What is the best hybrid bike to use as a commuter bike?

New bike commuter with questions!

  • This past weekend, I purchased my first road bike. My long term goal is to cycle to/from work every day. I’ve taken the bike on a few exploratory rides, been humbled by my general fitness level, and came away with a number of questions I hope you all can answer. (Many more details inside. (This ended up much longer than I thought it would.)) Last week, my cheap, way-too-small, mountain bike collapsed in on itself. The repair shop I took it too basically told me it’d cost about as much to fix as the bike was worth. So I’ve taken this as a sign to finally get off my ass and A. upgrade to a bike that fits me, and B. start using it to commute. For the past year I’ve been semi-commuting on the old bike: I drive to within about a mile of work (free parking!), and then ride in the last mile. The total commute that I’d be ramping up to is about 7 miles each way. I know this isn’t very far, but A. I’m a smoker (I know, I know), and B. there are steep, mile-long hills to slog through on each side of the commute. So, what are your tips and tricks for hill climbing? Is this just a case of grin and bear it? Get a little farther up the hill each day until I’ve conquered it? Are there specific exercises I can do while on level roads to help with the later hill climbing? The second major question I have is more about comfort. And appropriate clothing. My immediate concern is the seat. This is the first time I’ve had a hard seat, and man is my ass sore. The day after I bought the bike, I took it for a 15 mile ride. (The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom!) About halfway through, I realized my mistake, but there was no hope for it, I had to ride home. Now, two days later, while still tender, I no longer wince when sitting down. What are going to be my best options to mitigate that pain until my body adjusts to the harder seat? Will it adjust? I’ve been told that those harder, thinner seats provide much more control and stability, and that yes, I’ll be sore for about a month, but it will pass. What about the padded bike shorts? How much do they help? Do they completely negate the benefits of the hard seat? Ok. Enough for now. Though if you have any other advice for a new bike commuter, I’d love to hear it.

  • Answer:

    So, what are your tips and tricks for hill climbing? Gear down and spin your pedals. Idealy, you want to be spinning the pedals around 90 times a minute---this number is called cadence. If your cadence is too low, it means you're pushing too hard and are at greater risk of injury: blown knees are the most common, but hamstrings are also a big possiblility. To get your cadence up, 90 rpm is much faster than you might think, you need to gear down. Try to stay seated when you climb too. It will be hard at first, but will help develop leg strength. What are going to be my best options to mitigate that pain until my body adjusts to the harder seat? Padded bike shorts will help a lot. You can wear them as underwear if you don't want to parade around in spandex, though that is more comfortable. Seat fit is important, but it can take http://www.sheldonbrown.com/saddles.html to understand what the best fit should be. It's normal to go through a bunch of seats before you find one that suits you. You want a seat that supports the bony, hard parts of your pelvis (the http://www.epicidiot.com/sports/bicycle_saddles.htm) but also one that doesn't push or chafe on the soft bits. This is why http://www.jimlangley.net/crank/bicycleseats.html. The best way to do this is to work with your bike shop and find a solution that works for you. It might take a few returns to get this right. Though if you have any other advice for a new bike commuter Try to carry an extra tube, a pump/CO2 cylinder and a tire lever or two at minimum. They've saved my bacon a few times in the morning. Learning to dress for the weather is also important. My rule is that you should be slightly chilly when standing still. That way, when you're warmed up, you'll be at the right temperature and biking is more fun. When you get more into it, consider shoes and clip pedals. Best upgrade to biking ever.

Barmecide at Ask.Metafilter.Com Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

As someone who velo-commutes and, since giving up my car 2+ years ago, bikes everywhere, I approve of all the advice above. I have a only a few things to add: 1. I totally re-affirm that the most important thing is to just keep riding; your body will adapt. A lot of advice you've been given is a wee bit technical and in-depth. The thing with bikes, if you keep turning the cranks, you keep moving forward; everything else is commentary. 2. My trick with dealing with hills is to remember the advice my Dad gave me when he started dragging me out on 60 mile rides when I was 12 (thanks Dad, sorry I complained so much), "Throw yourself at hills." The faster you are going at the bottom of a hill, the faster and easier you go up it. So when you're in rolling hill territory, the trick is to never ever coast down a hill. Pedal your damn heart out so you have all the momentum you need to make the next hill your bitch. Dad also used to say, "I like hills, they give me something to do," but that's just because he's an insane masochist. 3. Ride bikes. Have fun.

