multiple sclerosis treatments and advice
-
Multiple Sclerosis: what tips, tricks, medications, supplements, treatments or therapies are worth trying? My mother was diagnosed with relapsing-remitting MS about 10 years ago; about 5 years ago she was rediagnosed with "secondary progressive" MS, which means that things started getting significantly worse. In the beginning she had trouble with balance, and had some memory/cognitive issues, but on good days was pretty normal. Now she can't walk at all without a cane and/or a strong arm, and generally needs a wheelchair. My sister's boyfriend commented that she seems as if she has alzheimer's (the doctors say these cognitive issues are just specific to the form of MS she has, which is apparently higher on the spinal cord than some forms). Her hands shake too much for her to drink out of cups anymore, and she is often too weak to sit up straight. She is living in london with my grannie & a live-in assistant, & they have (gov't provided) caretakers who make sure the house is clean and that she gets her disability benefits & is able to eat, etc, but they do not provide any medicines or treatments that are actually geared toward improvement. At first I thought this was just because there are no such treatments, but casual conversations and simple googling has shown that most MS patients in the US are fighting the disease, not simply being nursed. Her condition is devastating to me and I am not quite ready to give up, if there is any hope. So, please let me know of any avenues worth exploring or emphasizing. She is not really motivated to improve things herself, probably (at least partly) due to symptoms of the disease itself. Are there any programs or trials you know about that would be worth trying, in the UK or the US? Are there meds that have had a significant impact on anyone you know? My sister will be going along to a doctor's appt in May (we haven't been able to talk with them by phone) but any info or thoughts that will help us determine what might be useful are appreciated. I made http://ask.metafilter.com/mefi/17459#292396 earlier, which is sort of relevant.
-
Answer:
I have multiple sclerosis (thankfully quite mild), and by coincidence just had my annual appointment with my neurologist today. As I understand it, the main drugs prescribed for MS are Avonex, Rebif, Betaseron, and Copaxone. The first three are forms of beta interferon which basically cudgel your immune system. Copaxone is a polymer and they don't really understand how it works. All are injected. All reduce progression of the disease by about 30%. Each has its various plusses and minuses. I've taken Copaxone for about five years, and I'm pretty happy with it, besides the inconvenience of having to do an injection every night. I wish I'd started sooner. Unfortunately, these drugs are less effective for more aggressive forms of the disease. Note that these are not cures, they simply slow the progression. Last I heard, the British health system was still debating whether to pay for them, for that reason. The question was "do they help enough to be worth all that bloody money" or some such. They are expensive, as others have noted. Steroids: yes, these are palliative, but they have downsides. They get you wired and then drop you down when you come off them. I'd stay away unless you are trying to head off a serious exacerbation. Other good drugs: http://www.pdrhealth.com/drug_info/rxdrugprofiles/drugs/pro1544.shtml is tremendous for fatigue. It just makes it go away. It is not speed, it does not give you a buzz or make you happy. It just makes you not be tired. (Note: it's also very good for jet lag and for going two or three days without sleep, but those are off-label applications.) Provigil is about $6/dose (day) I think. I take a tricyclic antidepressant (disipramine) for neuropathy (aka neuropathic pain). That's when degradation of your central nervous system makes you feel things in other parts of your body that aren't there, like tingling and burning and buzzing. There are other drugs that help with it, but it's a bit of a mystery and a crap shoot. Regular pain killers don't do anything. The tricyclics are all generic now, so they are very cheap. I've found pot (aka medical marijuana) to be very helpful when I'm having an exacerbation. It actually can make the neuropathy more intense when I'm under the effects of the drug, but then the after effect is that it gets better. They way I've explained it to myself is that the pot helps my brain form new pathways around the areas that aren't working. As others have pointed out, keeping cool is very important. Heat causes swelling which makes the inflammation worse. There are times when I'm off in zombie land, can't think straight and don't want to try to stand up, and I take a cold shower and boom I'm back on planet earth. Pretty amazing. The last thing I'll say about MS is that for people who are newly diagnosed or who have the progressive form of the disease, it really really sucks. It is totally unpredictable. As soon as you adjust to one level of disability, you get hit with a new exacerbation. But you never know when it's going to come, or if it's going to come. Your body is just changing out from under you all the time. But there are things that can be done, and should be done. Best of luck with this.
mdn at Ask.Metafilter.Com Visit the source
Other answers
http://www.scienceblog.com/cms/node/7617 as adjunctive treatment for the symptomatic relief of neuropathic pain in adults with multiple sclerosis (MS). (http://sploid.com)
poodlemouthe
My partner has MS, and recently took part in a study to examine the effects of heavy duty muscle building work outs on the disease. It seemed to do some good, though I'm not sure of the exact details of the study, and this probably wouldn't help your mother. At the moment she takes Copaxone, which the Australian government covers the majority of the price (we only pay $28.00 per month for daily treatment) and does serious athletic training for 3 hours. Fortunately the progression has been slow.
