Very inexpensive guitar?
-
Well I'm learning to play guitar, but instead of getting a quality brand beginner acoustic like YAMAHA, my mom, being cheap ordered this $40 one: http://www.amazon.com/Beginner-Acoustic-Carrying-Accessories-Harmonica/dp/B001M4L796 I told her it was pretty cheap for a guitar and probably made out of cheap materials, but she does not listen. She says that since I'm a beginner and I'm just learning, it would be "perfect" for me. She says it can be a good as the higher priced guitars when I learn to play. Imo, it looks like a cheap toy guitar, like First Act. Were not poor trust me, but she just gets me angry when she always buy expensive stuff for herself but cheap crap for me. I haven't gotten the guitar yet, but I'm planning on either sending it back or just keeping it put up. Is this a guitar I can play on at the least or do I need to just hang it up?
-
Answer:
Here's my answer as somebody who's played guitars for the past decade in gigging bands. Feel free to show this to your mother: I'm fully supportive of buying cheap equipment for people who are just getting into music, but $40 is too cheap. Last Christmas one of my cousins bought a guitar very similar to this one for her son. I played around with it as did my father (a better musician than I am). Neither of us could even play it. We'd tune it and within 30 seconds it would be dreadfully out of tune. Even perfectly tuned the intonation on all the notes would be wrong and chords would sound completely out of tune. And it would only get worse the more we strummed and the further out of tune it went. It's not my first experience with $40 guitars. It's not just that they're bad guitars. They're not even playable for a pro, let alone a beginner. Send it back or it'll end up doing nothing more than being a wall ornament. It's very unlikely to be a playable instrument even if you are a pro. Inexpensive playable guitars tend to run between $100-$200 new. You can sometimes find great deals on Craigslist, but I'd stay away from $100 Craigslist guitars. Too often that's somebody trying to get rid of a defective and unplayable guitar. A $200 used guitar is generally going to outplay a $200 new guitar substantially though. Cheap musical gear generally runs at nearly half the price used as it does new. (The expensive stuff is nearly as expensive, sometimes more, than it is new on the other hand). If you want to get your son a guitar that is actually playable, $100 is a bare minimum and even that will have defects so troublesome he won't actually be able to play in a band. Maybe around $200 for a used guitar he'll get something inexpensive that will be quality enough to use for awhile. In music you really do get what you pay for. $40 gets you a wall ornament.
Elias at Yahoo! Answers Visit the source
Other answers
Here's my answer as somebody who's played guitars for the past decade in gigging bands. Feel free to show this to your mother: I'm fully supportive of buying cheap equipment for people who are just getting into music, but $40 is too cheap. Last Christmas one of my cousins bought a guitar very similar to this one for her son. I played around with it as did my father (a better musician than I am). Neither of us could even play it. We'd tune it and within 30 seconds it would be dreadfully out of tune. Even perfectly tuned the intonation on all the notes would be wrong and chords would sound completely out of tune. And it would only get worse the more we strummed and the further out of tune it went. It's not my first experience with $40 guitars. It's not just that they're bad guitars. They're not even playable for a pro, let alone a beginner. Send it back or it'll end up doing nothing more than being a wall ornament. It's very unlikely to be a playable instrument even if you are a pro. Inexpensive playable guitars tend to run between $100-$200 new. You can sometimes find great deals on Craigslist, but I'd stay away from $100 Craigslist guitars. Too often that's somebody trying to get rid of a defective and unplayable guitar. A $200 used guitar is generally going to outplay a $200 new guitar substantially though. Cheap musical gear generally runs at nearly half the price used as it does new. (The expensive stuff is nearly as expensive, sometimes more, than it is new on the other hand). If you want to get your son a guitar that is actually playable, $100 is a bare minimum and even that will have defects so troublesome he won't actually be able to play in a band. Maybe around $200 for a used guitar he'll get something inexpensive that will be quality enough to use for awhile. In music you really do get what you pay for. $40 gets you a wall ornament.
Elias
Your mom bought you a toy shaped like a guitar. It's not even full size so it's a child's toy at that. It's also a classical guitar which is intended for playing classical music. If you're not interested in playing classical music it's the wrong guitar for you. Return the guitar and see if you can get a mom who's smarter and not as cheap. Beginners' guitars cost $150 - $280.
Mikey, just Mikey
I think it's fine for just learning. It's not going to keep you from playing as well or not learning as quickly. Be thankful you have something to learn on, and when/if you get good, you can invest in something nicer. It's a student guitar, and that's what you are -- a student.
jelo
Oh geez read the description: "Remember though, new guitars do require frequent tuning." In other words, this "instrument" is incapable of staying in tune and will be completely worthless for learning music on. The sellers KNOW this and include that line to forestall complaints. Your mother needs to understand that trying to save money buying a cheap instrument is actually wasting money; that is $40 down the drain for an instrument that will not get played. If you have a guitar teacher, have him or her make a recommendation to your mother. NO guitar teacher would recommend the thing in your link. www.rondomusic.com sells cheap instruments that are at least really instruments. You might try one of theirs, their acoustics start around $70. I haven't played one and can't vouch for quality, their SX basses are not bad. Generally, though, a decent starter guitar would be in the $100-200 range. If she's concerned about the expense, consider taking up bassoon, or harp... that will teach someone to appreciate how cheap guitars are, even decent ones.
Jonathan
Your mom bought you a toy shaped like a guitar. It's not even full size so it's a child's toy at that. It's also a classical guitar which is intended for playing classical music. If you're not interested in playing classical music it's the wrong guitar for you. Return the guitar and see if you can get a mom who's smarter and not as cheap. Beginners' guitars cost $150 - $280.
Mikey, just Mikey
Oh geez read the description: "Remember though, new guitars do require frequent tuning." In other words, this "instrument" is incapable of staying in tune and will be completely worthless for learning music on. The sellers KNOW this and include that line to forestall complaints. Your mother needs to understand that trying to save money buying a cheap instrument is actually wasting money; that is $40 down the drain for an instrument that will not get played. If you have a guitar teacher, have him or her make a recommendation to your mother. NO guitar teacher would recommend the thing in your link. www.rondomusic.com sells cheap instruments that are at least really instruments. You might try one of theirs, their acoustics start around $70. I haven't played one and can't vouch for quality, their SX basses are not bad. Generally, though, a decent starter guitar would be in the $100-200 range. If she's concerned about the expense, consider taking up bassoon, or harp... that will teach someone to appreciate how cheap guitars are, even decent ones.
Jonathan
I think it's fine for just learning. It's not going to keep you from playing as well or not learning as quickly. Be thankful you have something to learn on, and when/if you get good, you can invest in something nicer. It's a student guitar, and that's what you are -- a student.
jelo
Related Q & A:
- What are some inexpensive hotels in Florence?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Which is easier to learn jazz bass guitar or jazz guitar?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
- What is a good electric guitar for beginning guitar player?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Which guitar hero/rock band titles does the WarBeast guitar work with?Best solution by Arqade
- Lap Slide Guitar vs Conventional Slide Guitar. What is the difference?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.