Are animals killed in the process of farming vegetarian foods?
-
I've heard that a lot of mice are killed in the process of farming wheat. Is this true, and is it true for other vegetarian foods? Is it possible for a vegetarian to ensure that no animals were harmed in the production of their good without growing it themselves?
-
Answer:
Yes, small mammals, birds (particularly in nests), and of course insects are killed in the process of raising and harvesting grain. But then, even dairy cows (considered herbivores by all) will not spit out a small piece of animal protein they happen to take into their mouths while grazing. Any effort to turn over soil, by machine or by hand, is going to kill some worms, grubs, and other underground creatures. Of course, this isn't the intent, but it's the fact. To avoid these examples of collateral damage, you'd have to restrict a diet to fruits and nuts, but then you have to find a way to deal with the insects that got to them before you.
John Burgess at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
Even while I was weeding I found a great many newts under every large weed, many ants nests, many spiders etc etc. It occurred to me I was destroying their environment.
Edward Martin
Unfortunately, for any amount of terrain we claim from the wild for agriculture, for each tree we convert into furniture or tools, for each house we build, for each baby we raise and nurture, an animal or several will have to die. Habitat loss is the number one, the most destructive, the primary threat to the survival of animals. In other words, just our mere existence and survival is a death warrant for animals. So, vegans and veggies, you too have animal's blood on your hands.
Carlos A. Sardá Sardá
Please take this into account when reading other answers. 70% of US grain production is fed to livestock. Meat consumption is still the main reason for the high number of animal deaths through grain production.
Thomas Smith
Vegetarian means avoiding just meat but still consuming dairy and eggs. Animals are killed in both the dairy AND egg industry in huge numbers. Dairy - dairy calves which are male are not of use in the dairy industry and only female calves are raised to produce more milk. The male calves are either shot after a day or so, raised for veal or raised for cheap beef. They are basically by-products. Eggs - again, male chicks are hatched as 'by products' of producing more female egg laying chickens to support the egg industry. The male chicks are killed within a day or so either by being gassed or ground up alive. In terms of plant based foods you cannot guarantee animals were not harmed as rodents, insects etc will be killed in the harvesting process however by becoming vegan you would be reducing your animal killing by a HUGE amount. A lot of agricultural land is farmed to produce animal feed. If you are vegan you do not take part in this whole section of agriculture, plus you don't directly kill any animals from the meat, dairy and egg industries Also a huge amount of deforestation is carried out for land for cattle ranching. Deforestation causes huge amounts of animal deaths and reduction in biodiversity, whilst also contributing to climate change and altering ecosystems worldwide. I would say the best diet to reduce animal deaths would be a palm oil avoiding vegan using cruelty free beauty products and also avoiding the amount of plastic you buy as plastic is another environmental problem especially for marine life. Palm oil is well documented as a huge driver of deforestation too. Growing your own vegetables would reduce animal deaths further if you have time and space.
Sarah Morris
Followers of a religion called Jainism come closest to not killing any animals to eat. To the point where they don't cook at night because bugs are attracted to the open flames and kill themselves. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jain_vegetarianism
Chris Bermingham
Yes, insects and some small animals are killed.. But, vegan foods are still much less harmful to animals than slaughterhouses, in which an animal spends their entire life in living hell. Vegan foods are also much better for your health, and the environment.Despite my bio ("100% vegan"), no one can really ensure that no small animals were killed in the process of farming. So, anyone who buys from a supermarket is really only 99.9% vegan, if you count the deaths of small animals who happened to be in the way of the machinery. But this is much better than not being vegan at all. Better for your health, better for the environment, better for world hunger, and is still better for animals.
Sakura Bisque
Intensive farming practices such as wheat cropping introduced to natural environments kills far more than just animals it destroys entire ecosystems. Many species of plant and animal life are wiped out or displaced as the cropping practice begins. This new environment is then usually favourable to a much smaller number and less diverse number of species. So animals such as rodents attempt to colonise the changed environment but are then killed through human control methods or inadvertently through the growth and harvest practices employed through human activity upon the crop.
Dan Eady
Yes, animals get killed when you grow crops. Other answers have mentioned running animals over when plowing and mowing, but if you just think about the fact you are converting a natural environment into cropland you soon realize that a lot of animals just lost their homes. So not only does crop production kill animals, it often kills all the succeeding generations of animals on that land.To illustrate the idea think about american bison and barbed wire. Before the farmers got to the prairies there were herds of buffalo so large they could take days to pass through a location. Wherever they went they ate the grass and trampled what they didn't eat. As soon as the first plow made it through the Cumberland gap and onto the prairies the buffalo was doomed. If the market hunters had not shot the buffalo into near extinction the farmers with their plows and wire fencing would have sealed their fate because the fencing to protect the crops would have meant no migration of the buffalo to fresh pasture and certain starvation for them.You can also look up the fate of the prairie chicken and the black footed ferret. These were also destroyed by wheat farming.Many farms were created by draining wetlands. This means loss of habitat for animals like beaver, muskrats, ducks, geese, frogs, etc.It does not really matter if the farmers are large agribusiness or if the are small farm holders. The result is the same.
Dan Hunter
Yes. Although not as many as in other country which I interpreted from answers above. But some insects and small rodents are killed for sure in India. In India, mostly there are not big farms and not very sophisticated machinery is used. Small fields are ploughed using either Tracktor or Bulls. These both means do not cause much harm to animals. Small insects are uncovered and Birds eat them. Hardly any snake or rabbit is killed. They run away after hearing the noise. Although insects are killed because of pesticides which is necessary otherwise they will destroy all the crop. Otherwise people in India avoid killing any animal until and unless its creating too much trouble.
Anonymous
Related Q & A:
- How to create new process as its own parent process?Best solution by Stack Overflow
- Who killed Mr. Body?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Do you think Princess Diana was killed?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Who killed Princess Diana?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What is the difference between intensive farming and organic farming?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.