If Jews claim Israel because "we lived there thousands of years ago", shouldnt Native Americans get land back?

Im a jew myself living in israel and we didn't get the land just because of our history. we got that land because jews came in the 1900's to that land and after it a lot of them joined when the world war II ended. i know that palestinians lived here as well but they disagree with the partition plan from the u.n and then it all began. syria jordan and egypt got independence in those years so that was the chance of israel. i think the land belong to whoever got authority to it. this is the logic

Interesting. And just what part did the U.S. play in the Holocaust (none), that it's so indebted to Israel and Israelis living in America and abroad???? What does the U.S. owe them? Why is the U.S. playing a favortism game with Israel being the favorite??? These are questions that will never be answered for some reason.

Okay, if we reenact history here as it took place in 1949, then I think the sequence of events would go something like this. 1949 - The UN passed the Palestine Mandate, 15 minutes later the surrounding arab nations invaded, 2011 - The UN passes the North American Mandate, and 15 minutes later, the surrounding states invade the indian reservations. Now, if the indians can defeat the invaders, the same way Israel defeated the invaders, then by all means, the indians should be allowed to keep what they can hold. But, seeing how the indians lost to the invaders before, and they have not really done much to improve their combat capabilities since losing the last war, I fear it would be a total slaughter of the indians. Is that what you really want? Are you advocating setting up a situation that will result in the complete genocide of the indian population? Wow, you really are a racist, you hate both indians and white people.

Now it is too late for both. The damage if any is already done. All around Europe there are countries that have been dominated several times by others. Go to history and you will be amazed how many countries have been under the rule of various nations. Still in the present time there are many countries in dispute specially by the larger nations. Also there are many areas among others like Cataluña in Spain and Corsica of France which are willing to secede from the dominating nation. The tendency since 1940 is that many countries are becoming republics. The number has increased to almost two hundred by now.

1. They don't screech. 2. By and large, they don't say they deserve it because they lived there thousands of years ago. They want to live there because they come from there. They claim Israel because they moved there and legally purchased the land back from the then current landholders. So, if Native Americans want to move back to their ancestral lands and legally purchase it back from current titleholders, I absolutely support their right to control the govt of those areas through democratic means, just as Israel has.