Should I see the school psychiatrist?
-
My professor is requiring that I see the school psychiatrist. What should I do? Sorry, this is terribly long, but I feel that the back story is necessary to understanding why I was referred to the school psychiatrist in the first place. I am in school for a health career that involves interaction with patients. We has an assignment to interview patients in groups in a hospital, and our teacher asked for a volunteer to do a solo interview that she would personally observe. Nobody was volunteering, and I thought it would be good practice, so I volunteered to interview the patient solo. I was significantly more nervous about being observed than I thought I would be, and could feel my hands shaking. The patient had an incredibly complex history, and I wanted to do a good job, so I took copious notes to try to keep track of the details of their many issues. I realized that in an effort to understand the patients multiple issues, I had deviated from the usual interview structure, and skipped a few important questions. I looked back at my professor to see if she had any feedback. I was nervous and could tell that the interview was not going well. My professor was frowning. I wasn't sure how to interpret that, but I figured the worst thing would be to miss an important piece of information, so I asked the patient more questions, I asked the questions that I had skipped, and attempted to gather as much information as possible. It was the worst interview I had ever done, but I felt that I got all the necessary information. After the interview, my professor took me aside and said "That was terrible. How have you even made it this far?" She explained that I went too long, was disorganized, and that she didn't understand how I had been allowed to pass my courses related to patient care. I tried to apologize, and explain that I was extremely nervous, and that this wasn't typical for me. I agreed that I was disorganized, said that was something I was practicing to try to improve, and asked if she had any specific suggestions. She just kept shaking her head and saying "That was really really bad. I thought you could do this, but clearly you can't." I was particularly hurt because she had taught a course on building empathy. I had been in a discussion group with this professor, and we has confessed our deepest fears and anxieties. This professor had a reputation for being cold, but I gradually came to trust her. I thought she had gotten a bad rap - she seemed like a shy but caring person, a good listener, and very human. That's why I was so shocked that her feedback was so negative. I told her I was going to practice interviewing with a special eye for organization, and asked her again for specific suggestions on how I can improve. She said that I took too many notes, and went too long. "You weren't present at all! You weren't even listening to the patient! You didn't have any empathy at all. How did you have us all fooled?" That hurt a lot. As much as I tried to fight it, my eyes started watering. She said that I would need to be monitored closely by the faculty, and I nodded and said "I just want to improve. I'll do whatever you think will improve my performance." That week I met with a classmate, and worked on organization and timing. I practiced with a family member. I tried to improve my performance. I think I am an empathetic person, but I practiced expressing empathy verbally. It came time for another evaluation, and I was shitting bricks. I didn't know who would be observing me (this time behind a two way mirror), but I knew they would be watching me closely. I interviewed the standardized patient. I did almost everything in the correct order. I payed careful attention to time. I took minimal notes. I listened to the patient and made extra sure to thank them for sharing their information, and to mirror back what they were saying so that the could correct me if I had something wrong. When they mentioned that they were in pain, I reassured them that we would do everything possible to find out what was causing it, and work to help make them comfortable. I was incredibly nervous, but I thought the interview went pretty well. When my evaluator came out, she asked me how I thought I did. I said I thought I did okay, but mentioned the things I did out of order, and mentioned a few small steps I had skipped. She said that she had been asked to watch me by the other professor, but that she was surprised at how well I did, that my performance didn't fit the description given to her by the first professor at all. I thanked her, but I was really embarrassed. She asked why I thought I had done so poorly the first time, and I said that I had been very nervous. She asked if the hospital setting had made me nervous, and even though I didn't think that was the main problem, I said yes. I didn't want to say that I get anxious about being scruitinized, because there will be many more instances in my academic career when I will be observed and critiqued. She asked why hospitals made me nervous, and I said I was worried about saying something insensitive to a patient who is coping with a lot of pain or a life threatening illness. I told her that I had a family member who had been hospitalized, and had complained about the way they had been treated by staff. I told her that I didn't want to cause patients any more stress than necessary. She said that I was very different from she had expected from the other patient's email. I was so incredibly