Find solution
How would you handle a special handling situation in the absence of any information or proper documentation?

What kind of information should young children be protected from?

  • The coyotes are eating the cats! I'm wondering how parents should go about judging what information their children should be protected from. Clearly there are many types of information that children should obviously be protected from, but there seem to be some grey areas as well, and it is those types of information that my question addresses. This question came to mind because of a recent situation. Coyotes have been preying on cats in our neighborhood for some time, and recently when I spoke of this aloud at the park in front of my 4-1/2 year-old daughter and two other kids who are about 6 and 8, their father started whispering about it to signal to me that this isn't something he wanted them to know about. I'm usually pretty mindful about what I say to whom, so I felt bad that I had done something careless, but I also realized that my approach to handling this information with my daughter was very different from the approach of the father of the two older children. As far as I can tell, the fact that coyotes are preying on cats doesn't disturb my daughter at all. We don't have cats and the other kids do, so that could be one reason their father is more protective about the information. But I think it's also possible I am intentionally more open about such information so that my daughter can grow and mature without being overly sheltered. I know that there's room for personal preference, cultural differences, etc. in parents determining how open to be about information that might be in some way disturbing or troubling to a child, and certainly I always err on the side of caution (including not saying something, or presenting it in a gentler way, such as saying "preying on cats" instead of "eating cats"), and the capacity of the child himself/herself to handle such information is of course a big factor as well, but I wonder if there is anything I am missing in thinking about this topic. For example, is it possible that coyotes preying on cats is disturbing to my daughter without me realizing it? She has shown no signs of it troubling her, and in fact she's very aware of the concept of food chains and who is predator and who is prey. I think the obvious answer to my question is each parent needs to make their own subjective determination, but I'm wondering if there is anything more than that guideline that parents would be advised to know about. What also would be helpful is some specific examples of such information that other parents have had to decide whether to share with their children and how they made their decision about whether to share it. I don't think I've faced this type of issue often because most information has been clearly black or white in terms of whether my daughter should know about it, but I can see the possibility of other information in the future falling into a grey area, thus my interest in input from other parents on this topic. Thank you.

  • Answer:

    We don't have cats and the other kids do, so that could be one reason their father is more protective about the information. But I think it's also possible I am intentionally more open about such information so that my daughter can grow and mature without being overly sheltered. Your family does not own a cat; there is no coyote threat to your family. His family does own a cat, and there is no need for his kids to be freaked out that their cat may be eaten by coyotes. That is not "overly sheltered" - that is the stuff of childhood nightmares. While you don't want to protect your daughter from broad information, you (like other parents) probably want to protect her from trauma. You know best whether your kid will be traumatised by a dead squirrel or seeing grandma in the hospital or attending an open-casket funeral or burying fluffy's mangled body in the back yard. I think an example of this is how many MeFites recently posted about the many parents who told them "Fido went to live on a farm" and only realised decades later that Fido had in fact died. Some parents will shelter their kids from that kind of personal upset; others will decide that learning to deal with grief and loss is part of the lessons of childhood. Neither I nor the "Fido farm" people are less able to cope with death or more naive or anything else as adults; these are calls parents make based, I assume, largely on the personalities of their children. I don't think there can be one universal guideline.

Dansaman at Ask.Metafilter.Com Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Hey, it is what it is. The father in question gave you the signal, you picked up what he was putting down. You respected his decision to not freak his kids out, and that's cool. You don't want to be that parent who ruins Santa for the rest of the kids because you're a "realist". But you can draw the line at the absurd, babies coming from a cabbage patch for example. Most folks are pretty good at getting across distress if you wander into territory they haven't covered with their kids. So talk away, but be on the lookout for the subtle signs that the other person would like you to change the subject.

Ruthless Bunny

In this case, about the coyotes, I wonder if the other family might have a cat go missing recently (coyotes or not). The father's reaction sounds like my neighbor's reaction when he told me about his son's dog being hit by a car; he didn't want his son to hear our conversation. Whatever guidelines you use, there's always the risk that even perfectly age-appropriate talk will be upsetting to a particular child (or adult) because of his or her own life and experiences. And there's no way to know that before you know it.

orange (sherbet) rabbit

FWIW, I don't think you did anything careless here; what you were talking about is a fact of the animal world without moral connotations. It was the dad's job in that case to field questions from his kids or to talk it over with them to see if they were disturbed. Chances are he was more disturbed than they were by the story. To answer your question, although it sounds like you're already being pretty cautious, topics I would watch out for: * People-on-people violence * Gruesome or disturbing facts ("coyotes preying on cats" isn't gruesome by itself, without more details) * Detailed talk about horror/scary movies or stories. I was in a convenience store this weekend; on a rack at kid eye-level was a DVD with a cover that scared the bejeezus out of me. I can only imagine seeing it at the age of 5 or so. * Detailed talk about sex.

Currer Belfry

It isn't just parental preference either, it is dependent on the kids too. I agree that you didn't do anything wrong but anecdotally you could have told me coyotes eat cats when I was 6 and I would have accepted that as a fact of nature. If you had told my 6 year old brother the same thing he would have had a meltdown of epic proportions because that boy LOVED cats in a highly emotional way.

magnetsphere

Basically violence or sex. Where you draw the line on those two continuums is the question, and I don't think you can accurately predict where another random parent/family will draw their lines. Also, the make-believe-ness of your various holiday mascots (Santa, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy, etc.).

Rock Steady

Some kids are more sensitive than others, so I would let that guide me. You know your kids, but you don't know other people's kids, so I would stay on the side of caution with other kids, and speak what you are comfortable with with your kids. As a data point, I was very sensitive to animals at that age and would talk to them and believe I had a deep connection with them. The coyote information would have set my imagination running, visualizing the deaths, imagining my cat being taken by them, etc. (kids have intense and creative inner worlds) That being said, if it was explained to me in some fashion that spoke to my fears and allowed me to understand the risks in life without feeling powerless about it, it might have been o.k. (but I kinda doubt it).

Vaike

Something to keep in mind is that parents will sometimes be overly cautious about specific topics that they know will upset their own children for personal reasons. I grew up on a farm, and things like coyotes eating cats is just a fact of life and wouldn't be censored from kids. But, I was an extreme cat lover from an early age, and I could see my parents shushing conversation about something like that because they would know I would get upset and lose sleep about losing one of my cats (and as parents, you don't want the struggle of soothing a possible overreaction from fear when it can easily be prevented in the first place).

Eicats

It probably depends on the kids as well though. I doubt that there's an objective answer because some very sensitive kids might be disturbed at 10 whereas some kids will never find it disturbing. Obviously it was something that the father of the older kids thought they couldn't cope with but that's a completely separate issue from what your child is able to cope with.

Laura_J

I was just having this conversation elsewhere re: a children's book that talks about the September 11 attacks. At what point do you tell your kid that passenger planes crash sometimes (accidentally and/or on purpose)? At what point do you tell your kids that cars crash sometimes? What happens the next time you go on a plane or in a car? At what point do you tell your kids about gun violence - friends told me that their young daughter was told at school, after the shootings at Sandy Hook, that "if she hears thunder inside to go play hide-and-seek", which struck me as dreadful on a whole bunch of levels. The point, as everyone says above, is that there are no rules about these things, and part of parenting is figuring this out for your own family. To the extent that you can respect that other people are doing the same for their own families, as you did, the easier it is all around.

judith

Load more

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.