I love my friend or not.

What should I do if I'm in love with my boyfriend's best friend, who is also my best friend?

  • So my boyfriend & I have been together for about 5 years, & have a child together as well who is 2 years old... I love my boyfriend but I feel very distant with him, like feelings went away between him & I. & i have been planning to move out of me & my boyfriends home... Well my boyfriend & I have a friend who is very close to both my boyfriend & I, well a couple weeks ago the friend admitted & told me that he had feelings for me, well before the friend told me I felt like I started having feelings for him. So when he told me he liked me of course I told him I liked him to.. Well we started kinda secretly "talking" & I feel Like I fell in love with him. We kissed a couple times & flirted & kinda acted like we were together when my boyfriend wasn't around. Well my boyfriend found out about this & I told my boyfriend nothing really happened other than us telling each other out feelings, & the plan between the friend and I was that once I moved out that we would then talk about the possibility of Dating. Well after my boyfriend finding out about the feelings between the friend & I now the friend has told me that he doesn't want to date me in fear of my boyfriend not bein his friend anymore but I really want the friend, he makes me 100% happy & is probably the most amazing guy I have ever met..& he treats me alot better than my boyfriend... But now I don't know what to do .? My boyfriend & him are still friends even after the truth had been said about the feelings, but I don't think I can handle only having a friendship with the friend, I want more than that.! I don't know if I should just move & forget any possibility of me an the friend or move and then try to be with the friend.? I'm so confused an broken over this... I kinda feel like if i moved and tried then i might Have a chance but then again I don't wanna loose the friendship me and him have.! Please help .??   Also wanna add the few times I've kissed the friend and every minute spent with him feels amazingly perfect.! Like its supposted to be me & him.!!!

  • Answer:

    It sounds to me like you are obsessing over the friend because you don't want to deal with the challenges of your current relationship. Stop that.   Your relationship is in trouble. Either repair it so it can continue happily, or end it. Both of these choices require focused attention. If you end the relationship, you need to rearrange your life so you're no longer living with him. You also need to work out how to have a functional non-romantic co-parenting relationship with him. Only when you have completed that should you be thinking about dating someone else.   So set aside your thoughts of this attractive friend. That will be difficult, but you can do it. Focus on yourself and your child. Decide what to do about your relationship, which shouldn't have anything to do with your crush. It sounds like you want to leave him, so leave him. Once the dust settles, you can start thinking about what to do next. Do you want to remain single for a while? Do you want to check in with the attractive friend and see if he's changed his mind? Do you want to date someone else?   Also, if you haven't learned this already, let me be the first to tell you: Just because a few stolen kisses "feel amazingly perfect" doesn't mean you are "supposed to be" with someone. They feel amazingly perfect because they're illicit and new and exciting, and you're frustrated and bored. You cannot judge real compatibility based on the initial rush of attraction, especially not when that initial rush of attraction takes place in circumstances like this.

Claire J. Vannette at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

This is really messy. Obviously the friend doesn't equally share the same feelings for you because he is choosing his friendship with his best friend over you. And of course everything seems amazing with the friend now. It's new!!! It's different!!! Don't let that blind you with the realities of life. Things change, people change and this feeling that you're having now will change. You have a child to think about now, it's not all about you anymore. I think you should forget the whole thing...at least for now. Move out and figure things out on your own. The relationship you have with your boyfriend is forever tainted. You don't love him, let him go so he can find someone who does.

Tricia Hosein

Let me tell you that I am a traditionalist when it comes to relationships, specially if there is a young kid involved. I believe that any relationship, no matter how old, is a work in progress. You have to constantly work on it to make it work. With this philosophy, here is my take on your situation. l don't think any 5 year old relationship with a 2 year old kid can ever hope to have 'spark' in it - at least not in the way a new relationship has. So what you are missing is probably non existent in the real world. The high that the new guy gives you is probably less than what your current boyfriend gave you when you decided you want to have a child with him. Think about that. What have you done to save and repair your relationship with your current boyfriend? Have you taken a week off for a trip - just the 3 of you? tried to really talk it out?  Tried a one week break from him? Visited a relationship counselor? This is a relationship -not an iphone that you can upgrade just because it dose not 'wow' you enough now! Half the reason for the excitement and attraction could be because new guy is the 'Forbidden Fruit' - are you sure that this will sustain? The new guy - he is reluctant. Even if you manage to bulldoze him and get him to accept you, do you think you will be able to assuage his guilt on cheating on his best friend in the long term? That is like trying to buying a house pre fitted with a land mine! How long is this new thing? Two weeks! You are comparing two weeks with a 5 year relationship? That's not love - that's called a crush! If you have to end the relationship with your current boyfriend - do it gracefully. What you are trying to do right now is called backstabbing. If you have ever loved him - do think of the fact that your plans, if successful,will result in his girl friend walking out AND his son being taken away AND his best friend leaving him.This triple whammy might destroy him completely (I am assuming you will get the child) As pointed out by if you have to leave him, your first priority should be on working out how are you going to minimize the impact of this on the child and then think about another relationship. Please remember that all long term relationships with kids loosely follow what is known as the 'W' curve. (I couldn't find a picture so I quickly drew one - not very nicely drawn but gets the point across) So what you are hitting is probably the first low of your relationship - Things are probably gonna get better now! Just give it some more time. Thanks for the A2A!

