What is the difference between these 2 Nikon DSLR lenses?

Advice on new lenses for Nikon D80 DSLR?

• Hi, I currently have an Nikon 18-55 mm DX lens and 55-200 mm VR lens for my Nikon D80. Although, I'm generally happy with them, it is sometimes a pain to be exchanging the lenses all the time. Is there a light general purpose lens that could replace both? I say light b/c I did have the 18-200 VR lens and it was just too heavy for me. I mainly enjoy landscapes, although I also like macro work as well. Sounds like I'd still need two lenses for that. What would be a better pair to own for that kind of work on a budget of $1000 for both lenses? Thanks!

• Answer:

  If you don't need the 100-200mm part of the 55-200mm lens that much, then you could consider the 18-105mmVR. Macro work pretty much always calls for a special macro prime lens, or extension tubes - neither will save you some work for switching lenses or mounting the extension tubes. But given that macro work requires a tripod and whatnot, i don't see the issue in a quick lens change there. Or are you looking for an intermediate between these two lenses that is decent for handheld closeups? If so, check out the dirt cheap 28-80mm/3.3-5.6G. I like it a lot on my D90 as a longer-than-standard-zoom, and its close focus limit designed for use on full frame/film combined with the crop factor makes it quite capable for closeups.It's terrible wide open at 28mm, but tack sharp from f/6 on. Here is a sample shot: http://www.flickr.com/photos/jens_wurm/5317898706/in/photostream/lightbox/