Did the police officer in this video act in an imprudent way?
-
He stopped them for speeding. If he wasn't a police officer, he would have gone away because they were two and he was alone. You don't mess with people that can kick your ass. Why did he have to escalate the situation? Wasn't it clear from their behavior that they were likely to attack him if he tried to arrest them? Why didn't he write down their licence plate and go away?
-
Answer:
He didn't escalate the situation. He was calm and courteous to the men up until the moment they assaulted him. All the beeps are the curses the driver is saying to the trooper. That was a frightening thing for me to watch. I've been in similar situations, where help wasn't immediately available and people were thinking of taking me on. The trooper was doing his job--enforcing traffic laws. The audio of the driver makes me think he was drunk. This makes the situation more serious than a speeding ticket. Even if it was only a speeding ticket, the driver is obligated to cooperate with the police. Cops, and people in authority positions generally, don't walk away when someone says "no." Your parents didn't do it, your teachers didn't do it, and the cops aren't going to do it. Those who choose to challenge the authority of someone equipped and authorized to use deadly force to back up their orders take the risk of being shot and/or killed. If you don't like what the cop says or does, take it up in court. Fight him at the side of the road, and you're going to prison or the morgue. More often than not, it's the latter. The cops win more than they lose.
Tim Dees at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
At the point that the officer makes a traffic stop, he or she is not really able to just "write down their licence plate and go away." First, the officer has the duty and obligation to know who the driver of the vehicle is. This requires that the driver present identification to the officer and the driver has a legal duty and obligation to provide identification. Believe it or not, there are plenty of people who loan out their vehicles to friends and friends-of-friends, and if the registered owner isn't the driver, there's very little chance of finding out who the driver is later -- I've heard, "I only know his street name..." too many times from the owner of a car involved in a crime. Second, the officer has a responsibility to make sure the person driving the vehicle isn't impaired or otherwise incapable of operating the vehicle safely. This driver's speech seemed slurred and "thick-tongued," and he was obviously not cooperating with the officer. These lead me to believe there is a good chance that the driver is impaired by alcohol or other drugs. Simply letting the driver go could create a significant risk of a crash-related injury for both the driver of the vehicle and anyone else unlucky enough to be in his path. Finally, the officer did not escalate the situation. The driver did, by fighting, and the passenger created the deadly-force situation by attacking the officer after he pulled the driver from the car. If the second person didn't get involved, the officer may have been able to subdue the driver without significant injury.
Christopher Hawk
As to your last question: Timothy McVeigh was pulled over during a routine traffic stop (driving without plates) when the patrolman noticed a bulge in McVeigh's jacket; he admitted to having a gun, and was arrested on the two (relatively, as it were) minor charges. I'm not saying the two citizens in the video necessarily equate to the Oklahoma City bombers, but neither the officer in the video nor anyone on patrol knows who may be behind the wheel of a vehicle they've stopped.
Tim Rank
He wasn't "unprudent" (sic) in any way. If he had not been a police officer he wouldn't have been pulling people over for speeding, so your first assumption is just weird. How you can watch that video and think it was the cop who escalated the situation is beyond me. Very clearly he was attacked for no reason, and defended himself.
Craig Good
You have an extremely odd concept of what a police officer's job is; they do not just "go away" if people engaged in illegal activity respond to them with hostility. If that were the case, the crooks would rule. The men in the car were the ones who escalated the situation, not the LEO. If they had cooperated, they'd be alive. Any chance that lesson is getting out there?
Lacey Sheridan
I watched. I saw a police officer doing his job and two or was it three drunk fools. If there was any unprudence (if you can make up words so can I) it was definately the act of jumping someone who has a gun and the right to use it. Think of some of the possible consequences of the officer just "going away". The drunk driver hits and kills someone else later. The officer is disciplined for allowing an obviously drunk driver to continue to drive. The clowns in the car are identified much later and are wanted for multiple offences. The officer is disiplined for allowing wanted fugitives to escape. The fools in the car boast all over town how they faced down a police officer. The officer is ridiculed out of his job by fellow officers. The most likely result is when the owner of the car is found later he denies being the driver at the time of the stop and nobody faces charges. As you said in your question, "don't mess with people that can kick your ass". The dudes in the car should have taken that advice.
Mike Neville
Based on what the camera shows, my only (light) criticism of the officer is that he shot once with one hand, missed, hesitated whether to shoot again, and took his sights off the target. We were trained to use both hands and shoot three times when in close quarters, which that definitely was (or from the hip, in too-close quarters). Buddy in the white shirt should have had too many holes to charge a second time. I suspect this is a troll question.
Jay McKinnon
Related Q & A:
- How to become police officer in Florida?Best solution by how-to-become-a-police-officer.com
- What do I need to do to become a police officer in New Jersey?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What steps does it take to be a police officer?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How do I become a police officer?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How old do you have to be to apply to be a police officer in Indiana?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.