Is it good to take revenge(prove myself, show him that I am capable of more than what he thinks) or be with him as a friend (and just smile and talk from face, not from heart) who talked bad about me? What would you do if you were me?
-
Here goes the story. I am myself Anna. My batch mate is Vinu. Anna and Vinu are studying in under grad school. My batch mate Vinu's close friend is David. David is one year senior to Anna and Vinu. David is a good friend, who use to help everyone, provide free advice and at times we feel that he is poking his nose too much into our jobs in the name of help. Anna was suffering to complete his courses and about to fail his under grad. David flew from another city and talked to Anna & Vinu and other group of friends, and suggested that Vinu should help Anna. With Vinu's help Anna graduated. Anna was looking for job and looking for a place to stay and start his job hunt. David said that Anna can stay in David's place. But Anna didn't make use of the help as he got job immediately. Few months later, Anna lost his job. This time, Anna asked David to forward his resume to David's friend. Accidentally Anna heard David saying "Anna is not worth of studying in X university. He doesn't deserve to get into those companies for which he is asking me to refer" through Skype chat. Anna didn't continue to listen as he felt that it may be kind of eavesdropping, but I am sure David and his friends (including Vinu would have continued to talk more bad about me). But next day, David smiled and said that Anna can stay in his place(second time) and look for job hunt. But didn't reply anything about forwarding the resume. But Anna got job and didn't make use of David's help(either staying in David's home or forwarding his resume). Now 1) What would you do if you were Anna? 2) Should I a) prove myself that I am capable of studying in X university and I am capable of joining the company that I was looking for (or) b) become David's friend(just say Hi-Bye friends) (or) c) be a good true friend(not as faking friends). 3) Should Anna later(after proving that he is capable of) say that he had heard what David was saying bad about him the other day? Please help me. I am confused and I can digest what he said about me.
-
Answer:
Hi Anna, For (1) I would confront David and Venu - if i believe he is also having similar thoughts. Mention that you listened to the talk and wanted to have a discussion about it because you were upset with it. A friend would totally understand it. For (2) preferred to do a and c . Else a and b. Note that "a" is regardless of me having to prove myself to anyone. It would matter most to myself what I end up doing in my life (I cant impact other people's life more with my life than how much it would impact mine). So I will try to just follow my dreams If I were you I would get the job at the company I want to work with and the university i want to study in (be it X as was in the discussion or a new interest be it Y or Z) . 3) - I personally feel you should speak to David (and venu is applicable) at the earliest or just forget about the whole incident. Do not let such things consume your thoughts/memory/ time. Am sure there must be plenty of good things David has done in the past - you will cherish keeping them in your memory bank much more than using it up for such incidents. Below is what I had written before you detailed your question --- For me there would be two different approach to this situation each depending on how much do I value the friendship - If I have valued his friendship - I would confront the person and discuss the issue with him openly. If i do value the person's friendship I would believe he would also value the same and hence we would try to work out the matter together to keep the relationship alive. It might turn out that once we resolve our difference and I explain to the person that If he has any thing against me he must feel free to come to talk to me about it rather than talking behind my back - it might end up being better for our friendship. On the other hand, I might discover that my valued friend actually does not care enough for my feelings. I would still be at gain from this experience. Since every relationship needs to be worked upon and not just dumped, I will be satisfied that I gave it a shot to save the friendship. I can then happily move on. I would also introspect myself in the light of the things that were mentioned about me - and if I see any merit in them try to improve myself in those aspects, else just ignore them. There has not been anything to value - no memories I cherish or stories I can boast of our friendship - I would again follow the above steps. Maybe I would gain a new friend or just loose an acquaintance. Either way - Revenge is not good. Hurting that person back would do no good to you but will make certain that you loose your friend / acquaintance. Showing yourself worthy to others / proving your worth should not be a motivation - rather it should be aimed to yourself. You need to always prove to yourself and be at peace with yourself. PS- i edited the phrase in the question ( "prove myself that I am capable than what he thinks" changed to "prove myself, show him that I am capable of more than what he thinks") to reflect what I thought you wanted to ask - please comment if you actually meant to prove to Yourself that you were capable of more than what your friend thinks.
Parikshat Sharma at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
There are times people say good/bad things about you. That doesn't mean that they want bad things to happen in your life. David must hace thought that you deserve something more than studying in X university so he said so. Don't take things negatively. You'll end up nowhere but in a mess. If I was Anna, I would take the third option of becoming a true good friend of David and here is the reason why - There were good and bad times in Anna's life in which David helped him. Don't forget the graduation time when David told Vinu to help Anna. Even after rejecting his offer David offered Anna to stay at his place again. Prove your friendship first before proving that you don't need help, before proving that you can be successful without anybody's help, before proving that you don't care and you yourself can achieve everything on your own. Hurting is easy but applying medicine on a wound is difficult. Take things positively and see everything will be good. And if you really want to prove than let your success make noise not your hardwork. Just go ahead and hug David today. Say thanks to him for everything he gave you. For all the time he stood with you. (If he has said anything bad for you) Make him realise his mistake. No one has ever died for being down to earth and forgiving. Infact it'll gain you respect in the other person's eyes. Be frank to David. Go ahead and ask him why he said such things about Anna. Make things clear instead of creating misunderstandings and make things worse. Good luck :D
Anonymous
I think that Anna should sit down with David and ask why David said those things. What David thinks about Anna should not matter, but might help Anna to understand what David was thinking when David said those things. Anna can then assure David that David is mistaken in thinking that Anna is not ready and Anna should go to study at X University anyway, because that is what Anna wants to do. But it will be hard to be around Venu and David when Anna knows this Skype conversation took place, so Anna will be happier in the end if he clears the air with David and David knows that Anna knows what was said. If David is worth Anna's friendship, David will confess why he said what he did and will not speak badly of Anna in the future.
Amy B Reineri
The same event happened to me. I was Anna. My brother was David. My brother had a job. He let me stay in his apartment when I was going to school and looking for a job.I asked my brother for referrals. He knew me. He knew that I was not qualified for the jobs I was looking for. So he told me that I did not have the skills. I was very hurt. It felt like he had punched me. He told me it to my face, but I am sure he talked to his friends about it before he got up the courage to talk to me. It is very hard to tell someone to their face that they are not good enough, because you know you are going to hurt them.David may believe you do not have the right skills and habits to be at your school or to get the jobs you are looking for. He may be offering you his apartment because you are still his friend and he likes you, and doesn't want to leave you with no place to live.You say that he said you are not worthy of being at your school. If someone said that to me, I would feel attacked and feel very sad. It took me many years to learn how to understand how people ment those words. When my brother said things like that, he meant that I did not have the skills...yet. I could get those skills.You said you wanted to take revenge by being successful. That is a good response. If you can take those words and be motivated by them, use them to find out what skills you need, you can get them. Then you may be qualified to get those referrals.There is another possibility. I have had people tell me I am not worthy to be in a school because it is an engineering school and I am a girl. Being a girl is not something I can change. If David saud you are not worthy because of something you can't change, like being a girl, then he is a very bad friend and it will probably be bad to live with him.if you are interested, I can talk to you more about what it is like to depend on the kindness of my brother while looking for a job. It was very nice of him to let me stay in his apartment and help me look for jobs. But I also hated every minute of it. I do not like to depend on people.
Tara Roys
Related Q & A:
- How do I find a friend on Yahoo messenger?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I add a friend who is yahoo member already?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
- What do I have to include in an invitation letter inviting a friend to Canada?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I send a file to a friend on Hotmail?Best solution by askdavetaylor.com
- I want to find a friend who moved address..... how can i do it.Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.