Can we make biology courses interesting using biologically-inspired computing?
-
Biology courses tend to be boring with mostly uninspired memorization. Maybe adding biologically-inspired computing to biology courses can make them more interesting? For example, evolution can be a rather boring subject but learn and use genetic programming and then it's much more exciting. As another example, the immune system can be boring as well, but learn and see how similar concepts can make computers more secure and it becomes a more interesting topic. More here on biologically inspired computing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bio-inspired_computing
-
Answer:
First, biology courses are generally not boring to people who actually like biology. So I'm assuming we're limiting our thinking to introductory biology courses. In those classes, you could certainly discuss bio-inspired computing as an application of the principles of biology, and you could do some of it in a course lab. I said "a" course lab, as in one session, because intro classes are supposed to teach the breadth of the subject, and there are a lot of other kinds of experiments and techniques to go through, as well. Here is something very important to remember: the current state of knowledge about the human body is often inadequate to accurately predict its responses, including via modeling. Certainly not always inadequate, but think of the number of cancer drugs that fail. It's because we're often uncovering additional parts of a mechanism we don't completely understand. We are not at the point where an in silico finding can be taken as gospel. It generally has to be replicated in the living organism. This means that biologically-inspired computing by definition will not give students a sense of how fundamental discoveries in the life sciences are made, which is generally through careful in vitro and in vivo experiments. Don't get me wrong, your approach sounds like a good way to get computer scientists more interested in life sciences--but that's not really what you asked. Bear in mind, as a biologist/bioengineer, the fact that the concepts underlying the immune system can make computers more secure does not fill me with passionate interest, whereas I do think immune responses to medical implants are pretty cool. Your mileage with others may vary.
Liz Altmaier at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
YES! I definitely think you can! In fact, I took courses with John Holland ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Henry_Holland ) and Mark Newman (noted Complex Networks theorist) during my undergrad days at the University of Michigan and they had a lot of these elements. Complex Systems and Complex Adaptive Systems studies in general I think are a great way to fuse things like biologically-inspired computing with computer science: Graph Theory and Complex Networks, with studies of predator-prey networks and ecological networks DNA substring/subsequence matching Neural Networks - A great crossover point for AI/ML and neuroscience The genetic algorithm. Inspired by evolution, so it's an obvious crossover point between the fields (pun very much intended). Motion of insects, like ants and bees, using simulations and models (See: SimAnt) Conway's Game of Life.
Vaibhav Mallya
At my institution at least, quite a lot of effort is being put into integrating more applied computing concepts into wider life science course material. Whilst I'm enrolled on a specific bioinformatics degree programme, most of the lectures I attend are with people who are studying other programmes. In a recent lecture we were introduced to the workings of BLAST and scoring matrices in what I thought was a suitably abstracted and easy to follow way. While a number of people, myself included, found it fascinating, the general attitude of the room was not positive. A later unit satisfaction survey revealed that many people found the content of this particular lecturer 'too hard' or 'confusing'. I may be somewhat biased, but I had little knowledge of the subject prior to the lecture and found it relatively straightforward to follow. Unfortunately, inclusion of almost any computing material in a lecture setting tends to elicit a similar response. In this country at least, it seems that alarmingly few biology undergraduates possess any kind interest in computing. I've discussed this topic with my course director and he believes that it is largely the fault of the British secondary education system, which tends stream those with mathematics and computer science interests away from life sciences at quite an early stage. As such, I imagine that the intersection of students with interests in biology and computing is very small. The USA does seem to do a better job of this, and I suspect that American undergraduates would more readily learn computing concepts in a biological context. I think that concepts of biologically inspired computing will have to be introduced in carefully and cleverly abstracted ways so as not to turn off the majority of students. As soon as code gets mentioned, most people stop listening. It's always going to be difficult to make string searching algorithms sexy, but I think that most of the subject areas Vaibhav Mallya mentioned could be taught in a visual and engaging way.
Bede Constantinides
As pointed out below this is not related to bio inspired computing but more to how biology courses can be made engaging for computing and engineering students : This Systems Biology course by Uri Alon (search 'uri alon systems biology' on youtube : -- an expert and a physics PhD who is now an authority on systems biology seems to be of interest to physicists, computer scientists and engineers. I havent seen the full video (or the other videos of this course) myself but it may be relevant to the question because his goal seems to be to present a mathematical/engineering/computing perspective and abstractions of biological mechanisms.
Rakesh Barve
Related Q & A:
- Is it possible to make life-size mannequins using paper mache?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I make money at home using my computer without doing any type of multi-level marketing?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How do I make my poster interesting?Best solution by evergreen.edu
- How to edit video to make it more interesting?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I make my job more interesting?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.