If a group of the smartest people were transported to the stone age, how long would it take to rebuild to our level of modern technology, e.x., the large hallidron collider?
-
You can pick your own geography, the number of people and their skills. The technology I was going to pick was the Atom bomb, but the obvious answer is that hopefully they're smart enough to not remake that.
-
Answer:
This idea has been examined in the sci-fi/alternate universe series, the "Nantucket series", by S.M. Stirling (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nantucket_series). In that book the island of Nantucket is thrown back in time to 1250 BC. But, as for rebuilding society from just the knowledge in people (no books or tools sent with the time travelers), there would be an inevitable "dark age" for these people as they lost knowledge with secondary generations. From there, I would just assume that the rebuild time would be about the same as the real world. So, how much knowledge would be lost? First thing these people have to do is feed themselves. And that will be the most likely to kill off this project before it even gets started. The Hunter-Gatherer way of life requires a diffuse population. Even with knowledge of agriculture and survival techniques, it could be a year of H/G lifestyle before enough seed stock was gathered to even begin farming. And another year before that becomes the new way of regularly feeding the modern-day tribe. By then you will have undoubtedly lost people from the project. Further, there are many, many developments we depend on today that took generations of breeding or development to gain benefit from. Domesticated animals have to be bred from wild stock. Plants have to be "bred" as well. It would be generations until wheat produced modern yields, and much the same for any other crop. So, once the H/G period is overcome and subsistence farming is developed (with its initial very low yield) and a capture and breeding program is started, all you have to do now is keep from losing the skills and knowledge you brought back with you while spending all day working on food production. Once you hit the farmer stage, you can probably support some people as teachers for the children that will be coming. Now it becoomes a matter of which skills can be taught and maintained without the tools of the trade to practice them. I agree with that the first generation might get to Iron Age technology within their lifetime. But there will be little chance for the parents to pass on technology from the modern era. Perhaps their descendants will make it to Chinese or Arabic-style Middle Ages, but I can't see how it would be possible to have the initial population's entire body of knowledge passed on perfectly without tools of the trade. So, most likely, this experiment would just fail with survivors returning to Stone Age technology as they spread out in the H/G lifestyle and lost members before agriculture became self-sufficient. Possibly they could regather as a set of villages and set up schools. But there is no chance of 100% knowledge transfer to a younger generation because farming is too labor intensive (especially without modern crops!) and there are no tools of advance technology which will be required to learn some sciences. (Imagine biology without microscopes, chemistry without exact scales.) At some point, probably Iron Age technology, the children are essentially making it up on their own, same as the real timeline did.
Todd Gardiner at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
They wouldn't be able to accomplish it in their lifetimes, or their childrens' lifetimes, and after that, things could break down very quickly. If there were enough smart people to get a self-sustaining society going (and I think this would be a big numberâsay, 50,000) with a diverse set of skills useful for reconstructing modern society, I could imagine that they'd get up to a Roman level of technology during their lifetimes, or their childrens'. But of course, after Rome came the dark ages. There's no reason to think that this group would go through exactly the same reversal, but there's no reason to think that somewhere along the way they wouldn't lose much of what they had built due to disease, outside invasion, some kind of internal religious fervor, whatever. The continuity of knowledge and the cultural drive to keep expanding knowledge would be the keys. Once human society got out of the dark ages, things started expanding very rapidly with the renaissance and the industrial revolution. If there were a continuity of knowledge, this group could skip the whole "let's invent the scientific method" step and jump straight into the industrial revolution, which has probably been proceeding as fast as possible, if not faster. So, say, 400-500 years if there were no reversals, but that's a big if.
Adam Rice
Most of the answers here fail to take inte account the energy wasted in maintaining a population density. Depending on the size of the group agriculture might not be needed at all. Most hunter-gatherers worked somewhere between 12 to18 hours per week, leaving plenty of time to engage in other activites such as mining, refining, smithing, masonry etc. Efficient toolmaking with iron tools might even decrease the time spent foraging and hunting even more. So if the group is small enough to be supported by a given area (food has to be transported towards the main population without spoiling) there would be less of a die off. And when I say small enough this is still a sufficient population density to have a small city since the transition to city life happened BEFORE agriculture. (Not really surprising, you need a permanent residence, as well as a notion of private ownership before starting to plant stuff into the ground for you to harvest a season later). This if the land transported to is abundant enough of course as for instance the Levant during the paleothic. But my guess is that most subtropical climates would do fine. Temperate regions with harsh winters would be much tougher since its hard to store food for months. So instead of trying to resolve the question into how many would die before agriculture we could start by how many would die before aquiring sufficient survival skills to life comfortably as hunter-gatherers. Once that skillset is aquired and the population lives in an Eden of abundance, with breath-taking beauty, easy work hours and communal life providing plenty of social stimulus why on earth rush for the office cubicle?
Pierre-Emil Chantereau
It depends on what they had with them. If there were no repositories of knowledge (e.g. books) and no tools at all it would take an extremely long time if ever. To put much of our current knowledge into practice demands a sophisticated web of precision production and logistics so a lot of knowledge alone would be fairly useless other than as a general guide. Ironically, stone age skills such as the ability to find edible roots would be more immediately valuable. Better hope the survivors aren't just intelligent - special forces training would be helpful.
Pete Griffiths
Related Q & A:
- How long does it take for a sprained ankle to heal?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How long does it take to become a paralegal?Best solution by legal.education
- Is child crying going to a NEW school ok? how long does it take to stop crying after starting a new school?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How long does it take to do a research on a particular animal's behaviour?Best solution by nuffieldfoundation.org
- How long does it take for an orange seed to grow from when it is a seed to when it is a tree?Best solution by wiki.answers.com
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.