What is the purpose of custom officers at a border to ask a traveller what their purpose is to visit a country?
-
Is it only to check that they have the right visa, and to double check with IT registers what is on file? For example if a traveller says business (or pleasure), and the officer says what kind of business (or pleasure)? Who is the officer to decide what kind of business (or pleasure) is legitimate or not? And if the traveller enters the country for non-legit purposes, he/she will not be the one disclosing it to a customs officer. The practice of asking seems out of date, and something in connection with when custom officers had a different kind of authority in the 18 or 19 hundred when they did not have IT systems and registers, and could stop a traveller from entering a country if they did not like him or her. What is your take on it?
-
Answer:
As pointed out, Immigration and customs officers are not the same thing and have different objectives. An immigration officer wants to determine if you are legally authorized to enter the country and (depending on the country) if you will be leaving on or before your permission to be in that country expires. A customs officer wants to determine if you are bringing any prohibited items into the country. So let's think about why each officer might ask you what your purpose is in visiting the country: An immigration officer gets some information just from how you answer the question. For example, you might say "to visit family" but when he follows up with "what family members and where do they live?" an inability to answer the question might indicate you in fact are not entering for that reason. Remember that the 20th 9/11 hijacker was denied entry to the United States because an immigration officer grew suspicious with his answers to these kinds of questions. At least on the United States, one of the things immigration officers are trying to determine is if a person is entering the country on a tourist visa but in fact has no intention of leaving (this is one of the biggest sources of illegal immigration into the United States...far more than people just crossing the border illegally from Mexico).Many people enter on student visas but then never leave... On the other hand, a customs officer might have a different need to ask the same question. If you are returning to the country, he might be trying to determine if you owe duty (taxes) on what you bought out of the country and are bringing back in...and did you declare things that seem reasonable and appropriate on your customs declaration. If you say you are entering on business, he might ask what commercial samples or goods you have with you (goods have to be declared). If you are a tourist coming from certain countries to visit, this might prompt further questions. For example, in the United States, visitors from Africa and South America frequently bring wooden items as gifts for family which are illegal to bring in due to the possibility the items have insects that pose a risk to the United States agriculture industry. There are even goods legal in some places that are not permissible in the United States. Not talking about illegal drugs here, but things like cuban cigars and even the "kinder" chocolate balls made in Germany (and sold at the Frankfurt Airport) which are illegal to bring into the US because the little toys inside are classified as a choking hazard in the US. I agree with your assessment that a person who is doing something illegal is unlikely to tell the truth when asked these questions. Rather it is HOW they answer that helps the customs or immigration officer decide whether more questions and or searches are warranted...
David Klain at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
From y experience, the questions I have been asked ( including the one in your question ) are generally to find out if I am at all nervous or inconsistent in my answers. We cross into the USA frequently in a Motorhome, and some of the questions are obviously "loaded" - for example " what are you bringing with you" If you say "nothing" ( which is not a bad answer if you infer that they are concerned about what you may leave in the USA ) , but its actually not true. I this case, I said " A Motorhome full of stuff, but nothing I am leaving in the USA", which I guessed to be the more accurate answer. It seems to be more a cat and mouse game than anything else. If you are willing to play their game - no problem !
Peter Brooke
To start with you need to realise that there are immigration officers and customs officers. They have different jobs. The customs officer is there to stop the import of prohibted goods and to collect duties on certain goods. The immigration officer is there to make sure that immigration policy laid down by the government is followed. Both of them use similar questioning methods to try and spot discrepancies in stories. You've obviously done too much travelling through major airports. Not all border crossing points between all countries use computers. I entered Canada 3 years ago and there was not a single computer in sight. Those guys have to fall back on the process they used BC (Before Computers). And so do all the other immigration officers the world over because IT only goes so far; there are people who (believe it or not) don't appear in computer databases who you want to keep out, and computers go down. So, you need to keep your questionning skills up.
Graham Harrison
Related Q & A:
- What's the worst thing you've seen a player do on a rugby field?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Is it okay for a girl to ask a guy out?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What is a bachelor of Science degree, and what can I do with such a degree?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How to get a PR?what are the conditions to get a PR?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How is it like working as a paralegal? What advice can you give to a potential paralegal?Best solution by Ask.com old
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.