Which Is Best Search?

In which types of search does Google most clearly fail? And what avenues and sites address these issues best or most promisingly?

  • A failed search is hereby understood to mean a search which does not produce a relevant link on the first page. In other words: in which types of searches does Google simply not help? What are examples of other approaches (like social search) that try to address this issue? How successful are these solutions and which type of searches leaves this still unaddressed?

  • Answer:

    has given some good examples of fairly weird queries which are intrinsically hard for search engines. I think there are lots of natural kinds of searches for which Google isn't that useful (or at least much less so than it usually is). For example: Research for purchase decisions Finding things to do (when you're not sure what you want to do) Finding a non-famous person with a common name Finding out what's going on right now Finding a comprehensive list of just about anything (unless there is a web page with the list on it) Finding scientific information at a deeper level than Wikipedia

Michael Hochster at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Lyrics.  Search for the lyrics to a popular song, and you get a bunch of crap.  Lyrics sites are almost all awful.  You get a bunch of pages all with the same text buried in a bunch of obnoxious ads.  Google should just put its best guess right on the search results page.  It would likely be at least as good as what's on the top search result now.

Coleman Foley

A query where Google clearly fails: http://www.google.com/search?q=!!! (should be 3 x !) Answer should include: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/!!! (should be 3 x !)

Sérgio Nunes

Google is still bad with types of queries found on Quora or other Q&A or discussion board type questions.

Roshan Joshi

Google fails miserably on Bible references requests. This is why I created Biible : http://www.biible.info which enables you to find who has commented any bible passage.

Raymond Balmès

Follow up to my original question: All answers to my question here are very relevant and interesting. They address failures of Google for which Google was not designed for originally. Clearly, Google fails in understanding human language questions and possible solutions are highly interesting from an AI point of view. However, I would like to clarify the intention of my question. What I was mostly aiming at is where traditional search has failed where it is supposed to work and how we could address this. I.e. if I want to learn about a specific topic or a keyword without knowing what to exactly look for (e.g. in an area where I am not knowledgeable), Google will return a myriad of "matching" results but in no order of relevance that will help me to get the bigger picture. Without knowing how to navigate a topic broadly, I am literally lost in millions of links.

Vincent Daranyi

I've found when doing searches on some variables and programming issues Google has been horrible. As an example, I'm searching for further information on a variable called $variable_name for ProgramX. When I do an exact search for Program X "$variable_name" it rarely gives me correct information and will send back information on pages for 'variable name' instead.  I've found that Bing has been much better at returning proper pages for this type of information.

Bruce Rick

Finding lists of domain names is terribly hard. Google does not want to rank pages with huge size - and this is precisely what I need for these queries. The most useful result has literally been last (25th out of 25 results for example).

Kalin Karakehayov

Google also continues to fail in providing real product reviews to searchers, since product reviews are a major area for content farm scamming.

Deborah Lipp

For me, the biggest weakness of Google search is the absence of qualitative results. Asking "Who are the best poets in Ireland?,"  "What is the most important book of philosophy?" "What is the best blog on surfing?" all return links to other sources, some helpful some not. I'd like the ability to get a ranked list of results from such qualitative queries, even if they are subjective. It's better than nothing.

Zachary Davis

Related Q & A:

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.