What are the job prospects for an engineer with a PhD?
-
It is often rumored that PhDs have a hard time finding a job outside of academia. What truth is there in these rumors?
-
Answer:
It depends on what field you're talking about. I'd say in general yes, you're going to have a bias against you in the beginning. Many employers will automatically assume you'll become easily bored with typical design work (which is probably the case). Also, as a PhD, you're going to command a much higher salary. If you're straight out of school, employers will be reluctant to shell out that much money on an unproven asset. If you're not interested in academia, your best bet is to look for R&D positions at larger companies or design and development roles at start-ups. It's been my experience that, for some reason, mid-size companies either have no use for or mis-manage PhDs. On the plus side, once you have a few years experience you're generally more employable and people will generally assume (rightly or wrongly) you're extremely technically competent. On the negative side, many people will also assume that all you want to do is crunch numbers and run experiments all day, not necessarily interact with customers or work on things like business development. If you're asking this as someone considering pursuing a PhD, I'd urge you to carefully consider what you want out of your career. If you want to pursue challenging and complex technical problems, are willing to face an initially very tough job search and want to spend most of your life solving engineering problems, it's the right choice. However, if you're interested in less technical problems, are more of a people person or want to move quickly up the management career path, I'd recommend against it. If you want to be a manager, no degree trumps real world experience.
Benjamin Steinhaus at Quora Visit the source
Other answers
It all depends on the research topic of the Ph.D. graduate. For Ph.D.s in electronic design automation, integrated circuit design, and computer architecture, Ph.D.s are required or strongly preferred. Yes, the job opportunities are small, since the number of companies that can do these are small. However, the supply of Ph.D.s in these fields are also small, so Ph.D.s in these fields are highly valued. For Ph.D.s in civil engineering, they may have a harder time. Ultimately, can the Ph.D. graduate enter an industry that has corporate research labs or is doing R&D that favors/requires Ph.D.s? If not, can the Ph.D. graduate switch to a new field/topic that exploits her/his skill set and help high-tech companies make money? A couple of examples: Microsoft Research hires Physics Ph.D.s. Who would have thought that statistical mechanics is so relevant to complex systems, including social networks, and computational complexity (e.g., the category of NP-complete problems)? Likewise, Yahoo! Research hired a physics Ph.D. (Dr. Duncan Watts) to look at social networks. MIT has a professor (can't remember her name right now) who did her physics Ph.D. in Germany (or somewhere in Europe), a postdoc at the legendary research lab of Prof. Albert-Laszlo Barabasi, and is now a civil engineering professor at MIT; she is from Latin America. So, yes, Ph.D.s do have good opportunities. They just have to be aware of the markets that require their expertise or create new markets for the world.
Pasquale Ferrara
In some very specific areas, there is no truth at all to those rumors, especially if you come from a reputable school and have a reputable advisor. It's a low supply, high demand (and high wage) situation for those areas. I studied computer microarchitecture and compilers while pursuing my PhD, with a focus on performance. Finance companies pay dearly for expertise, with some friends making well over $500k annually (mostly bonuses, and I can't speak for bad years). I have also seen recruiters still reaching out even when their companies have a general hiring freeze. What surprised me is that even some VCs made note of PhDs, so it can be helpful in the start-up world. I have also noticed that employers will hire high quality PhDs when the problem they're facing is very open ended and has no prescribed solution, since this mirrors the PhD experience.
Shane Ryoo
It depends on the type of engineering, but in general, there are plenty of jobs for engineers with a Ph.D. outside of academia.
Konstantinos Konstantinides
I was recently at a conference where a panel was discussing about the future prospects of PhD. You have heard it right, PhDs have a hard time finding a job outside of academia (or even in academia!), but that's because the expectation of someone with a "Dr." title is that he/she will be absorbed as soon as the PhD is over. Most of the times, candidates don't know how to search for the right job, how to brand themselves. Its a common saying "Don't oversell your PhD card". People won't hire you because you have a PhD, they will hire you if they see the right potential in you. An example to illustrate my point: Suppose you are a recruiter of a big company and you need someone to work in your R&D section. Whom will you prefer, someone with a Bachelors who is yet to figure out what he/she wants in life, or a dedicated researcher, who knows how to get the job done? There are no points for guessing the answer! It can be tough to get a job, because there may not be the right opening. But once you find it, its worth it!
Harsh Beria
In India, The scenario is totally different.Better to settle down for a Good Government Job, Rather than wasting your precious young life in books. Because the output of PhD (Except IIT's/IISc) is a waste.
Harish Kumar Nirala
At least in Electrical engineering, I can safely say that this is not the case. PhDs are highly valued in top companies.
Vishal Agarwal
Related Q & A:
- What kind of job will I have to do as a computer engineer?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- After LLM, what are job prospects?Best solution by Quora
- What are the job opportunities for a computer engineer?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
- What are the job scopes in Canada for a civil engineer? Will I get the job easily?Best solution by ask.shiksha.com
- Once I have a PhD, is it easy to find a professor job?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
Just Added Q & A:
- How many active mobile subscribers are there in China?Best solution by Quora
- How to find the right vacation?Best solution by bookit.com
- How To Make Your Own Primer?Best solution by thekrazycouponlady.com
- How do you get the domain & range?Best solution by ChaCha
- How do you open pop up blockers?Best solution by Yahoo! Answers
For every problem there is a solution! Proved by Solucija.
-
Got an issue and looking for advice?
-
Ask Solucija to search every corner of the Web for help.
-
Get workable solutions and helpful tips in a moment.
Just ask Solucija about an issue you face and immediately get a list of ready solutions, answers and tips from other Internet users. We always provide the most suitable and complete answer to your question at the top, along with a few good alternatives below.