Is it worth of doing MBA after BE(CSE)?

MBA from UCT...worth it?

  • I am from India and I have been accepted into the Graduate School of Business, University of Cape Town, MBA Full Time program.  Acceptance into the GSB-UCT MBA full time program ranks as one of the high points of my life and it thrills me beyond anything has in the recent past. But now that I have been accepted, I have some second thoughts revolving around cost, the job prospect, the future etc... Whatever I have saved will be enough to cover my living expenses but for the tuition, i would have to get a loan (about USD 40K).  I have a set of retired parents and I shudder at the prospect of asking them to dig into their hard-earned savings to help me pursue my goals. But, the fact is, world economy is precariously poised and a little jolt could send it plummeting into abyss. While I want to be optimistic about the future, I have to be a little pragmatic and ensure that I am not struggling for survival when and if the dreaded economic trough arrives. Being in a massive debt or worse, putting my parents under a massive debt is definitely not in my plans for a rainy day. Now, is the MBA program from UCT worth the risk? Is it worth taking out that loan? I would ideally want a job that pays me enough to pay off the loan in about an year or so. So...I would probably need a job outside India.  How difficult is it for Foreign UCT Graduates to find jobs in South Africa? How is UCT perceived outside of South Africa? Would it be possible to get a job in another country based on a MBA degree from Cape Town? Let me know! :)

  • Answer:

    The UCT MBA is arguably the best in Africa and amongst the best in the world. It enjoys an excellent reputation in South Africa and UCT as a University is well recognised globally. Congratulations on getting in. But that's the stuff you already know. Job prospects in South Africa are generally limited but the country faces a severe skills shortage. Sounds like a dichotomy but it is effectively a First World Economy (Services heavy, reliant on knowledge workers etc) with a developing world Labour force. So if you bring the right skills to the table getting a Job is not that tough as a foreigner. Be prepared for a strenuous work permit process (Job Advertisement, Rejected Candidates CV's, Police Clearance Certificates from every country you have lived in). An MBA essentially gets you your first job and gives you a network. UCT provides you with a solid South African Network. Depending on your experience you would be a perfect candidate for a South African company entering/with an existing presence in India. Everything from finance (Old Mutual), retail (Shoprite-Checkers), Quick Service Retail (Debonairs), Media & Entertainment (Naspers - OLX, MXIT etc) have a presence in India plus International Giants like GM, Unilever, Volkswagen etc cross cultivate their developing world staff so for them you maybe an interesting candidate based on your prior experience. But you are playing on probabilities here essentially if you are able to network locally and have relatively scarce skills its more likely than not that you will get a job post MBA.  I would not advise on taking a loan to do it unless you have a similar amount saved for a rainy day as a fail safe because who knows where the economy will be in 2 years time. The risk is immense and prospects on the local economy vary enormously depending on who you speak to. If you have gotten into a decent Indian program rather stick to that Indian company's only recognise Indian Qualifications at a premium (and a few select international programs). Long term with increased SA-India trade a UCT MBA will help a lot on in establishing a South African network that you can leverage later. It is an exceptionally well tailored course and is generally attended by experienced professionals in SA. So you will be attending classes withe the country's next set of business leaders. However your eventual decision will be based on what is the alternative?

Abhishek Das at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

I haven't personally done much research into the program, but I have had several friends do the UCT MBA (all South Africans) and they have unanimously had a fantastic experience and all walked into good jobs afterwards. One interesting thing to take into account is that the course is regarded as one of the best value MBAs available. The Finacial Times 2013 list ranks it as the second best value MBA in the world. http://rankings.ft.com/exportranking/global-mba-ranking-2013/pdf Aside from the course itself and the job prospects after completion, Cape Town is a wonderful city and a fantastic place to be based for a year.

Richard Marshall

Good answer above, I would only add that the combination of affirmative action laws and the onerous work permit process are pretty serious discouraging factors to companies considering hiring foreigners.  Some companies are used to it and are willing to do it and others are not, so that's a risk factor if you're looking to work in South Africa after graduation (where UCT obviously has a sterling reputation).  Bottom line, If you go for it you will get a great education in a fantastic city that should lead to a good job but is not guaranteed to do so right away.  Whether that makes sense given your financial situation I'm not sure.  As the previous poster said, it depends what your alternatives are.

Anne Haig May

Hi Richard The MBA was initially designed as a tool for getting engineers business functional. So the main courses teach (very) broad accounting, marketing, finance, operations, economics, HR, leadership... and tie them all together very nicely. But none of these are sufficient to compete with specialized professionals in these fields. In that strategic application an MBA can only be useful as a door opener from an already existing technical/specialist career. So unless you have a position in mind, the return on investment will most likely not materialize. People do however get MBA's for different strategic reasons. Entrepreneurial types get MBAs for a bit of extra credibility and/or the connections they meet, and don't really care about the coursework. Others use it as a personal development tool with only very general benefits. But unfortunately, it is a very risky investment whose payoff will depend largely on YOUR ability to use it as a differentiator (from other applicants), or YOUR ability to use it in getting value out of a business idea over anything you would have achieved without it. Radek

Radek Tanski

The latest global MBA ranking from the Financial Times shows that the University of Cape Town is the country’s top business institute in the country, and in Africa, as well as the best value for money MBA in the world. It is 52nd in the world. Information from: http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/university-of-cape-town http://businesstech.co.za/news/international/86570/sa-university-mba-rated-best-value-for-money-in-the-world/

Jesse Green

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.