embarrassed at this point that I started tearing up again. She seemed concerned and said that if I cry that easily, I was in for a rough couple of years as I advanced in my training. She suggested that I seek therapy to work through my issues. I nodded, but didn't tell her that I am already seeing a therapist regularly. I recently got an email from the first professor saying that to pass the class, I will need to meet with the school psychiatrist to "assess my attitudes and emotional well being." So here's the rub. I have seen the school psychiatrist, and I really don't want to see her again for a number of reasons, including that I don't trust that the sessions are confidential. During sessions, she would leave my prescriptions in the common copy machine that she shares with the first professor as well as a dozen other administrators. One time she left my prescriptions there for for over 30 min, even though I asked if she could move them someone more private. She has also accused me of lying. During a session last year, I asked for my usual prescription of 150mg of an antidepressant. She said that according to her notes said I was taking 300 mg. I said that I had only ever taken 150 mg, and that she had prescribed me 150 mg in the past, but she said I was trying to exert control and wrote me a script for 300 mg. I thought I might have been mistaken about the, but when I got home I saw that my previous prescription was indeed for 150mg. I knew it would be very hard to get another appointment with her, so I took the 300 mg and was loopy for a month until I saw her again. When I saw her, I tried to explain I was having terrible side effects, and that 300 mg was too much. She said I was perseverating and paranoid. I told her I felt terrible, and asked her to look at her notes to see that she had prescribed me 150 mg in the past. She looked at her notes, and saw that I had indeed been taking 150 mg. She asked me: "Why did you tell me you were taking 300 mg?" I said "I didn't." She rolled her eyes, and I decided not to argue with her. So I have to schedule an appointment to talk to her about my emotional well-being and I really don't want to. Since the middle of last year I have been seeing a different psychiatrist who is not affiliated with my school, and he has been treating me for Generalized Anxiety Disorder. I haven't yet told him about this situation because I have been away on break, but I will see him again next week. I don't know what to do. It seems like I should suck it up and see the school psychiatrist, but at this point I feel like anything I say can, and will be used against me. What do you suggest I do? If you want to contact me, my temporary email is [email protected]
-
Answer:
Express your concerns to the dean of students. Seriously, that is their job.
anonymous at Ask.Metafilter.Com Visit the source
Other answers
Seconding cnanderson. It is time to go over the top on both the professor and the psychiatrist. Assuming you are in the US, the psychiatrist is violating HIPAA guidelines by leaving confidential patient information in public areas (i.e. prescription in a common copy machine). If that psychiatrist has been discussing this with your professor without your consent, that risk for them losing their license. This is serious. Also: tell your psychiatrist that you have been seeing the entire thing. Print this off and hand it to him.
Mister Fabulous
IAAP, albeit not in this field. Unless you're in a discipline in which "see the school psychiatrist on command" is accepted practice (and/or are not in the USA), your first professor has violated all sorts of standard regs up the wazoo. Suggesting that a student see the SP if they are having serious emotional issues is one thing; requiring them to do so is another plate of beans entirely. Refuse and complain. However, speaking as someone who is also in a department-level administrative position, please ascertain the chain of command before filing a complaint. If you try to jump several rungs in the bureaucratic ladder, all that will happen is that you'll be bumped down to the proper starting point--except that the starting point will now be ticked that you went over their head. The most likely place to begin for your prof is with the department chair.
thomas j wise
"That was terrible. How have you even made it this far?" You weren't present at all! You weren't even listening to the patient! You didn't have any empathy at all. How did you have us all fooled?" This is the professor that teaches an *empathy* course? Go over her head.
notsnot
This is like something out of Gaslight. With the exception of the second evaluator, I'd say you are stuck between two nasty people who have their own issues. I think both of them should be the ones being evaluated, not you. Why would your professor require you to see the school psychiatrist when by law prof is not allowed to get any information under HIPAA? If the psychiatrist can't tell her anything, what's the point? So that you feel better about yourself? Sounds like you are doing that by seeing another (less wackadoodle) person. My gut reaction is to push back - NICELY - to prof and say hey, thanks for your suggestion, I am seeing a psychiatrist (just not crazy psycho school one) and I will make it a point to discuss this issue with that person. If she raises more of a stink, I would kindly remind her of HIPAA regulations and the fact that even if you did see wackadoodle school psychiatrist, she's prohibited from sharing anything (or damn well should be). Good luck!