Mitesh Jain

Okay. You need to step back. STEP BACK NOW. Think about it. In reality you need to figure out what's going on with you, your son and your soon to be ex-husband. DO NOT get into a new relationship before ended your current one. This seems like a really fucked up situation but if this new guy feels as much for you as you do for him then he will tell your husband the truth and you two will be together, further down the line. Get your priorities straight and also do what's right for your child. What your feeling for the other guys may just be lust also. Give it some time. Settle down away from you husband and then bring him around.

Alicia Cruise

"Well  after my boyfriend finding out about the feelings between the friend  & I now the friend has told me that he doesn't want to date me in  fear of my boyfriend not bein his friend anymore" well this alone is clue enough that your friend won't choose you over your boyfriend. In case you decide to break up with your boyfriend, I'm seeing you'll be by yourself while your ex boyfriend and your friend will be hanging out in a bar, looking for girls, and having the best time of their lives. Also, you cheated when you were supposed to be rekindling your relationship with your boyfriend. Think about that.

Robbie Antonio

I willing to bet you became depressed after giving birth and the ensuing first year or two were very hectic and in you desire to be a good mom there is a sense about you that you lost what it was that you were or wanted to be. It's possible that you had an injection of oxytocin to increase labor speed during child birth and that has had a negative effect, perhaps even causing colic to the child, or postpartum on some level. Additionally the important thing to note is that what actually also happened in this case as with many others is that the emotional bond between partners suffers terribly, a woman who has a child is afterwords assaulted by her body's hormones most of the time. The emotional bond of oxytocin is associated with your partners initial moments of forming commitments and kind gestures of lovey dovey wovey teddy bear goodness. The times have made him smile less perhaps, perhaps his intentions are pure and he has put the baby before you thinking it what you would want, or perhaps your low oxytocin levels suspended your connection with reality in some way and you are living life with some false assumptions about reality and what is true. Perhaps he feels abandoned but cares enough that he was willing to give you time and in this case it was time enough to form a novel bond because repairing the one you have requires fixing what is wrong and creating a new one based on how both of your lives are now very different. Also, there is fringe speculation that a side effect of birth control is when you stop taking it your ability to connected through your primary bond is severed and you become stranded and must feel alone or seek a novel connection. I hope any of the babbling was actually helpful, I'm sorry I won't even approach giving someone any advice, I don't advise you take anything but knowledge and wisdom and see what fits with what your soul tells you is toward the light. :-)

Jason Bogovich

A relationship is like a fixed deposit. It's value increase with time. Think a lot, a lot before you pull the plug on a 5 year long relationship for one that's a few weeks old. Read this: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2263518/I-left-love-life-I-thought-I-better-Now-Im-childless-42.html. Think a million times before ending a relationship as stable as yours has been. If you do decide to end it, the new guy doesn't look like a great reason for it. The "This is it" feeling that you get is nothing other than infatuation or what is called "romantic love" in psychology terms. This phase of a relationship has been found to have the same effects on the human brain as addictive drugs. http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2011/02/11/the-science-of-romance-the-love-drug/ DO NOT trust your decisions on this guy. They're influenced by your "high". Besides he's already made his position clear. He doesn't want to be with you if that costs him his friend. Even if he does get in a relationship with you in case you break up with your current boyfriend - this issue is likely to keep on causing strains between the two of you for a very long time now, and might even cause an end to the relationship. I understand the friend is an irresistible attraction to you now (exactly like addictive drugs :D). There's no quick way out of this, apart from not seeing him at all for a few months now. If needed ask for your boyfriend's help. Tell him you want to make this relationship work, and because of your feelings the friend is causing you distraction. Tell him you don't want to see the friend for some time now. Tell him you want to overcome your feelings and are working wholeheartedly towards it. In the meantime try to make your current relationship work by putting in the required efforts. http://www.loveinindia.co.in/11-proven-ways-keep-relationship-fresh-new-exciting/ Like one of the other answers here mentions, long relationships are bound to hit lows from time to time. It's NOT going to be as exciting and stimulating as your first year together - probably ever. Think about whether you're ready to sacrifice stability and long-term happiness for momentary excitement. I think not.

Sulagna Dasgupta

Chose the one who forever will make you happy, in this case, the best friend. But don't forget the kid, at least you should be loyal with the kid.

Arghya Ghosh

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.