How many of you celebrate Kwanzaa,and how do you celebrate it?

Do you celebrate holidays that are deemed religious but have no religious connection to them?

  • In my family we celebrate Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas, but not religiously. To us these holidays are about having the family together to eat good food, enjoy each others company and have a good time, we aren't atheistic we just all have our own thoughts towards that area. Now I know there are lots of people who also celebrate like this, but it never occurred to me that to someone who knows me, and doesn't celebrate any of these would think that my choice to celebrate them is connected to religion. It had never been a concern or even a thought until I met my fiance who's mother is a Jehovah's witness, who doesn't celebrate or acknowledge any of these days. So do you celebrate any or all of these, but aren't religious?

  • Answer:

    Christmas, Easter and Hallowe'en were all originally religious festival - Christian ones. If it weren't for those religious roots, you would not have them to celebrate at all. That's a connection to religion. The Jehovah's Witnesses deny these historic festivals because they need to show how much better they are than other Christian denominations. They have, therefore, invented stories about how the other churches have been subverted by paganism and adopted pagan customs. These stories have no basis in fact, but that doesn't stop them spreading around eagerly.

°。♥Imagine♥。° at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

We get together, eat good food, enjoy each others company and have a great time as well. We do not celebrate pagan holidays. In any encyclopedia you can read the origins of these holidays and realize they are all pagan and have NOTHING what so ever to do with Jehovah but with Satan . Have a great day. JW Miami, FL

gonoyo

Humans have ALWAYS taken religious celebrations, renamed them, rededicated them to their own interests and promptly announced them new. The Christian religions did this to Pagan celebrations and the modern day non-religious do this to religious ones. The non-religious (or even the atheists), do exactly as the Catholic church did hundreds of years ago, they take ancient religious celebrations, promptly pronouce them non-religious occassions, change the reason they are doing them and rebaptised the religious celebration "a 21st century securlar family occassion" and while keeping all the trappings (the hot cross buns, the easter eggs, the little baby Jesus or angel on the tree) call it "new" and are stunned and amazed when someone points out the obvious, namely that you are following an ancient religious custom. The understanding is if *I* perform a religious celebration for a different reason, that celebration is instantly purged of all its former religious meaning. If he performs an ancient Buddist ritual as a Jew, does it instantly become Jewish? if she follows a Islamic celebration as a Hindu does it intantly lose its ancient Hindu significance? And if I celebrate a Christian holiday as an atheist does that make it a secular one? After having perfomed and ancient native American raindance around an totem pole, someone can be forgiven for failing to understand it was just for exercise your legs and had nothing to do with the weather. You are shocked because not everyone shares this extremely myopic worldview of history or customs.

26th March 2013 after Sunshine

Humans have ALWAYS taken religious celebrations, renamed them, rededicated them to their own interests and promptly announced them new. The Christian religions did this to Pagan celebrations and the modern day non-religious do this to religious ones. The non-religious (or even the atheists), do exactly as the Catholic church did hundreds of years ago, they take ancient religious celebrations, promptly pronouce them non-religious occassions, change the reason they are doing them and rebaptised the religious celebration "a 21st century securlar family occassion" and while keeping all the trappings (the hot cross buns, the easter eggs, the little baby Jesus or angel on the tree) call it "new" and are stunned and amazed when someone points out the obvious, namely that you are following an ancient religious custom. The understanding is if *I* perform a religious celebration for a different reason, that celebration is instantly purged of all its former religious meaning. If he performs an ancient Buddist ritual as a Jew, does it instantly become Jewish? if she follows a Islamic celebration as a Hindu does it intantly lose its ancient Hindu significance? And if I celebrate a Christian holiday as an atheist does that make it a secular one? After having perfomed and ancient native American raindance around an totem pole, someone can be forgiven for failing to understand it was just for exercise your legs and had nothing to do with the weather. You are shocked because not everyone shares this extremely myopic worldview of history or customs.

SUNSHINE

We get together, eat good food, enjoy each others company and have a great time as well. We do not celebrate pagan holidays. In any encyclopedia you can read the origins of these holidays and realize they are all pagan and have NOTHING what so ever to do with Jehovah but with Satan . Have a great day. JW Miami, FL

gonoyo

Christmas, Easter and Hallowe'en were all originally religious festival - Christian ones. If it weren't for those religious roots, you would not have them to celebrate at all. That's a connection to religion. The Jehovah's Witnesses deny these historic festivals because they need to show how much better they are than other Christian denominations. They have, therefore, invented stories about how the other churches have been subverted by paganism and adopted pagan customs. These stories have no basis in fact, but that doesn't stop them spreading around eagerly.

greensho...

First Jehovah wants us to have a strong family bond but in a way that is approved by Jehovah. Let me give you an example why we dont celebrate holidays and why origin matters. Suppose you found and piece of candy and it was washed and clean looked good to eat but knew the origin of the candy being found in the gutter making it unclean would you partake of it. No i dont think you would. Same as holidays we know the origin of these pagan holidays being unclean so therefore we dont participate in the celebration of them. We get together with our families at i do to just have a meal or talk or laugh and dont need a holiday to do this which makes it to me more special.

farrah

First Jehovah wants us to have a strong family bond but in a way that is approved by Jehovah. Let me give you an example why we dont celebrate holidays and why origin matters. Suppose you found and piece of candy and it was washed and clean looked good to eat but knew the origin of the candy being found in the gutter making it unclean would you partake of it. No i dont think you would. Same as holidays we know the origin of these pagan holidays being unclean so therefore we dont participate in the celebration of them. We get together with our families at i do to just have a meal or talk or laugh and dont need a holiday to do this which makes it to me more special.

farrah

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.