Why did some chimps evolve into humans, and some remain chimpanzees?

Would it be possible to breed chimpanzees as intelligent as humans if one mated only the smartest chimps from each generation for many years?

  • I know the practice of artificial selection allows us to modify heritable traits in a population over time; certain dog types that were artificially bred and the recently domesticated silver fox come to mind as pertinent examples. So, could we potentially breed extremely intelligent chimpanzees (or other non-human primates) by selecting smart individuals from each generation and mating them with each other? Would there be a limit to the intelligence these primates could reach? If it is possible, how long, theoretically, would it take to reach a standard of human-like intelligence? This question has intrigued me ever since I learned about artificial selection in Honors Biology freshman year (just two years ago). I'd love to hear anyone's thoughts on the matter. (This is a cross-post from my ask.science question on reddit: http://redd.it/10oocz.)

  • Answer:

    Probably not. While many biological aspects are flexible, there are quite a few "hardware" constraints. In the same manner you won't be able to evolve a cat that can jump three floors up, it's very unlikely you can make chimps evolve human intelligence. The chimp's brain is simply not build to do that. Chimps are very intelligent apes, with some mental traits we see in humans at an age of several years. However, it's likely that like any animal their brain structure itself has a sort of capacity ceiling, which has very different qualities than that of humans. This is why even the most intelligent chimps can only learn so much in the way of abstract concepts and forward thinking. That said, if you took enough time you could probably evolve chimps into a much more intelligent animal - but that animal will no longer be a chimp in the same sense that Homo-Sapiens were no longer Homo Erectus.

Ido Kaminsky at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Yes, definitely, but it would probably take a long time. Also, you'll have to define "intelligence" very carefully.

Dan Zhang

This is not possible for multiple reasons, two of which are highlighted here. First, human intelligence is a product of a mosaic of behavioral and cognitive traits that evolved in the context of a tightly wound feedback system between biology and culture. So, the question of breeding smart chimps to reach human intelligence can only make sense if "intelligence" can be imagined as a product of a single (or a few single) traits, and also discounting the interplay between biology and environment (and in the later stages of evolution, culture). This certainly is not the case. Second, there is no reason to suggest that these traits in chimps which we recognize as denoting "intelligence" have any relationship to the mosaic of evolutionary traits which we humans, over time, accumulated, some of which may have erupted out of random mutations. In this way, even if you define intelligence in chimps and identify the aspects of the genotype which correspond, it is totally unlikely that the favoring of these traits will result in a human-like intelligence. Hope this helps.

Tom Huxley

There are assumed to be many genes favourable to high IQ, both in humans and other species.   By breeding, you could maybe produce a breed that had all of them in all individuals of that breed.  But you could also find that some of the high-IQ genes have nasty side-effects, as happens with selective breeding of dogs.   This would take centuries, and you would still just have a smarter chimp.  Humans have accumulated a lot more relevant genes in the millions of years since we split from chimps.   Long before that, we are likley to understand the genes involved.  Then we could do it much quicker using genetic engineering.  (Assuming we want to, of course.)

Gwydion Madawc Williams

It took millions of years for us to evolve. If by "many" you mean anything not at least within a few orders of magnitude, and you are not directly manipulating and changing genes (effectively creating a much higher mutation rate to speed up the process) the answer is assuredly no. To have our intelligence the same mutations as occurred in us would have to spontaneously occur again, without other negative mutations getting in the way.  This takes a LONG time by random chance.

Jeff Kesselman

   The short answer is yes.     The longer answer is that this would be an extremely difficult process, taking many generations probably several thousand years in which succeeding generations of selected chimpanzees would be bred to other high performing chimpanzees. Over time this would result in chimpanzees with a higher performance for the traits selected and depending upon the conservation of nearly random mutations in brain development and intelligence result in near human intelligence.

Gerald Goll

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.