What does cause an increase of insulin?

On a low carb diet, my blood glucose levels go up when eating few carbs and little protein. Does this show that my insulin response is low and that a low carb diet protects me from an increase in insulin resistance?

  • Quora didn't allow me to ask the whole question so let me explain. I've used low carb dieting for a decade to keep off ~50 pounds and avoid type 2 diabetes, which both of my siblings had at a much younger age than I currently am (51). Since I've noticed that my blood sugar elevates to prediabetes level (100-125) on low carb while consuming almost no carbs and adequate protein (to avoid excess gluconeogenesis), it seems to me that one explanation might be that my insulin response is reduced. When I cheat and eat carbs after a carb fast, however, I find it sometimes lower (in the 80s). This got me thinking that perhaps my blood glucose level is finding it's natural level on low carb and the introduction of carbs - and the attendant insulin response - pushes down the blood glucose level because I have better insulin response. It leads me to conclude that measuring blood glucose alone might not be enough in low carb individuals because there is no measure of insulin. While high blood glucose is bad, so is high insulin. So the question is (if my assumptions aren't completely off-base): is a slight elevation of blood glucose better than chronic hyperinsulinemia?

  • Answer:

    Hi Ethan, I see from your comment elsewhere that you have been on low-carb for a decade; you might consider putting your comment into the question details as they do provide important, relevant context.  In any case, I highly suggest that you give the following a read as it addresses exactly the issue that you are pondering: http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2007/10/physiological-insulin-resistance.html In short, people on long-term low-carb diets can expect the following: fasting blood glucose trending up into the prediabetic range "failing" abrupt oral glucose tolerance tests mild reactive hypoglycaemia on abrupt introduction of large carb intakes In a long-term low-carb individual, these are all normal, expected, and not indicative of a pathological condition, even though they would otherwise be considered alarming in a typical high-carb individual. As a long-term low-carber, the more useful marker would be the HbA1c test.  I suspect that if you do one you will find yourself at or below 5%, well into the "Normal" range or better in terms of diabetes diagnostic criteria.

Gary Wu at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Insulin resistance means you need more insulin to process the same amount of glucose to obtain the same effect (usually translated as your blood sugar level going down to the same level). Nothing in your question suggests this, it maybe even is suggestive of you developing insulin resistance. These interventions have been proven to lower insulin resistance: physical exercise independent of weight loss losing weight most probably the use of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metformin

Liang-Hai Sie

Without being able to compare what happens to your blood glucose on a HIGH carb diet, I have no way to respond to your question.  Low carb ways of eating can protect susceptible people from advancing into full-blown Type II diabetes, IMO.  As a lay person, I also tend to believe that if you don't eat high carbs, one may never experience the effects of Type II diabetes, even if you actually "have" it.  The model, IMO, appears to be similar to that of alcoholism.  You HAVE alcoholism forever, once you have it, but if you don't drink alcohol, you will not have to experience the effects of alcoholism except in a few rare conditions.  (You may respond to some pain killing medications differently than non-alcoholic people.)

Karen Tiede

Gary Wu has an excellent answer and I agree that the HbA1c test would be much more revealing. As a long-term low-carber, the more useful marker would be the HbA1c test.  I suspect that if you do one you will find yourself at or below 5%, well into the "Normal" range or better in terms of diabetes diagnostic criteria.

Gary Kohl

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.