Panjandrum

"B. there are steep, mile-long hills to slog through on each side of the commute." When my husband started bike-commuting and had to conquer a hill, our Dutch friend looked at him like he was crazy and informed us that when commuting and faced with a hill, the bicycle-loving Dutch jump off and walk. There are no awards for conquering hills in a commute setting, and they may make you stink when you get to work.

Eyebrows McGee

Slap a Maxie Pad in the crotch of your undies and Voilà!... padded shorts ;-). Seriously, you DO have to harden your ass, so to speak. Just ride a little bit at a time and don't over-do it. I ride a http://www.profile-design.com/titec/products/saddles/el-norte/el-norte-expert.html saddle on all my bikes including my road bike. Technically it's a downhill mountain bike saddle, however here is my theory on bike fit ergonomics... Bikes are static and somewhat rigid, the human body is not. So don't try to force anything and give yourself options. That said, the El Norte is a long saddle with padding along it's entire length. This gives you the option of scooting back and forth along it a centimeter at a time or so to provide varying positions and to work different muscle areas (little things like a centimeter or a degree in angle make HUGE differences on bike fit). It's a common misconception that a wider saddle helps, however it simply interferes with the pedaling motion and creates sore spots. As for hill climbing... I've heard it said that your quadriceps (thigh muscles) are the strongest in the body. I'm not sure about that but I do know that when you isolate that muscle group while riding it makes you instantly more efficient. Here's how to do it... "Quiet" your upper body as much as possible while riding, then concentrate on bringing your knees as close together while pedaling, even grazing your bike's top tube with every stroke as a measure of how close you are getting. You are now pumping using the muscles right above your knee caps. Try this and then try pedaling as bow legged as you can and you'll instantly feel the difference in efficiency. Then, when you need the power on a hill or any other time, bring those knees in. (If you observe other riders for this aspect you can almost always tell the difference between a cyclist who trains and positions and one who just lolly-gags along).

No Shmoobles

A granny gear would be a small front and/or a large rear gear. A larger front gear will make it harder to pedal.

Carbolic

Oh! And if you have a smartphone, and want to turn this into a game (ie. to beat yourself), download http://runkeeper.com/home, and record each commute to keep track of how you're doing.

schmod

No matter what the weather, clothing that wicks makes a huge difference, especially as a base layer. This can be proper cycling gear, or just whatever cheap exercise or hiking gear you can find. I don't wear padded shorts for my commute, but without wicking underwear I get swamp crotch and saddle sores. REI has a nice selection. Your tires probably take Presta valves (the skinny kind). It's a good idea to replace one of your valve caps with a http://bicycletutor.com/presta-valve/ so if you're out without a pump you can fill up at a gas station or a bike shop's free air hose. If I'm sweaty when I get to work I clean up with a washcloth at the sink if I can. Otherwise, I use http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B002PA382U/metafilter-20/ref=nosim/. Or actually, I used up my bottle so I just made my own mix of ethyl alcohol, witch hazel and a little water.

hydrophonic

If you want to hit a certain cadence but don't want to invest in a bike computer that tracks cadence, use a song! When I'm not sure what my cadence is, I sing "Santeria" by Sublime, which has about 90 bpm, and adjust accordingly. I am not a crackpot.

mskyle

Thank you all. I'm ok with walking up part of the hill, I'll certainly need to for a few weeks. And yes, the shop did fit the seat, handle bars (I forgot to mention I'm new to drop down handle bars as well), etc. I don't have clips, but I do have the foot cages for my toes. I hadn't thought about the knee stress from trying to power along in too high of a gear. I'll definitely change that. My large (for me) ride on Monday was very casual, I sat mostly upright, slowly traveling in a low gear. So, new, hard seat plus upright relaxed position, plus long ride seems to be a perfect recipe for a sore butt. I do feel like I'm getting more used to it already. (better response in a bit, maybe I shouldn't have asked this on such a busy day!)

Barmecide

One thing that took me a while to figure out was http://www.sheldonbrown.com/frame-sizing.html#frontback. There are specific pains associated with an improper fit that are easy, at the beginning, to assume are fitness related. Keep reading and keep adjusting until things feel right. Fenders are the next purchase you should make. Rain will sneak up on you. I've got a set of SKS Raceblade (or something?) that are temporary fenders that work pretty well if your bike doesn't have the proper braze-ons for mounting permanent full fenders.

clockwork

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.