Are there powerboat races around the world?

What are the real world equivalents of races described by Tolkien?

  • Is it possible to map the kingdoms and races described by Tolkien (The Hobbit, LotR) to real world empires and races? Somehow I have the feeling that each fictional race represents something deeper, some quintessential characteristics as expected from a historical race, but cannot say why.

  • Answer:

    The short answer is "not really". Anything that I say after that will be overstating the case. Tolkien hated allegory, and any statement of the form "The Xs are really Ys" would make him really, really cranky. So you really need to read the rest of this with the realization that "no" is the correct answer. Most notably, the Elves aren't anybody but Elves. The whole conceit of Tolkien's universe is that Elves were a real species who have diminished and disappeared. They're not inspired by any real-world people, but by myths which he made is own. The Orcs and Ents are similarly inspired by myths, not by any humans. In creating his other peoples, he might begin with a notion from the real world. The Rohirrim are definitely inspired by the Germanic peoples; they use Anglo-Saxon names and imagery. Rohirric poetry is alliterative verse, in the same style as Beowulf. They are a client kingdom of Gondor, which can be compared roughly to Rome. He once described Minias Tirith as "Byzantine"; that is, Constantinople, the eastern surviving part of the fallen Roman empire. Their enemies allude faintly to the enemies of Rome: from the East, people slightly like the Mongols and Huns. From the South, people a bit like Africans. But as I stressed earlier, it would be a serious error to equate the two. The Hobbits harken to a romanticized Victorian English countryside folk. And Tolkien admitted that he thought of the Dwarves as Jews: a displaced people living in other lands, speaking their own language to each other. Given the stereotype of greedy Jews and the Dwarves, a Nazi sympathizer tried to sound Tolkien out on anti-semitism, which he explicitly rejected: he said is name "is not Jewish in origin, though I should consider it an honour if it were." So, I really don't think it's fair to say that there are "deeper, quintessential characteristics as expected from a historical race". That's not how he worked. He sometimes drew ideas from the real world in places, but they were a starting point for his imagination, not a reality he was trying to shadow with allegory. This is important, because it would be very easy to try to extend the allegory, and stated that he would "regret giving any colour to the notion that I subscribed to the wholly pernicious and unscientific race-doctrine".

Joshua Engel at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Races? Maybe inspirations from different places who could know. How ever I can tell you Tolkien Grew up in the Orange Free State South Africa, and stated that the Misty  mountains in the LOTR trilogy was directly influenced by the Drakensberg Mountain. Direct translation. Dragon Mountain

Max Botha

Tolkien's "races" are really fantasy creatures from northern European mythology. Elves and Dwarves and Trolls and Orcs and Dragons are all straight out of the Icelandic and other sagas. They don't correspond to human races at all. However, some of his human peoples are inspired by, or at least informed by, real human people. The Southrons are black and fight with war elephants. Tolkien is using ideas from north Africa and Carthage. The Easterlings are a bit reminiscent of the Huns. The Rohirrim seem like Anglo-Saxons, except for the horse-fetish which is all their own.

Ernest W. Adams

I can make a list but it will be highly subjective and it's all my opinion, not Tolkien's. Numenor, I always thought that they are some kind of reflection of Roman Empire, so powerful that enemies surrenders. As Gondor, they are just like the last era of Byzantine Empire, remnant of an old, mighty Empire, still has some power and still respected. Harad, well it's easy, Elephants, black people, living in the deserts, joining the invaders, they are just like African people. Rhun, Easterlings, well I think they got a slight resemblance with Persia or Persian empires. Fought Western people, living in the east, large area, I don't know actually. Rohirrim, well it's a tricky one, I think Rohirrim is a hybrid. Their names and looks reminds Germanic tribes, but their lands, living at the steppes, close bonds with horses, and known as best horsemen of the world, I think they are some kind of hybrid of Huns and Germans. As Dwarves, I mostly think barbaric tribes of Vikings, but I think Jews as well.As Elves, I think they are the Greeks of Middle-Earth. Some of them good sailors, some of them perfect warriors, some of them wise folk, but in common, they are the leader of civilization of Middle-Earth, arts, culture, highly defensive, they influenced Men just like Greeks influenced Romans and they got weaker in time. As clans Noldor reminds me Spartans, proud, powerful and best warriors of their kind. Teleri and Vanyar reminds me Athenians, wise and advanced people, best sailors of their kind. 

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.