anesthesia. It is a risk. It's a relatively low risk, but it's always a risk. Your dog may simply be one of those very sad cases. It is likely that no malpractice was involved and it just happened. Without pursuing a long and protracted legal course of action, you will never know for sure what happened. And even under those circumstances, it may be exceptionally difficult and expensive to find out. At the very least, you can open up a formal inquiry with the local veterinary board and try to get some questions answered. Again, I am so sorry that this happened.

Wow, long post. Why not have a necropsy done?

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.