Any other Vegan Muslims out there?

If Muslims kill innocent people elsewhere, why is it wrong to kill innocent Muslims who live among us?

  • People say that we will try to talk with them. Most talks with Muslims have failed miserably. They either demand a Muslims state like of India , Kashmir and Egypt or convert rest of people to Muslims. What is wrong in killing rest of Muslims if they are so pathetic? When I say this , I mean this http://www.indianexpress.com/news/protests-against-afzal-gurus-hanging-at-jantar-mantar-21-detained/1071899/ Whole world knows that Afzal Guru was wrong except these sick Muslims. Even these educated Muslims feel that Afzal Guru was a hero and not a terrorist.People say that we will try to talk with them. Most talks with Muslims have failed miserably. They either demand a Muslims state like of India , Kashmir and Egypt or convert rest of people to Muslims. What is wrong in killing rest of Muslims if they are so pathetic? When I say this , I mean this http://www.indianexpress.com/news/protests-against-afzal-gurus-hanging-at-jantar-mantar-21-detained/1071899/ Whole world knows that Afzal Guru was wrong except these sick Muslims. Even these educated Muslims feel that Afzal Guru was a hero and not a terrorist.     People say that we will try to talk with them. Most talks with Muslims have failed miserably. They either demand a Muslims state like of India , Kashmir and Egypt or convert rest of people to Muslims. What is wrong in killing rest of Muslims if they are so pathetic? When I say this , I mean this http://www.indianexpress.com/news/protests-against-afzal-gurus-hanging-at-jantar-mantar-21-detained/1071899/ Whole world knows that Afzal Guru was wrong except these sick Muslims. Even these educated Muslims feel that Afzal Guru was a hero and not a terrorist. Link to Questions, Topics, Blogs and People

  • Answer:

    First, Imagine I saw or know a person of religion X murder someone, should the punishment be given to you (assuming you are of religion X) just because someone of your religion had sin? Should you be killed? Second, what if a person decides to convert into Muslim? All of a sudden, he is eligible for death just because he starts chanting "Allah" instead of X's God. Third, I read somewhere, "Choose whom you hate carefully. You may become what you hated in the first place." Think what you are doing killing the innocents, you are becoming the very monster you were trying to eliminate. Fourth, find those Muslims who have killed people, bring them to trial and sentence them. There is a very thin line between good and evil. Hitler thought all "Jews" were bad and see what we witnessed.

Gagan Gupta at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

"An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind" -Mahatma Gandhi

Dharanish Kedarisetti

Because that would make you no different from them. You must know that many muslims in the world are at the best like us: they try to have an education and make a living. Killing innocent people, muslim or not, never has any justification

Śarada Kuchibhotla

Because it would be immoral to do so. The fact that someone who is a Muslim commits a crime does not change the innocence of everyone else who is a Muslim. Their human rights and their innocence is not affected by this. It does not matter whether those who do commit terrorism commit the terrorism because of their version of  or their (mis)understanding of Islam OR whether it is merely a coincidence. If you abhor terrorists who kill innocent civilians, becoming one of those terrorists yourself is the ultimate defeat by terrorism. You become that which you hate and instead of defeating your enemy, you have joined them and become one of them. "Better to light a candle than curse the darkness." To fight terrorism and reduce terrorism in the world, one must resist it. This may involve taking up arms against those engaging in terrorism (and not people "like" them or who "remind us of them" but actual imminent threats) AND by vigilance to stay true to higher morality and refuse to sink into terrorism oneself. Is it hard? Of course it is hard. In fact, many terrorist groups deliberately use this as a weapon. They engage in attacks designed to cause the other side to lash out at innocents. It helps one's recruiting efforts and "reveals" that the "enemy" (in this case you) are "just as bad" as the terrorists said you were. Don't make them right. Peace.

Eli Kass

There is a fundamental flaw in the framing of your question. A terrorist kills innocent people over some lame ideology. That terrorist can be of any caste, creed or religion. That doesn't mean that all the people who belong to that caste/creed/religion are terrorists. Hence, Muslims don't kill innocent people, terrorists do. Capisce??

Kushagr Goyal

You are basing your conclusion on a very erroneous premise. It is not their religion that is the cause. It is their mentality. The people you are referring to are sort of deranged in their own way, and it is the difference in opinion and perspective, and the need to act violently by some people, that has today resulted in terrorism. Whatever opinion you have of Muslims, are based on the actions of a select few. There is a legion of all communities out there that mimic the same action, and all from different religions and communities. Yet, there is a much larger Muslim population which only wants to live in peace, like a common person. And to answer your question, if we start behaving like them, what actually is the difference between terrorists and us peace lovers.

Abhishek Das

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.