Which Carnival cruise ship is best?

Carnival Dream, I have been on it twice it is so much fun. You can not go wrong with it. They have a freaking water park on board and everything, best cruise I have ever taken with any cruise line.

Well if you went out of Mobile then you'd be going on an older, smaller ship called the Fantasy. She got upgraded a little while ago but you can still tell she is the oldest ship in the fleet. I went on her over Christmas and enjoyed her immensely though. She would be a great choice. New Orleans has the Carnival Triumph which is basically identical to the Victory. I have no idea about how her service is or how her amenities are so your best bet is to ask yourself how you liked your Victory cruise. If you did then you would like the Triumph more than the Fantasy because of her greater size. The largest Carnival ship is only a little bigger than the Triumph so going out of your way to go on it (is is the Carnival Dream) isn't worth it. One of my favorite ports is Progreso, Mexico which we went to on the five night Fantasy cruise. It has a lot of nice features that other ports don't have.