What is the difference between polymer science, polymer chemistry, and polymer physics?
-
-
Answer:
Polymer Science refers to the entire field. Though this is not generally true, if someone were to say they are a polymer scientist they would mean they have MS level credits in both Polymer Chemistry and Polymer Physics gaining a Ph.D in Polymer Science.. The other two is as they sound. Polymer Chemists are interested in reactions, and Polymer physicists in bonds. In the end we all need to know more of the other disciplines and become true polymer scientists. I am definitively a polymer physicist.
Matthew Putman at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
I worked as a thermal analyst for many years, in which capacity I met many scientists and engineers who were actively engaged in polymer development. This was in an industrial setting. We normally used the term 'polymer science' unless we had a reason to be more specific. For example, if the issue had to do with curing thermosets (a reaction) or chemical compatibility, we would typically talk about 'polymer chemistry,' If the issue had to do with material properties, we would speak of 'polymer physics.' Curiously, we also used the physics label when discussing rheology even though both of our rheologists were PhD chemists. They referred to themselves as 'Rheologists,' btw. I remember only two who called themselves 'polymer-something,' They were both materials scientists, and they opted for the 'Polymer Scientist' label. The rest went for the department-level ID, including those who had done both masters and doctoral level work specializing in polymers (that is, they called themselves 'Chemists,' 'Physicists,' 'MEs,' or 'ChemE's'). I can see where this might be done differently in academia, but in industry, conveying one's background and general approach is of vital importance. A chemist and a chemical engineer might both be properly described as 'Polymer Chemists' but they are not going to ask the same questions or follow the same line of investigation. Those two approaches brought together are far more powerful than either used in isolation, but there are also certain all too predictable arguments that will take place unless everyone is upfront about their backgrounds. The potential rewards and pitfalls skyrocket every time someone with a different take on polymers is added to a team. Looking at books categorized as 'Polymer Chemistry' (PC) or 'Polymer Physics,' (PP) or 'Polymer Science' (PS) I have seen is a great deal of overlap. The PC books were more likely to go into the gory details of reaction mechanisms and kinetics. The PP books were more likely to go into tensor calculus (heavens protect us). The PS books were of two types: introductory-level texts on the one hand and materials science / engineering handbooks on the other (the latter have loads of useful tables in the appendices). So to return to the original question, "What is the difference between polymer science, polymer chemistry, and polymer physics?" my experience suggests it is a matter of where emphasis is placed and to what extent. Furthermore, I think those differences are as yet fluid and evolving. Two decades hence, there might be a definitive answer to your question, but not so much today. --------------Edit------------- LOL, I see I have gotten my early upvotes from my fellow ChemE's. It may be the foregoing is the ChemE perspective on polymer science ;-)
Beth Hutton
Polymer Science is a generic term covering the various subdivisions of the subject. Polymer chemists are mostly interested in the task of making plastic substances from their precursor chemicals; by reacting ethylene, propene or other hydrocarbons with catalysts under appropriate conditions Eg high pressure. Plastics or thermoplastics are typically made by free radical chain reactions. In contrast polymer resins or thermosets, another class of man made polymers, are made by cross linking various reactive momomers or oligomers together, Eg polyurethane paint when spread into a thin film eg on a wall, undergoes a cross linking reaction to form a resin; the crosslinking reaction is induced by atmospheric oxygen. Resins unlike plastics are essentially one big molecule ! That's why there are few if any solvents for them. In contrast plastics can be softened with solvents being linear in their structure at the molecular level. The distribution of polymer chain lengths in a given plastic material is largely controlled by the kinetics of the free radical chain reaction, in the monomer to polymer conversion process. So you've got to like reaction kinetics if you want to be a polymer chemist ! Lots of physical chemistry. Rubbers are amorphous thermoplastics above their glass transition temperature. Polymer spectroscopy carried out for polymer material identification purposes is also a speciality within the field of polymer chemistry. Also gel permeation chromatography or gpc which is another polymer characterization technique. In contrast, polymer physicists are more interested in the physical properties of the materials polymer chemists have made for us. Such as the optical properties of the polymer ( Eg contact lenses ), the behavior of polymers in solution ( Eg non drip paint; which is a non-Newtonian fluid ie its viscosity decreases when a shearing force is applied to it eg paint brush spreading paint on a wall, and increases when that force is removed, Eg paint brush removed from wall on its way to paint tin for more paint ). Polymer physics also includes the study of light scattering by polymers;( eg used as a polymer characterization method ); the study of the statistical mechanics of rubber elasticity, plus other theoretical topics. Also polymer crystallography, and Raman spectroscopy. Polymer material scientists tend to be interested in the engineering properties of substances that happen to be a plastic or resin. So like metallurgy, polymer materials science concerns itself with stress strain relationships & the tensile strength of the material; with the toughness of the polymer material; its hardness; the material's melting point or glass transition temperature; creep; & materials selection for mechanical design. Plus properties metals don't have such as viscoelasticity. The strength of materials is a fundamental subject within materials science whether the material under study is a metal, plastic, resin, composite, glass, a ceramic, or concrete; or a natural material such as wood or granite. Polymer blending is another subject within polymer materials science. Also thermal analysis, using techniques such as TG, DTA, & DSC. Turning to polymer engineering. Polymer engineers often have degrees in mechanical engineering. Polymer engineering concerns itself with the moulding or castings of polymer materials into useful engineering products. Things such as plastic buckets, rainwater goods, tyres, yacht hulls, plastic bottles, aircraft windows, plastic shopping bags, sneakers, shoes, car panels, train seats, aircraft interiors, vending machine tea cups, toys, sports equipment etc, the list goes on ! Major polymer engineering processes deployed to make such goods include; plastic injection moulding ( plastic washing up bowls made using this type of moulding machine ), vacuum forming ( plastic egg cartons made in this way ), extrusion machines ( PVC drain pipes ), plastic composite mouldings ( yacht hulls, aircraft wings, military technology ), reaction injection moulding ( automobile panels ), blow moulding ( plastic bottles ), & rotomoulding ( large plastic tanks ). Polymer technology has a slightly broader remit covering subjects in addition to polymer engineering ranging from polymer additives for car engine oil ( Eg star polymers ), to medical polymers (Eg pace makers ), polymers in electronics, household paints, fabrics, rope, polythene beakers for hydrofluoric acid. In fact any useful application.
Joseph Hall
It exist also polymer technology. The difference between polymer science and polymer technology is evident, because the first is associated with theoretical studies and the second one it is associated with the practical applications of these studies. I think polymer chemistry is referred to the development of the reaction of polymerization and depolymerization, while polymer physics is related to the study of the physical properties of polymeric material (in particular viscosity).
Daniele Pugliesi
At my company, we use Polymer Science as a broad discipline. Polymer chemistry is typically associated with synthesis. We have overlap with polymer synthesis and organometallic catalysis. We generally associate polymer physics with the study of structure property relationships.
Larry Gros
Related Q & A:
- What is the difference between a Computer science (A.S.) and Computer Information Systems (A.S?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What is the difference between forensic chemistry, forensic biology, and forensic science?Best solution by answers.yahoo.com
- What is the difference between a computer engineering major and computer science major?Best solution by Super User
- What's the difference between science and engineering?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What is the difference between computer science and computer programming?Best solution by wiki.answers.com
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.