Why does John Maynard Keynes end "The General Theory" with "Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist."?
-
It just seems so odd to me. Why would he attempt to persuade governments to act a certain way and then say that these men are just acting as a slave of a DEFUNCT economist?
-
Answer:
I've always very much liked that quote. It is a full-frontal assault on anti-intellectualism. The key word is "defunct." Keynes certainly did not consider himself a defunct economist. His point is that practical men (politicians, businessmen, whoever) who feel they are above the highfalutin ideas of economists are simply making decisions, whether they are aware of it or not, based on weak economic models that current ("non-defunct") economists would reject. I find it similar to what some behavioral economists say about psychology in economics. It cannot be ignored. Pretending to ignore psychology in economics is just subconsciously endorsing a bad model of human psychology.
Eugene Bialczak at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
Keynes' statement is part of a long tradition, insisting that philosophy influences us, even when we are ignorant of the philosophy. It's easy to write this off as wishful thinking by philosophers (and economists). But read Betty Friedan's The Feminine Mystique to see how abstract, academic ideas spread into other academic areas, into popular culture, and into popular magazines. Freudian ideas of sex roles became part of Margaret Mead's anthropology, part of college courses, part of advice in popular magazines, and finally part of how everyone 'knew' women and men should behave.
Ed Caruthers
Sometimes they are the slaves of long dead Noble prize winners and assumptions of a gaussian distribution of outcomes... Nassim Taleb has done well pointing this out. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Swan_(Taleb_book) Another example: I worked for a pretty good buisness unit manager, who was determined to have the #1 or #2 market share for every line of business. He said that this was because the 1 & 2 players usually made the most money. (which is generally true). He attributed this wisdom to Jack Welch... ( ;-) ) The market share / learning curve / profitability connection was formally developed by Bruce Henderson at Boston Consulting Group (BCG), and popularized by BCG and the people who left BCG and formed Bain. Those ideas had been published about 20 years before, in the 1970s. You would thought these ideas came down on stone tablets with Moses, instead of being theories based on a limited set of observations. If we wait about 5 more years, I expect we will see even John Boyd's strategic insights showing up on Corporate Powerpoints.
Bill McDonald
I don't know what Keynes really meant, but my guess is he was saying that ideas developed by economists do affect the framework of practical decision-making, albeit with a time lag. This may be through directly influencing their thinking, or indirectly, by affecting the option set within which they have to make choices. The mechanism of this propagation may be so indirect that the practical folk don't have a clue about it. One might interpret this as a clarion call to economists to understand the long term impact their ideas might have, and hence be more careful about the theories they spread. Anti-Keynesians might note the irony of the quote: practical people in politics, business, and the media in the 21st century continue to be deeply influenced by Keynesianism, the ideas of the defunct economist Keynes.
Vipul Naik
Related Q & A:
- Why my LAUNCHcast plug in is quite?
- How exactly did Leonardo Da Vinci influence art in general?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why is Yahoo messenger quite wrong with the weather plug-in?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- Why are people who get their coffee from STARBUCKS usually better looking than those who go to DUNKIN DONUTS?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What skills are usually required to be a front end developer?Best solution by Quora
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.