tomble
MDN: If your mom is experiencing serious symptoms then, yes, I'm surprised she isn't on any palliative medications at all. But there could be things going on in the case that we don't know about and the doctors do. Still, lets look at tremors. Tremor can be disabling but there are various medications that can sometimes help. Tremor is actually one of the more difficult symptoms to treat, but you mentioned it specifically... Any of the following MAY help with the tremors: various strong anti-histamines, propranolol (a beta blocker), primidone (an anti-convulsant), acetazolamide (a diuretic), clonazepam or buspirone (anti-anxietics), and more. If your mom has a serious tremor, she might respond to one of those. Or she might not. I don't think its possible to say in advance. But as I said, my understanding is that serious tremor is a toughie to treat effectively. For other things... there are multiple drugs that can treat many or most symptoms of MS to a greater or (unfortunately) lesser degree. Spasticity, fatigue, dizziness, nystagmus, bladder dysfunction, and many others can be fairly effectively treated. Some people respond much better than others and it's impossible to say in advance who I'm not a doctor and you should really talk to them rather than me. But I hope I'm at least giving you some idea of the type of stuff that is out there. I don't want to give you false expectations though. There are probably drugs that can help with symptoms, but someone who develops MS in their 40's with fairly rapid progression is in a difficult position. I believe only something like 25% of people with MS are eventually confined to a wheelchair and most of those are so confined after 15 or 20 years, not 5. That's about as specific as I feel comfortable being when talking about a particular case. I have read a ton of literature and research journal articles about MS in general, but I am (again) not a doctor and you should talk to them about your particular concerns. But there are definitely questions you should be asking the doctor when you or your sister see him.
Justinian
But these treatments are VERY expensive and without insurance probably prohibitive. Something like $12,000 a year just for the injections. That may be, I am sorry to say, why she never received them. Sorry again, just tring to share info. wow... no, please don't hold back information for fear of offending; I'd certainly much rather have a sense of things and I'm a pretty reasonable/practical type. That does make a lot of sense. Yet you said earlier that if she's not on meds something is wrong - are there less expensive treatments that you'd expect her to be getting? My mother does respond somewhat to cooling treatments, but taking a cold bath isn't something she can do continuously... but those suits look kind of interesting, and the advice about refrigerated bandanas is good. Thanks for all the links above. So, to recap, - steroids can help alleviate symptoms but only briefly and generally only for relapsing/remitting; - interferon treatments definitely slow progression but are extremely expensive; - mitoxantrone can slow progression but might be dangerous for the heart. are there other groups of medications I should be aware of (& the pluses & minuses that come with them)? I know there's no cure, but I want to be aware of as many potential angles as possible.
mdn
http://www.nationalmssociety.org/Research-2005Feb28.asp is instructive about the two deaths in the Tysabri combination trial.
tomierna
In addition to the great information other posters are giving about drug therapies: Some MS patients find that cold can help palliate symptoms. Cold packs, cool baths and showers, and cooling suits are all methods that I know people sometimes find useful. http://www.msaa.com/publications/cooling/contents.htm is a little bit of discussion about cooling and MS. You might want to bring this up as a secondary, supplementary, non-drug therapy option with your mother and her doctor.
redfoxtail
She's in Britain and so presumably covered by NHS, but NHS provides interferons in only a limited trial way AFAICT, and that only recently. She could talk to her physician about getting into the program; it's tentatively approved for secondary progressive.
ROU_Xenophobe
MDN: Steroids are really only pallitave. They generally shorten the duration of relapses in relapsing-remitting MS, which makes the patient more comfortable. But they do not delay disease progression and would not have mattered much in the long term. But if your mother was diagnosed with relapsing-remitting MS, the most effective treatment would have been Avonex or Rebif which are beta interferons. They have been clinically proven to make a difference. I want to be clear that these are NOT a cure. But they do help prevent some relapses and may delay progressive disease. But these treatments are VERY expensive and without insurance probably prohibitive. Something like $12,000 a year just for the injections. That may be, I am sorry to say, why she never received them. Sorry again, just tring to share info.
Justinian
She had had symptoms for at least a few years by then, though... I should say, some people then began retroactively categorizing previous behavior as symptomatic, e.g., my dad started saying, oh yes, I knew something was wrong around the time she turned 30... but it is unclear if this is really based on anything or not (my parents divorced when my mom was about 40). I can't tell, not least because I was just a kid at the time.
mdn
Related Q & A:
- Has anyone read the guide X-Factor Auditions: Tips and Advice? If so what's it like?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- How does Multiple Sclerosis homeostasis in the human body?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What are visible symptoms of Tuberous sclerosis?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Does anyone know the prices for Spa treatments at Spa Aqua in Cancun?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What treatments are for Swine flu?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.