Leezie
I think you should write a letter to the first professor thanking her for her feedback (yeah, she was a bitch, but that's how she is, apparently, and she did provide some feedback that was relevant to your work) and letting her know that you are working with a therapist on these issues. If she pushes back on why it's not the school psychiatrist, reiterate that you are choosing to work with someone else you feel more comfortable with. If she continues to push on you using the school psychiatrist, go over her head on this issue.
ThePinkSuperhero
I am also a professor, not in your field, and I literally sat here with my jaw hanging open as you related the outrageously inappropriate and intrusive behavior of your professor. As others have noted, if a student came to me with a problem or appeared to be seriously distressed, I might let her/him know about the availability of counseling services. Never in a billion years could any prof at my school get away with requiring a student to get medical evaluation or treatment in order to pass a course. If a student appears to be seriously ill or a danger to self or others, my college -- and I'm sure yours -- has a defined procedure a prof can initiate to determine if intervention is needed, but that would never be unilateral or tied to someone's academic performance. And all this because you had an attack of performance anxiety during an evaluation that would cause many beginners to react the same way? Ridiculous. I wouldn't volunteer the information to her that you have your own therapist because your private medical situation is none of this prof's business. Do try to get the professor to confirm the "therapy requirement" either in writing via e-mail or orally in the presence of others. Then contact her department office or check the school's website to find out the standard procedure for reporting a problem you're having with a prof. Yes, university officials are protective of faculty in part because we receive a lot of frivolous complaints, but there have been plenty of times that my department head and dean have taken a very well-meaning, honorable prof aside and said, "Um, this requirement in your syllabus (or this thing you told a student to do)?" You can't legally do that, so stop." And the stringent terms of HIPAA regulations look like nothing compared to FERPA, which we are constantly reminded to be careful of.
FelliniBlank
I'm not certain how your school works, but I cannot imagine a scenario at a traditional college or university where your professor has the right to demand you seek medical care before granting you academic credit.
Adam_S
- I don't understand why you took that medication once you confirmed the dosage was incorrect. For an entire month. With terrible side effects. Please talk this choice you made over with your therapist. - Unless the rest of your school/program is primo grade A++, please think about transferring. Sometimes institutions or organizations take on deeply dysfunctional characteristics, and where you go to school qualifies. Sometimes being in the right environment makes all the difference. If you can't sort this out easily with the Dean of Students or whoever, don't see it as your failure, but do move on.
jbenben
Just -- be prepared that if you go to their direct supervisors, the direct supervisors could push back hard on you, *especially* if they do see that wrong was done, in an effort to cover their own butts. I once went to the head of my university's health clinic to make them aware of a patten of problems I'd had with one nurse practitioner -- she seemed forgetful and discombobulated to the point where I was concerned - writing prescriptions in incorrect amounts, writing prescriptions for the completely wrong thing, a bunch of things along those lines. I didn't come in in a hostile way, more like "hey, this is something you might want to be aware of." The degree to which this person pushed back on me was *insane,* looking for any way that all these incidents were actually my fault. So, just be prepared for the fact that something like that might happen, and don't let it stop you from looking for help with this.
Ashley801
Related Q & A:
- Where should I go and what should I see in Europe?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why can't I see any of my messages that I send on Yahoo messenger?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How do I see my avatar when I log into mail?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How can I see how many words I've typed?Best solution by libroediting.com
- How can I see the people I may know on myspace?Best solution by ChaCha
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.