Which magazine is better: Elle or Vogue?

What should I major in if I want to end up writing for a magazine like Elle, Harpars Bazaar, or Vogue?

  • I'm going to be a college freshman next year, and I was planning on majoring in journalism and marketing. However, I don't know if I should consider majoring in something else if I want to end up writing for magazines of that specific caliber. And yes, I do realize journalism is dying, no need to remind me :)

  • Answer:

    Communications, Strategic Comm/Advertising, Marketing, Journalism (geared toward Magazine or Feature Writing), Digital Media. Go to your classes, pay attention, establish a killer GPA the first semester or 2 & ride it out the rest of your syllabuses (syllabi..?) until graduation time & hope things are better for your economically than they were for me (Mizzou Journ grad BA in Magazine Journalism '09) In all seriousness & sincerity, the best thing you can do is start blogging. Every day. About stuff you like. Products that you maybe can't afford but admire. Don't just self-promote & talk about your life. Be funny. Be yourself. Write every time you get a chance. If you have an aha moment during the day that would be worth blogging about because it's either amusing, exciting, awkward, lovely, frustrating, chic, fugly, write it down in your Moleskin or whatever trendy overpriced notebooks are hot right now. Or put it in your phone's notepad for later. Blog about anything but if you're really passionate about the glossy gilded world of fashion mags, it will write itself. Start early & engage with your followers. Launch a Tumblr. Then use an app like Overgram to design a quick cute Instragram post directly people to your site. Tag acccordingly (#instafashion, #instastyle, #swag, #designer #bags #fashionblogs #fashion #shoes....anything relevant you plan on blogging about). Cast your hashtag net & cast it wide. Don't just reblog other user's #ootd posts. Provide real life recommendations & add value to an audience. Create a community & connect people through your blog. It's an excellent creative outlet & can garner you years of opportunity if you get started now (provided you can write well & connect to your readers so they keep coming back, maybe even bookmark you) Be honest. Be realistic. Sure we all love oogling over luxury handbags boasting a price tag comparable to the cost of braces for a family of 5 so post some really amazing bagporn every now & then but also change it up with DIY posts. Do your research. What kind of little beauty tips & hacks aren't well-known amongst your peers? Pinterest is an excellent resource for stuff like this. Did you know that conditioner is 1000 better than any dedicated Schick shaving cream for silky smooth legs? Baking soda added to your shampoo once a week clarifies yours hair garnering some of the fluffiest, bounciest locks I've seen in years. See? This is what girls want to know. How to cut costs in this area so they can then buy something in another area :) The fashion industry is all smoke & mirrors. You would never guess that the Elle Magazine offices in New York located right at 50th & Broadway had mildewy carpet, off-white walls completely worsened by dirty beige cubicle dividers, bathrooms that were worse aesthetically than my public high school's & the intern computers did not even boast flat screen monitors (this was 2008 I'm talking about & I was working as an editorial intern for the .COM department). Think dingy Compaq Presario desktop computers (like the ones you used to run Encarta 99 off of for your homework assignments) a la Montgomery Ward 12 inches tall & 20 inches back. Our revered "beauty" editor had terrible taste & even worse adult acne. You can only fake it til you make it for so long & print pubs like the ones you're mentioning is all about facades & living outside of your means. Approach your new editorial ventures in a fresh, revamped way & be honest in your posts. Look at fashion blogs. Peruse them. Scour them. Find the ones that are doing more than just posting pretty things that were pulled down from ThisIsGlamourous or something equally anticlimactic & invaluable. ManRepeller  is one of my favorites. She is an industry vet, she's terribly uncouth, wears the oddest combinations in the iffiest trends of the current moment but she is magnetic & accessible & people flock to read her every day. She doesn't care what's coming down the runway because no one care afford a $17,000 trench for Resort 2014. Yes it's the trickledown effect so we'll find a similar-looking trench in our neighborhood Forever21 6 months from now & then it will start to deteriorate because it's crap quality. This is now the direction to head. Blog about your experiences, how your clothes, your shopping behavior, your online product obsessions, beauty swag you definitely don't need but want nonetheless because http://Sephora.com just has that effect on us ladies & gentleladies.  I interned for FREE for over 500+ hours with Elle.com & Ellegirl.com & it literally went nowhere. I should have been considered immediately after graduation for an E.A. or Fashion Assistant position because I went through the necessary hoops but the fashion industry doesn't follow rules. It's political, it's unfair, it's over-the-top & hard-working, straight-laced girls frequently finish last because they didn't know this connection to the Senior Editor from shared Connecticut upbringings, bullshit, bullshit, bullshit.  Start a blog. Tweak it as you go along. If you're serious about writing, write every day. It's a skill that must be practiced in order to become better. Don't be afraid to self-promote your posts on your FBook, IG, Twitter, Google+,  LinkedIn, Pinterest, wherever & drive traffic to your blog through your existing connections. Once you start delivering good content out a sheer organic place via your authentic affinity for fashion, the rest will follow. Your friends & followers will share it & so on & so forth. You'll actually find yourself doing what you love, building an audience to then have influence in the fashion blogger space while also marketing via content (aka content marketing which is the future of online advertising). You're in an awesome place right now with so much opportunity a WiFi connection away. Good luck & feel free to message me for any help getting in the door with the right people :) I have a rolodex that someone should be taking advantage of! Read some of my current & former postings & musings here: http://amberintheapple.blogspot.com/ http://maddox-madison.tumblr.com/

Amber Fehrenbacher at Quora Visit the source

Was this solution helpful to you?

Other answers

Don't be silly.  Journalism is not dying.  It is simply evolving.  The variety of media available for journalists has grown tremendously and presents so many different avenues through which one can choose to communicate.   If your focus is on working for a top fashion magazine then a degree in fashion journalism may make sensee.  Remember that journalism is not limited to text these days though.  Many of us get our news online and video has become a very popular way of sharing news.  Videography would also be a complimentary focus.   Photography is another critical facet of journalism.  Photos and text go hand in hand when telling a story.    Burke is right.  Immersion is crucial.  Get to know the industry inside and out.  If you can write on different topics from an experienced perspective you will be much better off.    From experience I can tell you that this school has an amazing fashion program and they happen to offer Fashion Journalism as a focus.    http://www.academyart.edu/fashion-school/index.html   Best of luck!

Jessica Van Sickle

Become a polymath in the subject.   Fashion is not going to die, nor will the coverage of the industry.  Learn to design, learn: how make items, how to model , how put on productions,  photography, videography, and even a bit of acting. Write about all of it and have a few very critical editors and coaches to help you rip up your work and do it again and again. Volunteer your time with a local paper or blog to learn about what they want and - eeech deadlines!   Being an aesthete is one thing, sharing your passion is another.  You are looking to become a go between and an educator and writing is just one medium of communication - you will need to learn others.   There is no one degree I could suggest other than English Composition, but there is so much more, so very much more - that all looks like a great deal of work and fun.

L. Burke Files

It really doesn't matter you just have to know the fashion world inside and out and be well-spoken, hard-working, and confident. Check out http://twentiescollective.com - I worked at Harper's briefly.

Jessica Schiffer

Just Added Q & A:

Find solution

For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.

  • Got an issue and looking for advice?

  • Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.

  • Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.

Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.