Is senator Inhofe right to call for a criminal investigation of the climate scientists?

• Senator Inhofe is asking the Department of Justice to investigate whether there has been research misconduct or criminal actions by the scientists involved, including Dr. Michael Mann of Pennsylvania State University and Dr. James Hansen of Columbia University and the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies. The staff report describes four major issues revealed by the Climategate files and the subsequent revelations: 1.The emails suggest some climate scientists were cooperating to obstruct the release of damaging information and counter-evidence. 2.They suggest scientists were manipulating the data to reach predetermined conclusions. 3.They show some climate scientists colluding to pressure journal editors not to publish work questioning the “consensus.” 4.They show that scientists involved in the report were assuming the role of climate activists attempting to influence public opinion while claiming scientific objectivity. The report notes a number of potential legal issues raised by their Climategate investigation: 1.It suggests scientific misconduct that may violate the Shelby Amendment — requiring open access to the results of government-funded research — and the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) policies on scientific misconduct (which were announced December 12, 2000). 2.It notes the potential for violations of the Federal False Statements and False Claims Acts, which may have both civil and criminal penalties. 3.The report also notes the possibility of there having been an obstruction of Congress in congressional proceeds, which may constitute an obstruction of justice. I'm in the Caribbean, I don't know why my page comes up as UK/Ireland.

• Answer:

  Throw Gore in that mix too.