Should I give my friend a letter of recommendation for my old dream job?
-
Last year, I worked my dream job as the Director of a small museum and cultural center, and was forced to leave because my husband's job took us to another city. A friend of mine has expressed an enthusiastic interest in the job, but does not have any museum training, or any background in managing or running any type of business or institution whatsoever. He wants me to write a letter of recommendation. Should I? I served as the Director of a small museum in northern Nevada last year. It turned out to be my dream job, not just because of the excellent work environment, but it was the ultimate culmination of about sixteen years of working towards a goal like that. It took a lot of formal, higher education, training, and hands-on experience that you just can't get any other way. The work is extremely challenging, detail-oriented, difficult, and supremely rewarding. I was forced to leave that job. My husband had been unemployed for several months and finally was hired on with a new company in another city with a fantastic package, full benefits for him and myself, and a handsome paycheck that was much bigger than mine. We couldn't live on what I was making alone, so we decided to go ahead and make the move. I was so determined to hold onto that job, though. I actually flew every single week back and forth between the old city and our new one. After a couple of months, I was completely exhausted from travel and the frustration of never really being home in either city. I made the hardest decision- to resign. It was one of the hardest decisions I have ever had to make. The museum's Board of Trustees and the staff of volunteers took it very hard, too. They really liked me and my work, and we had all felt like I was making a genuine difference there. Fast forward to the present, and the museum is looking for my replacement. A friend of mine is very interested in doing the job. In a lot of ways, I think that he would be a good fit. He's outgoing, intelligent, and has a vast network of people and resources that could have a big impact (especially financially) on a small, struggling local institution. However, he completely lacks the professional and educational background that I have. It was largely because of this background that I was hired on in the first place. I also have a great network, but it's not even close to what my friend has. I gave him a great deal of assistance toward getting this job. I provided him with all of my application materials, my resume, curriculum vitae, and exit interview materials, all of which would give him a distinct advantage over other candidates vying for the same position. I've also spent a lot of time talking with him and answering his questions about what they will ask in the interview, what are some areas they will want expertise in, what some of the ongoing issues are at the museum, and so on. I've been like his personal Cliffs Notes for getting this job! In the past week, though, he's been pestering me for more information, requests to go over his application materials, critiques of these materials, etc. He listed me as a reference without asking me. In addition to everything I have already done for him, he now wants me to write him a letter of recommendation. I admit, of course, that I have some mixed feelings about this. It was a job I dearly loved, and I do want to see it go to the right person. If my friend had an educational or professional background like mine, I would absolutely feel inclined to write that letter for him. However, the fact that he totally lacks any background in any of these areas makes me wonder, that he might not be the best candidate. That I am the outgoing Director at present certainly would give a letter of recommendation tremendous weight, especially given the rapport I had with the Board of Trustees. The thing that makes it a bit yucky is that it's a personal friend, someone who has been very good to me. I don't know if he'd be upset with me or not if I didn't write the letter. I have given so much time and effort to help him get this job already. And yes, it is hard to see my old dream job go to someone who might not have the same appreciation for what it takes to work in that world. In no way whatsoever is it a run-of-the-mill office job! Extra details: * He does have other letters of recommendation in his application packet already * He has a hefty record of unemployment/being fired from previous jobs * He has caught the attention of one of the Board of Trustees members who has a lot of clout with the museum and other board members, and she already seems ready to hire him Am I being a complete ass for hesitating to write him such a letter? Should I let him down on this one? Or do I write the letter anyway, knowing that my influence will put him at a distinct advantage over others who might be more qualified?
-
Answer:
No, don't write this letter. You can easily get out of this on "I'm sorry, I've done all I can for you here, good luck." If you want to be really nice I would maybe be willing to send a quick note to someone there saying he's a friend and asking to make sure to review his application materials and not just immediately garbage bin him (which is pretty standard for professional referrals), but it sounds like you've never even worked with this person in a professional capacity, so forgetting anything else you're not even theoretically in a good position to write him this letter (I would actually make that clear when I referred him too, "I've never worked with him professionally, but he is outgoing, intelligent, and have a vast network of people and resources [etc. etc.]".). For nothing else, if you write this letter and he does not succeed in this role, that will reflect very poorly on you and your judgment, and will sour the opinions of you that your board/colleagues there currently have. Don't put yourself in that position.
