I want to learn basic Spanish, does it matter whether I learn Latin American or Castillian Spanish?
-
I am travelling to Spain in May and I want to learn some basic Spanish before I go. I'm trying to decide between two Spanish learning software programs, Pimsleur (Latin American Spanish) and Rosetta Stone (Castillian Spanish). My question is, if my goal is to be able to communicate IN SPAIN, should I stick to Rosetta Stone's Castillian Spanish program? As a beginner, will it even matter whether I learn basic Latin American or Castillian? Everyone tells me that Pimsleur is a great program, but my only concern is that the Latin American Spanish it will teach me might not be useful in Spain. Is this a valid concern? Or are the two similar enough for a beginner that it doesn't make a difference?
-
Answer:
Latin American Spanish doesn´t exist, a mexican doesn´t speak like an argentinian or a chilean. Steer clear of Spain´s Spanish cause no one uses vosotros but them, I´d stick to mexican Spanish since they use the tu (not vos) and ustedes(not vosotros) and it´s the most spoken in the US, although we can all understand each other.
DerangedBaboon at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
Latin American Spanish doesn´t exist, a mexican doesn´t speak like an argentinian or a chilean. Steer clear of Spain´s Spanish cause no one uses vosotros but them, I´d stick to mexican Spanish since they use the tu (not vos) and ustedes(not vosotros) and it´s the most spoken in the US, although we can all understand each other.
Kilroy
Castillian is just another name for the Spanish language as spoken in all Spanish speaking countries.There is no real difference in the language as taught in the schools and in print everywhere.Unless you have a great deal of money I would not spent much on expensive courses. Buy a little book -Spanish for travelers.It may have some pictures and It may have a few hundred words.It will have many short sentences.You can not learn very much Spanish in a few weeks.5 words every day would be very good.Good Luck.
Don Verto
they're both spanish, people will understand you in whatever country you go to, there are just some differences which is basically the slang like the difference between the english from the US,England and Australia. The way people from latin america speak for me personally is better and easier to understand, but i'm not saying that spain spanish isn't good or is worse than latin american spanish. They're just a little more proper or posh. I find them harder to understand than someone from say mexico, but not all latin americans speak the same, there are some latin american countries that are hard too understand too so it's not just the spain-spanish. Either way you'll be ok whichever one you decide but if it were me i would go with the latin american spanish. buena suerte! good luck :)
I have used Pimsleur (the audio) and it's actually the Spanish from Columbia which is Castillian. If you are going to Spain, I would learn Castillian though. That's what they speak mainly over there. There isn't a whole lot of difference, but their words are considered more "proper" by Spanish speakers and also a few words are actually different. Ex. el coche vs el carro Both mean car but el coche is Castillian while el carro isn't. See?
Brittany
Dont worry. spanish is the same in latino america and spain. im mexican and i dont have probles to speak in spain.
gorogo
First of all Latin American Spanish and Castilian Spanish do not exist. Castilian and Spanish are the same. Castilian is the proper name for the language but since it was the most widely spoken language when the reunification of Spain it started to be known as Spanish. But there is no difference. In fact, if you check http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/10/Castellano-Espa%C3%B1ol.png you can see that the use of the term Castilian is as common as Spanish among the native speakers to refer to the language. What Rosetta Stone calls Castilian Spanish is what it's called Standard Spanish or Neutral Spanish http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Spanish This is the one taught in journalism schools and you will hear it in movies and tv, and is a combination of different characteristics from the different accents from Central-Northern Spain. But Spain has way too many to think that all spaniards talk like that. Again, it's just a mere formality for the movie and tv industry. You'll find the different andalusian accents quite different from this, for example. About Latin American Spanish.... well, it does not exist either. The Castilian aka Spanish spoken in Argentina is as distant from the one spoken in Mexico than from the one spoken in Madrid.... the Castilian spoken in Venezuela is closer to the one spoken in the Canary Islands (Spain) than to the one spoken in Guatemala. Since Central American movie and tv industry traces its origins to its dependence from the US, it developed on its own way and a standard spanish was established by combining the different accents from all the caribbean. In the case of south america, since both the central america and spain standards became so big, the different south american countries chose one or the other, most of them the central american one since they're industries are more connected to the US Latin Media.
Bertuccio
I'm from Argentina and I understand quite well other Latin American folks as well as people from Spain. We have some differences in accent mainly but not in grammar concepts. Grammar Spanish is the same here or there. Millions of words are the same. Sometimes you can find differences for instance we drive an auto, an automóvil, a carro. Viajamos en colectivo, en bus, en micro. These differences are not to cry. Basically all of us speak the same language. Now I feel much curiosity to get those softwards in order to understand better what do you speak about. But in your case, you're going to travel to Spain, won't you? Then buy a Spain softward. I don't dare to recommand because I never have had one of those in my hands. Don't concern! You just go and learn. It'd be not bad to learn both! At last they have to be the same grammar and more popular sayings.
Sounds_tuned
they're both spanish, people will understand you in whatever country you go to, there are just some differences which is basically the slang like the difference between the english from the US,England and Australia. The way people from latin america speak for me personally is better and easier to understand, but i'm not saying that spain spanish isn't good or is worse than latin american spanish. They're just a little more proper or posh. I find them harder to understand than someone from say mexico, but not all latin americans speak the same, there are some latin american countries that are hard too understand too so it's not just the spain-spanish. Either way you'll be ok whichever one you decide but if it were me i would go with the latin american spanish. buena suerte! good luck :)
Castillian is just another name for the Spanish language as spoken in all Spanish speaking countries.There is no real difference in the language as taught in the schools and in print everywhere.Unless you have a great deal of money I would not spent much on expensive courses. Buy a little book -Spanish for travelers.It may have some pictures and It may have a few hundred words.It will have many short sentences.You can not learn very much Spanish in a few weeks.5 words every day would be very good.Good Luck.
Don Verto
Related Q & A:
- I want to learn to play guitar.Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Can I learn Spanish from listening to Spanish radio?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- I want to learn about Turkey.Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Should I go to college and major in Spanish if I want to learn Spanish?Best solution by louisville.edu
- No I want to learn how to sing, but I'm shy?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.