How comparable is the Arduino circuit board to actual circuit boards?
-
I just got an Arduino Starter Kit like a week ago. Does Arduino dramatically simplify the process, or not really? I guess my question is if am I actually learning about electronics, or am I learning the super dumbed-down version? In a similar vein, could I use the Arduino sensors like the analog heat sensor with another circuit board just as easily? Would the LED lights involve the same process of setup?
-
Answer:
First, it is not very meaningful to talk in terms of "circuit boards". Arduino consists of a microcontroller mounted on a circuit board which includes a power regulator, some input/output pins of various types and a switch and LED. The item that does most of the work is the microcontroller. So the comparison should be between using the microcontroller and development environment offered by Arduino or some other microcontroller. The answer there is that programming the Arduino is somewhat "dumbed down" but don't let that stop you. The fundamentals are generally the same. As for things you connect to the Arduino (lights motors, sensors etc) well those behave the same no matter what they are connected to. Personally I think that Arduino allows you to quickly get familiar with the basics of electronics. It is a useful step on the way to mastering them. Starting off on a harder environment doesn't make you learn any faster. In fact if it is too hard it could be discouraging and disappointing.
Jack Dahlgren at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
First, let me give you an idea as to what an Arduino actually is. Arduino is just another Atmega development board. You can find many other circuits like Arduino aimed at the exact same market. What makes Arduino so successful is that it is open source and it has a lot of community support. An Arduino consists of a microcontroller (which is basically a very compact computer, an Atmega328, in your case), all the circuits required to run it (like a power regulator, a USB to Serial Convertor chip) and a software package (i.e. the notepad like GUI and all the libraries). "Actual circuit boards" can be of many types. Some can be purely analog (like amplifiers for your speakers) or hardwired digital (like some remote controls or old washing machine controllers, but mostly old stuff) or some may have small computers similar to ones found in your Arduino. The circuits which have microcontrollers are categorized as embedded systems. When an engineer designs an embedded system, he will first try out his design on a ready made "development boards". These boards are similar to your Arduinos, except mostly, they are not Arduinos. This is proof that his concept works. After testing his idea and he moves to production level design. Here, he will design all the circuit to the exact specifications. E.g. he may shrink it, make it more robust, make it cheaper etc. So, basically when you use an Arduino, you can, at max, build a prototype. Since you are just starting, Arduinos are fine. But, I would suggest that you don't stick to them for a long time, because they are a bit dumbed-down. The Arduino IDE has built-in (and downloadable) functions to implement most of your code for you. So, you miss out on many key concepts. However, I would suggest that you take a look at this site: http://www.javiervalcarce.eu/wiki/Program_Arduino_with_AVR-GCC As for Adruino Sensor, to tell you the truth, most of these sensors exsisted even before Arduinos were conceived. They are just repackaged are "Arduino Sensors" by eager sellers who want to hop on the Arduino Bandwagon.
Ajinkya Kamat
Thanks for the A2A scott..... coming to your question, "The aim of aurdino team is to make a device that is technically simple and accessible to a large group of people with diverse technical backgrounds." yes, you are right. Arduino simplifies the process a lot. But,if you are actually trying to learn electronics,no that is not the way how you learn electronics........ Aurdino is for some one 1.)who wants to build something in electronics but don't have an idea of how things work inside actually, but is in badly need of a device which he needs to do a particular work. (or) 2.)wants to build something instantly with electronics and enjoy the excitement that comes on seeing the device work. But,contrary to the above 2 points,if you are a beginner, it boosts up your confidence a lot and gives you enough confidence to kick off with understanding of electronics........... what you are learning is application, and yes that will be enough if you want to just make things work. But,if you want to understand why they work atleast in the superficial level, you can't do that with aurdino(i've never used aurdino but being an electronics student myself and an active IEEE member i learned from others and internet how largely it simplifies things.......) so,that concludes it scott. Do all the things possible with your aurdino board and then after getting a lot of confidence move on to some real elcetronics by checking out blogs and some sites....like circuits today,electronics for you and there are many other things for micro controllers specially. I don't have an answer for your second question right now. But,if possible i ill consult with my pals who used to work with aurdino and tell you........ Have a nice day.......
Vinay Kumar Reddy Yerram
Related Q & A:
- How To Knit With A Knitting Board?Best solution by youtube.com
- How to detect compatibility mode in IE and actual version?Best solution by social.msdn.microsoft.com
- How do I change my avatar to an actual picture of myself?Best solution by Meta Stack Overflow
- How do I get a waitress job without actual experience?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How do I insert a picture into an actual mail message?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.