chatelaine at Ask.Metafilter.Com Visit the source
Other answers
> He listed me as a reference without asking me. Game over. Bad friend, no letter. That's a sign there are issues. Asking for a reference is a sign of respect, and your friend broke this trust. If you get called by your former employer, I'd be inclined to state that you didn't give your permission.
scruss
I'm so sorry you had to give up this job! It sounds like you're still mourning it. For a second, though, let's take that reality out of the equation. The gig is no longer yours, and someone else is going to get it. You're clearly conflicted about whether or not your friend can do the job well. (Positive: great network! Negative: little experience and spotty employment history). If that's the case, why have you been helping him so much with the application process? In his position, I would expect a recommendation from you, too. But regardless of his expectations at this point, I would not endorse your friend if you don't believe he is right for the job. Doing so could potentially cause big problems for both the museum and him. When he asks again, you can say that it's a personal policy to only write job recommendations for people you have worked with. That's totally reasonable, and he should back off.
jessca84
I wouldn't write the letter. But, because you say he's been a good friend to you in the past, here is what I would do: 1. Call your closest acquaintance on the hiring committee; 2. Tell them exactly what you told us - that you think his network is exceptional and that if there's a big fundraising portion to the job, his network could be a great asset to them; but that he lacks the qualifications for the other parts of the job as you performed it; 3. Tell him that you made a personal call rather than writing a letter, and told them how great his network is and that it could really help them. That's it. And you know, it's possible that the fundraising component is a bigger part of this now than it was when you were there, or that parts of the job requiring your training can be done by others, etc. So it's possible that he could be an asset for them even he only stays a couple years. And I strongly disagree that it was wrong for him to put you as a reference. You helped him apply for the job! I would assume that you were in my corner too if you did that for me.
fingersandtoes
He has a hefty record of unemployment/being fired from previous jobs Personally, there are very very few situations where I would be comfortable writing a recommendation for someone who had been fired from many jobs. It it your own credibility and professional persona on the line here. Nthing that you only write reccs for people you've worked with.
smoke
Why not write the letter but include a section (or paragraph) that describes the reservations that you've listed here? Don't give the letter to him -- send it directly to the hiring committee. You don't have to make your reservations sound like deal-breakers -- just an honest and diplomatic assessment of possible deficiencies in his background.
alex1965
You should take this job back. You should absolutely take the job and move back. No way should you recommend someone else. This is your job and your life. Please take care of yourself!
internet fraud detective squad, station number 9
Also: I'd use the call opportunity to ask how things are going, catch up a bit, and say something like "you know Phyllis, it just kills me to have had to leave that role. I miss the museum every day. If there are ever any projects you need done that don't require being onsite, I hope you'll let me know so I can help in another capacity." Just in case.
fingersandtoes
Don't write the letter. You'd be doing the museum a disservice by putting someone forward who you don't think is fit for the position. And you run the slight risk of tarnishing your own reputation if he screws up - and you have some valid concerns that he might screw up.
cabingirl
Forgive me for looking at a previous question. I think this question explains the central mystery of your previous question: why would your husband suddenly start treating you with abuse and contempt? There are abusers who mostly control their behavior until some circumstance (falling pregnant being the most common) limits their partner's ability to leave. Our neighbor growing up was abused by her husband; she lost her hearing in one ear, he hit her so hard in the head. The first time he hit her? in an airplane bathroom, on the way from her native Chile to his native US, just a few days after they married. Now she was in a foreign country, with no family or friends, and was soon pregnant to boot. He could treat her as he liked, and did. Up until the last several months, it seems, you lived in a place where you had a dream job and a support network. Your husband was even dependent on your income for a while. Now he's not, and you've given up that network. In short, it's my conjecture that giving up your job was when your husband gave himself permission to start treating you abusively. Contact the museum, tell them you'd love your old job back, and move back. This will only get worse.
palliser
Related Q & A:
- What can I give my friend for his birthday?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I send my friend a link?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What do I need to study in uni for my dream job?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How long should I give a prof to write a letter of recommendation for a graduate school application?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- I need to write a letter of recommendation for myself.Best solution by Stack Overflow
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.