Is it dumb to give a girl a valentines day gift in high school if your not dating the girl but want to...?

I see no reason to say that's dumb. The Japanese do it. In fact, they have Valentine's Day AND White Day. There's a day for girls. There's a day for boys. And it's just as much about getting the one you love as it is about loving the one you have.

Well if you are talk to her alot then it isn't very dumb at all. She will actually think it is kinda cute. And if it is a good gift I mean one she really likes it will be very difficult for her to turn you down. I think it is a great idea. I wouldn't definitely go for it.

no! i think that its a great idea! i mean.. i think that its a good way to show her that you like her and i think that its really cute! cuz valentines day is supposed to be a day of 'love' and stuff! right?

Well i dont think its dumb but, im planning on doing the same exact thing wednsday. Proabably going to get some roses or carnations. That is if im able to get out of the house with all the snow we're supposed to get. Go for it man, a lot of girls would think its a really sweet thing to do.

I think thats a great idea. I know if I was the girl and I got a Valentine gift from someone that would really make my day. I say go for it. Don't go too expensive though. But don't ever think that is stupid, its very romantic if you ask me. Go for it, and good luck

No i don't see what's wrong with it. If she's single, she won't feel lonely anymore. Hey whatever works man.

No, it's a good way to ask her out. And if she doesn't already have a date, then she'll be particularly pleased that she has an admirer on V-day.

Nope, many men have entered the gold palace that way.

r u desperate?